As set forth below, we award TURN $233,525.51:
Attorney/Staff Work on D.06-02-032 (R.04-04-003) | ||||
Attorney/Staff |
Year |
Hours |
Hourly Rate |
Total |
Michel P. Florio |
2005 |
2.50 |
$470 |
$1,175.00 |
Michel P. Florio |
2006 |
0.75 |
$485 |
$363.75 |
Robert Finkelstein |
2005 |
2.50 |
$395 |
$987.50 |
Marcel Hawiger |
2005 |
.75 |
$270 |
$202.50 |
Marcel Hawiger |
2006 |
3.00 |
$280 |
$840.00 |
Matthew Freedman |
2005 |
7.50 |
$270 |
$2,025.00 |
Matthew Freedman |
2006 |
10.75 |
$280 |
$3,010.00 |
Hayley Goodson |
2004 |
.25 |
$190 |
$47.50 |
Hayley Goodson |
2005 |
39.00 |
$190 |
$7,410.00 |
Hayley Goodson |
2006 |
3.50 |
$195 |
$682.50 |
Nina Suetake |
2005 |
44.00 |
$190 |
$8,360.00 |
William Marcus |
2005 |
1.33 |
$210 |
$279.30 |
William Steinhurst |
2005 |
17.75 |
$175 |
$3,106.25 |
Bruce Biewald |
2005 |
4.50 |
$180 |
$810.00 |
Cynthia Mitchell |
2004 |
1.00 |
$115 |
$115.00 |
Cynthia Mitchell |
2005 |
64.50 |
$140 |
$9,030.00 |
Subtotal |
203.58 |
$38,444.30 |
Attorney/Staff Work on D.05-12-022 (R.04-04-003) | ||||
Attorney/Staff |
Year |
Hours |
Hourly Rate |
Total |
Michel P. Florio |
2005 |
8.25 |
$470 |
$3,877.50 |
Robert Finkelstein |
2005 |
.50 |
$395 |
$197.50 |
Subtotal |
8.75 |
$4,075.00 |
Attorney/Staff Work on D.06-07-032 (R.04-04-003) | ||||
Attorney/Staff |
Year |
Hours |
Hourly Rate |
Total |
Michel P. Florio |
2006 |
5.75 |
$485 |
$2,788.75 |
Matthew Freedman |
2006 |
1.75 |
$280 |
$490.00 |
Subtotal |
7.50 |
$3,278.75 |
Attorney/Staff Work on D.07-09-040 (R.04-04-003) | ||||
Attorney/Staff |
Year |
Hours |
Hourly Rate |
Total |
Michel P. Florio |
2004 |
5.75 |
$470 |
$2,702.50 |
Michel P. Florio |
2005 |
76.50 |
$470 |
$35,955.00 |
Michel P. Florio |
2006 |
52.50 |
$485 |
$25,462.50 |
Michel P. Florio |
2007 |
43.25 |
$520 |
$22,490.00 |
Robert Finkelstein |
2005 |
.25 |
$395 |
$98.75 |
Matthew Freedman |
2004 |
7.50 |
$270 |
$2,025.00 |
Matthew Freedman |
2006 |
3.75 |
$280 |
$1,050.00 |
Hayley Goodson |
2006 |
1.25 |
$195 |
$243.75 |
William Marcus |
2004 |
4.33 |
$195 |
$844.35 |
William Marcus |
2005 |
25.17 |
$210 |
$5,285.70 |
William Marcus |
2006 |
8.50 |
$220 |
$1,870.00 |
William Marcus |
2007 |
1.17 |
$235 |
$274.95 |
Greg Ruszovan |
2005 |
13.05 |
$155 |
$2,022.75 |
Kevin Woodruff |
2004 |
9.00 |
$200 |
$1,800.00 |
Kevin Woodruff |
2005 |
6.50 |
$200 |
$1,300.00 |
Subtotal |
258.47 |
$103,425.25 |
Attorney/Staff Work on D.08-07-048 (R.04-04-003) | ||||
Attorney/Staff |
Year |
Hours |
Hourly Rate |
Total |
Michel P. Florio |
2007 |
2.75 |
$520 |
$1,430.00 |
Subtotal |
2.75 |
$1,430.00 |
Attorney/Staff Work on D.08-09-024 (R.04-04-003) | ||||
Attorney/Staff |
Year |
Hours |
Hourly Rate |
Total |
Michel P. Florio |
2007 |
21.75 |
$520 |
$11,310.00 |
Michel P. Florio |
2008 |
10.50 |
$535 |
$5,617.50 |
Subtotal |
32.25 |
$16,927.50 |
Attorney/Staff Work Mohave - MACS (R.04-04-003) | ||||
Attorney/Staff |
Year |
Hours |
Hourly Rate |
Total |
James Helmich |
2005 |
00.00 |
$160 |
$.00 |
Subtotal |
00.00 |
$.00 |
Preparation of NOI and Compensation Request (R.04-04-003) | ||||
Attorney/Staff |
Year |
Hours |
Hourly Rate |
Total |
Michel P. Florio |
2007 |
3.00 |
$260.00 |
$780.00 |
Michel P. Florio |
2008 |
21.75 |
$267.50 |
$5,818.12 |
Nina Suetake |
