Word Document PDF Document

STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER, Governor

PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION

505 VAN NESS AVENUE

SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94102-3298

TO: All Interested Parties in Del Oro Water Company's Advice Letter No. 241-C

Enclosed is draft Resolution No. W-4804 of the Division of Water and Audits. It will be on the Commission's November 20, 2009 agenda. The Commission may then act on this Resolution or it may postpone action until later.

When the Commission acts on the draft resolution, it may adopt all or part of it as written, amend or modify it, or set it aside and prepare a different resolution. Only when the Commission acts does the resolution become binding on the parties.

Parties to this matter may file comments on this draft resolution. An original and 2 copies of the comments, with a certificate of service, should be submitted to:

    Division of Water and Audits, Third Floor

            Attention: Martin Bragen

    California Public Utilities Commission

    505 Van Ness Avenue

    San Francisco, CA 94102

Parties may submit comments on or before November 10, 2009. The date of submission is the date the comments are received by the Division of Water and Audits. Parties must serve a copy of their comments on all persons on the service list attached to the draft Resolution, on the same date that the comments are submitted to the Division of Water and Audits.

Comments shall be limited to five pages in length plus a subject index listing the recommended changes to the draft resolution, a table of authorities and appendix setting forth the proposed findings and ordering paragraphs. Reply comments are due on November 16, 2009 and shall not exceed five pages in length.

Comments shall focus on factual, legal, or technical errors in the draft resolution and shall make specific reference to the record or applicable law. Comments which fail to do so will be accorded no weight and are not to be submitted.

/s/ RAMI KAHLON

Rami Kahlon, Director

Division of Water and Audits

Enclosures: Draft Resolution No. W-4804

Certificate of Service

Service List

WATER/ JB5/MRB

PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

DIVISION OF WATER AND AUDITS RESOLUTION NO. W-4804

Water and Sewer Advisory Branch November 20, 2009

RESOLUTION

(RES. W-4804), THIS RESOLUTION APPROVES DEL ORO WATER COMPANY'S (DOWC) ADVICE LETTER (AL) 241-C AND ADOPTS TARIFF SCHEDULE 14.1-RI, AS MODIFIED.

SUMMARY

This Resolution approves DOWC AL 241-C and adopts Tariff Schedule 14.1-RI as modified. This AL was filed pursuant to Standard Practice U-40-W1 and includes a request to establish Tariff Schedule 14.1 (Schedule 14.1) 2 to provide for mandatory rationing for its River Island district in times of water shortage if voluntary measures do not yield the necessary reduction in consumption. The utility will track available water supplies, compare them to historical demand, and determine what overall reduction in consumption is required. Based on these calculations, the utility then creates individualized allocations for each of its customers. Under Schedule 14.1, DOWC must track the following in a memorandum account: (1) volumetric penalties from its customers for consumption over their allocations generated from Schedule 14.1; (2) its incremental operating expenses incurred after the date Schedule 14.1 is activated;3
(3) any penalties paid to its water wholesalers, if any; (4) any additional income in the form of penalties paid by customers for violating water use restrictions; and (5) any additional income in the form of flow restrictor installation and removal charges.4

BACKGROUND

DOWC, a California corporation, is a Class B utility serving approximately 7,791 connections in 14 districts throughout the state. The River Island district has 336 connections in two physically separate systems, served from 14 wells providing potable water. Additional potable water is purchased from two privately-owned wells. Non-potable irrigation water is supplied to 15 customers who are also connected to one of the potable-water systems.

Almost every summer River Island runs short of water as well production drops and water use increases. During July, 2009, production from the 14 active wells was inadequate to meet demand on a sustained basis. On August 14, 2009, DOWC held a public meeting and declared a Water Shortage Emergency, in accordance with Water Code Sections 350 - 352.

DOWC has filed AL 241-C to adopt Tariff Schedule 14.1-RI, allowing the company to implement mandatory rationing measures between June 1 and October 31 of a particular year, or other times if necessary, through a Tier 1 advice letter. Measures include penalties for water use in excess of allocations, penalties for non-essential water use, and flow restrictor installation and removal charges when other measures do not bring compliance.

DOWC has filed AL 242-B concurrently with 241-C. AL 242-B seeks authority to establish two memorandum accounts; one to track the lost revenues and cost savings due to reduced water sales upon implementation of Schedule 14.1-RI; and one to track water use violation penalties collected from customers, water use penalties imposed by and paid to water wholesalers, if any; and the administrative and operating costs incurred by implementing Schedule 14.1-RI.