2008 |
4.00 |
$112.50 |
$450.00 |
Subtotal |
28.75 |
$7,048.12 |
Expenses | |
Consultant Travel |
$211.90 |
Photocopying Expenses |
$565.20 |
Auto, Parking and Tolls |
$217.10 |
Postage |
$41.34 |
Phone & Fax |
$85.22 |
Subtotal |
$1,120.76 |
Total Award for R.04-04-003 |
$175,749.69 |
Attorney/Staff Work on D.05-04-024 (R.04-04-025) | ||||
Attorney/Staff |
Year |
Hours |
Hourly Rate |
Total |
Michel P. Florio |
2004 |
9.25 |
$470 |
$4,347.50 |
Michel P. Florio |
2005 |
0.75 |
$470 |
$352.50 |
Hayley Goodson |
2004 |
.50 |
$190 |
$95.00 |
Hayley Goodson |
2005 |
2.75 |
$190 |
$522.50 |
William Marcus |
2004 |
19.50 |
$195 |
$3,802.50 |
Jeff Nahigian |
2004 |
4.25 |
$140 |
$595.00 |
Cynthia Mitchell |
2004 |
18.00 |
$115 |
$2,070.00 |
Cynthia Mitchell |
2005 |
4.50 |
$140 |
$630.00 |
Nina Suetake |
2004 |
1.50 |
$190 |
$285.00 |
Subtotal |
61.00 |
$12,700.00 |
Attorney/Staff Work on D.06-06-063 (R.04-04-025) | ||||
Attorney/Staff |
Year |
Hours |
Hourly Rate |
Total |
Michel P. Florio |
2006 |
.50 |
$485 |
$242.50 |
Marcel Hawiger |
2005 |
1.75 |
$270 |
$472.50 |
Hayley Goodson |
2005 |
9.25 |
$190 |
$1,757.50 |
Hayley Goodson |
2006 |
57.25 |
$195 |
$11,163.75 |
William Marcus |
2006 |
21.42 |
$220 |
$4,712.40 |
Cynthia Mitchell |
2005 |
28.00 |
$140 |
$3,920.00 |
Cynthia Mitchell (travel) |
2005 |
3.00 |
$70 |
$210.00 |
Cynthia Mitchell |
2006 |
99.00 |
$140 |
$13,860.00 |
Cynthia Mitchell (travel) |
2006 |
3.00 |
$70 |
$210.00 |
Subtotal |
223.17 |
$35,548.65 |
Attorney/Staff Work on D.08-01-006 (R.04-04-025) | ||||
Attorney/Staff |
Year |
Hours |
Hourly Rate |
Total |
Hayley Goodson |
2007 |
7.25 |
$210 |
$1,522.50 |
Cynthia Mitchell |
2007 |
6.25 |
$140 |
$875.00 |
Subtotal |
13.50 |
$2,397.50 |
Preparation of NOI and Compensation Request (R.04-04-025) | ||||
Attorney/Staff |
Year |
Hours |
Hourly Rate |
Total |
Michel Florio |
2004 |
1.00 |
$235 |
$235.00 |
Hayley Goodson |
2007 |
3.50 |
$105 |
$367.50 |
Hayley Goodson |
2008 |
32.00 |
$140 |
$4,480.00 |
Subtotal |
36.50 |
$5,082.50 |
Expenses | |
Consultant Travel |
$259.72 |
Consultant Lodging |
$534.95 |
Photocopying Expenses |
$153.87 |
Auto, Parking and Tolls |
$96.50 |
Postage |
$2.13 |
Subtotal |
$1,047.17 |
Total Compensation for R.04-04-025 |
$57,775.82 |
Consistent with previous Commission decisions, we order that interest be paid on the award amount (at the rate earned on prime, three-month commercial paper, as reported in Federal Reserve Statistical Release H.15) commencing on February 4, 2009, the 75th day after TURN filed its compensation request, and continuing until full payment of the award is made.
We direct PG&E, SDG&E, SoCalGas, and SCE to allocate among themselves a responsibility for the payment of the amount of $57,775.82 awarded in R.04-04-025, based upon their California-jurisdictional gas and electric revenues for the 2005 calendar year, to reflect the year in which the proceeding was primarily litigated.
We direct PG&E, SDG&E, and SCE to allocate among themselves a responsibility for the payment of the amount of $175,749.69 awarded in
R.04-04-003, based upon their California-jurisdictional electric revenues for the 2005 calendar year, to reflect the year in which the proceeding was primarily litigated.