DOWC has also filed Application 09-08-016 requesting a new connection moratorium for its River Island district, to be maintained until such time as the company is assured of adequate water year-round.

NOTICE AND PROTESTS

DOWC gave public notice of the Schedule 14.1 Staged Mandatory Water Conservation and Rationing for River Island, of the proposed connection moratorium, and of the time and location for a public meeting with the CPUC. A legal advertisement was also placed in a local newspaper in advance of the meeting. The public meeting informed customers about the water shortage, the impact of the proposed conservation and plan on customers, and the effect of the proposed connection moratorium. An outline was provided of DOWC's Rule and Schedule 14.1 filing, including information about how customers can contact the Commission with comments and the proposed process for filing for an exception to a customer's historical allotments.

To help customers conserve water, DOWC provided indoor and outdoor water efficiency tips and resources for more water conservation information. The utility also made available free water conservation kits and information on available hardware.

A question and answer session followed DOWC's presentation.

DISCUSSION

DOWC's River Island district draws potable water from 14 functioning wells and purchases potable water from two privately owned wells. They also draw untreated irrigation water from one well. Last year they sold about 13,000,000 cubic feet of potable water and 500,000 cubic feet of untreated water.

For several years, before purchase by Del Oro, River Island has run short of water in the summer and has asked customers to voluntarily conserve water. This has resulted in some reduction in use, but customers still had inadequate supplies in June, July and August. On August 14, 2009, DOWC held a public meeting with its customers and declared a Water Shortage Emergency, in accordance with Water Code Sections 350 - 352.

The Water Code states:

"353: When the governing body has so determined and declared the existence of an emergency condition of water shortage within its service area, it shall thereupon adopt such regulations and restrictions on the delivery of water and the consumption within said area of water supplied for public use as will in the sound discretion of such governing body conserve the water supply for the greatest public benefit with particular regard to domestic use, sanitation, and fire protection."

Tariff Rule 14.1-RI has been designed to conserve the water supply for the greatest public benefit. It provides a minimum level of consumption for customers below which they need not reduce their usage.

The tariff provides increasing penalties for excess use of water. Customers using up to 15% over their allocation will be charged a penalty of 1-1/2 times the normal rate for the excess water used. Customers using more than 15% over their allocation will be charged a penalty of twice the normal rate for the excess water used. These penalties will be in addition to the normal quantity cost for water used.

The tariff also provides penalties for wasteful use of water, such as: irrigation with potable water between 10:00 AM and 6:00 PM; use of water resulting in flooding or runoff in gutters or streets; washing of cars with a hose except with the use of a positive action shut-of nozzle; or using a broken or defective sprinkler, watering or irrigation system after being notified to repair it. Penalties increase with repeated violations.

The tariff lists charges for installation or removal of a flow restrictor. Flow restrictors will be installed if financial penalties do not result in conservation.

PUBLIC MEETING

A notice of the proposed Rule 14.1 and public meeting was mailed to customers on September 25, 2009, and published in the Porterville Recorder on September 28, 2009. A public meeting was held on October 13, 2009 at the River Island Country Club. DOWC explained Schedule 14.1-RI, the need for mandatory rationing during water shortages, and the penalties associated with excess use or wasteful use of water. The company said required reductions would be based on 2008 consumption. They said customers using less than 1,000 cubic feet per month would not be penalized regardless of 2008 usage. They explained the use of the Exception Form to request a larger allocation.

DOWC noted that the copy of Tariff Schedule 14.1-RI circulated with the Notice of Public Meeting says subdividers who have contributed wells as a condition of being connected to the system would be exempted from excess use penalties. The tariff schedule has been corrected to eliminate that statement. Those who have contributed wells as a condition of service would be exempt from a service connection moratorium, to the number of lots those wells could supply with potable water; but no customer will be exempted from mandatory conservation and rationing.

Customers were concerned with the use of 2008 as a base year on which to calculate proposed reductions; some had already reduced their usage significantly, and felt they could not cut their usage much more without hardship. They proposed a several-year average as a fairer basis for reduction. Del Oro has agreed to use 5-year consumption records to create a base period for rationing.

One customer using agricultural water objected to rationing because the water from that well was not potable. The company explained that usage of the agricultural well reduced the potable water available.

COMMENTS

Public Utilities Code Section 311(g) (1) provides that resolutions must generally be served on all parties and subject to at least 30 days public review and comment prior to a vote of the Commission. Accordingly, on October 21, 2009, the draft resolution was mailed to the parties on the service list. Comments were filed on , and reply comments were filed on .

FINDINGS AND CONCLUSIONS

1. Del Oro Water Company filed Advice Letter No. 241-C for its River Island Service Area on October 7, 2009 requesting approval of Tariff Schedule 14.1-RI.

2. Tariff Schedule 14.1-RI calls for rationing between June 1 and October 31 of a year when it is activated.

3. Tariff Schedule 14.1-RI calls for activation of rationing by Tier 1 Advice Letter.

4. A request for activation or a change in a rationing stage should be based upon changes mandated from a governing agency or a reduced availability of water from the utility's own supplies.

5. Activations of rationing stages in a Schedule 14.1 are time-sensitive decisions whose review and approval can be done by staff on a ministerial basis.

6. Under Commission Rule 96-B, Tier 1 advice letter filings are effective immediately upon filing by the utility, subject to disposition (acceptance or rejection) by CPUC staff.

7. Del Oro Water Company should file new Tier 1 advice letters to activate Tariff Schedule 14.-RI to reflect the effect of reduced total available water supplies (both purchases and Del Oro Water Company's own pumped water), compared with customer usage demand adjusted for (i) conservation programs and (ii) adjustments to individual customer allotments due to appeals.

8. All necessary documentation should be included in Del Oro's Tier 1 filings to allow staff determination as to whether the proposed reductions are consistent with the above requirement.

9. Del Oro Water Company's rationing allocation methodology for its customers will be based on 5 years of historic water usage.

10. Del Oro Water Company's water use violation penalties for its customers is based on a billing period allocation.

11. A memorandum account, such as the Mandatory Conservation Rationing Implementation Memorandum Account (MCRIMARI) should be used to accumulate all expenses necessary to implement Rule 14.1 and Schedule 14.1-RI that have not been considered in a General Rate Case or other proceeding, as well as water use violation fees collected and penalties paid by DOWC to wholesalers, if any.

12. The debit or credit amount in the MCRIMARI account should be disposed of as directed or authorized from time to time by the Commission.

THEREFORE IT IS ORDERED THAT:

1. Del Oro Water Company is authorized to file an advice letter to establish the tariff Schedule 14.1-RI, as modified in Appendix A.

2. Del Oro Water Company shall monitor water consumption and available water supplies for its River Island district to determine water supply shortages.

3. Tariff Schedule 14.1-RI shall be activated by Tier 1 Advice letter when a water supply shortage first occurs.

4. The advice letter activating Schedule 14.1-RI shall set water use allocations.

5. Changes in rationing levels and water use allocations shall be activated by Tier 1 advice letters as water supplies and demands change.

6. De-activation of tariff Schedule 14.1-RI shall be done by Tier 1 advice letter when rationing is no longer needed.

7. This resolution is effective today.

I certify that the foregoing resolution was duly introduced, passed, and adopted at a conference of the Public Utilities Commission of the State of California held on November 20, 2009; the following Commissioners voting favorably thereon:

APPENDIX A, Page 1

Schedule No. 14.1-RI

STAGED MANDATORY WATER CONSERVATION AND RATIONING

River Island District

(continued)

APPENDIX A, Page 2

Schedule No. 14.1-RI

(Continued)

STAGED MANDATORY WATER CONSERVATION AND RATIONING

River Island District

(continued)

APPENDIX A, Page 3

Schedule No. 14.1-RI

(Continued)

STAGED MANDATORY WATER CONSERVATION AND RATIONING

River Island District

(continued)

APPENDIX A, Page 4

Schedule No. 14.1-RI

(Continued)

STAGED MANDATORY WATER CONSERVATION AND RATIONING

River Island District

(continued)

APPENDIX A, Page 5

Schedule No. 14.1-RI

(Continued)

STAGED MANDATORY WATER CONSERVATION AND RATIONING

River Island District

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I certify that I have by mail this day served a true copy of Draft Resolution No. W-4804 on all parties in this filing or their attorneys as shown on the attached list.

Dated October 21, 2009, at San Francisco, California.

NOTICE

Parties should notify the Division of Water and Audits, Third Floor, California Public Utilities Commission, 505 Van Ness Avenue, San Francisco, CA 94102, of any change of address to ensure that they continue to receive documents. You must indicate the Resolution number on which your name appears.

SERVICE LIST

DRAFT RESOLUTION No. W-4804

Page 1 of 2

    Gary and Susan Carlson

    16252 Wrangler Drive

    Springville, CA 93265

 

    Bill and Rose Jones

    31789 Mill Drive

    Springville, CA 93265

 

    Norm Smith

    32226 River Island Drive

    Springville, CA 93265

    Jack Gregg

    32746 Greene Drive

    Springville, CA 93265

 

    Del and Nancy Pengilly

    31576 Avenue 176

    Springville, CA 93265

 

    Virgil and Alice Christianson

    31756 Mill Drive

    Springville, CA 93265

    Loren and Karen Marks

    16604 Goat Ranch Road

    Springville, CA 93265

 

    Stan Gilletto

    32600 Irish Lane

    Springville, CA 93265

 

    Guy Huffaker

    32765 Riverside Drive

    Springville, CA 93265

    Dan Pastre

    32405 Pleasant Oak Drive

    Springville, CA 93265

 

    Jean Louis and Yolande Condamine

    32265 Pleasant Oak Drive

    Springville, CA 93265

 

    Tony Weber

    16973 Coyote Drive

    Springville, CA 93265

    Mickey and Doreen Gambrell

    16497 Wardlaw Drive

    Springville, CA 93265

 

    Jay and Louise Warnke

    32235 Fairway Drive

    Springville, CA 93265

 

    Bill Graves

    32233 Fairway Drive

    Springville, CA93265

    Joseph and Deborah Wood

    32237 River Island Drive

    Springville, CA 93265

 

    Loyd Lucas

    33617 Globe Drive

    Springville, CA 93265

 

    John Millwee

    31710 Mill Drive

    Springville, Ca 93265

    Ann Konda

    32815 Riverside Drive

    Springville, CA 93265

 

    Dick Eckhoff

    33352 Globe Drive

    Springville, CA 93265

 

    Roger Kroeber

    33730 Bear Lane

    Springville, CA 93265

SERVICE LIST

DRAFT RESOLUTION No. W-4804

Page 2 of 2

    David Berg

    P.O. Box 1100

    Springville, CA 93265

 

    Ralph and Jeanne Preall

    32011 Pleasant Oaks Drive

    Springville, CA 93265

 

    Neale and Mary Louise Brown

    32791 Riverside Drive

    Springville, CA 93265

    Fred and Deanna Piazza

    32409 Pleasant Oaks Drive

    Springville, CA 93265

 

    Scott Mann

    31620 Avenue 176 #A

    Springville, CA 93265

 

    Paul and Beverly Hillman

    33725 Globe Drive

    Springville, CA 93265

    Wayne and Judy Millies

    31794 Mill Drive

    Springville, CA 93265

 

    Dough and Joy Harvey

    32398 River Island Drive

    Springville, CA 93265

 

    Gary Johnson

    32600 Greene Drive

    Springville, CA 93265

    Eugene Estes

    32779 Riverside Drive

    Springville, CA 93265

 

    Gerald H. Johns

    33158 Globe Drive

    Springville, CA 93265

 

    Jeff Friedman

    32914 Highway 190

    Springville, CA 93265

    Jay Eaton

    16017 Cattle Drive

    Springville, CA 93265

 

    Larry and Ida Herrera

    1233 North Lindale Way

    Porterville, CA 93267

 

    Janice Hanna

    Director

    Del Oro Water Company

    Drawer 5172

    Chico, CA 95927

    Robert S. Fortino

    CEO

    Del Oro Water Company

    Drawer 5172

    Chico, CA 95927

       

1 SP 40 outlines the general procedure for utilities to request and implement water conservation and rationing, by way of Tariff Rule 14.1 and Schedule 14.1, and service connection moratoria. Rule 14.1 is implemented in response to a utility's request for voluntary rationing from customers in order to reduce consumption. This may be accomplished by voluntary compliance with water use restrictions.

2 Schedule 14.1 is activated in response to a governing agency or a water wholesaler declaring a water shortage and imposing mandatory rationing on a utility, or other reductions in the available water supply that may result in the utility's reduction of customer water allocations based on a percentage of the customer's historical usage.

3 Schedule 14.1 provides for a series of progressively restrictive water allocations (stages) to the utilities' customers corresponding to decreasing levels of available water supply. Schedule 14.1 is first activated when mandatory water use allocations, rather than voluntary conservation measures, are necessary. DOWC files for initial activation of Schedule 14.1 as well as more restrictive stages by filing a Tier 1 AL stating a specific need for decreased water allocations to its customers.

4 Water use restrictions prohibit non-essential or unauthorized water usage by customers for such things as washing hard-surfaced areas which results in excess run-off and outside watering of vegetation with potable water during certain hours. Fines start at $25 per instance with activation of Schedule 14.1 and increase incrementally by another $25 with each additional offense. Flow restrictors may be installed when other penalties do not bring compliance.

Top Of Page