GEW/jva 10/17/2005
BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
In the Matter of Joint Application of Verizon Communications Inc. ("Verizon") and MCI, Inc. ("MCI") to Transfer Control of MCI's California Utility Subsidiaries to Verizon, Which Will Occur Indirectly as a Result of Verizon's Acquisition of MCI.
Application 05-04-020
(Filed April 21, 2005)
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE'S RULING
RECEIVING EXHIBITS INTO EVIDENCEThis ruling receives into evidence those exhibits last marked for identification in Application 05-04-020 by Administrative Law Judge's Ruling dated September 30, 2005.
IT IS RULED that the exhibits marked for identification in Attachment A are received into evidence in Application 05-04-020.
Dated October 17, 2005, at San Francisco, California.
/s/ GLEN WALKER
Glen Walker
Administrative Law Judge
ATTACHMENT A
EXHIBIT LIST IN A.05-04-020
Exhibit No. Description of Exhibit Witness Date
Ident Recd
Verizon/MCI
Verizon/MCI 1 Agreement/Plan of Merger 4/21/05 10/17/05
Verizon/MCI 2 Amendment to Plan of Merger 4/21/05 10/17/05
Verizon/MCI 3 Declaration McCallion 4/21/05 10/17/05
Verizon/MCI 4 Declaration (redacted) Hallbach 4/21/05 10/17/05
Verizon/MCI 4(c) Declaration Hallbach 4/21/05 10/17/05
Verizon/MCI 5 Declaration Rubinfeld 4/21/05 10/17/05
Verizon/MCI 5(c) Declaration Rubinfeld 4/21/05 10/17/05
Verizon/MCI 6 Declaration Smith 4/21/05 10/17/05
Verizon/MCI 6(c) Declaration Smith 4/21/05 10/17/05
Verizon/MCI 7 Certificate of Incorporation 4/21/05 10/17/05
Verizon/MCI 8 Verizon 2004 Annual Report 4/21/05 10/17/05
Verizon/MCI 9 Verizon Form 10-K 4/21/05 10/17/05
Verizon/MCI 10 Verizon Form 10-Q 4/21/05 10/17/05
Verizon/MCI 11 Cal. Certificate of Good Standing 4/21/05 10/17/05
Verizon/MCI 12 Del. Certificate of Good Standing 4/21/05 10/17/05
Verizon/MCI 13 MCI Form 10-K 4/21/05 10/17/05
Verizon/MCI 14 MCI Form 10-Q 4/21/05 10/17/05
Verizon/MCI 15 MCI Pro Forma 4/21/05 10/17/05
Verizon/MCI 16 MCI 2004 Annual Report 4/21/05 10/17/05
Verizon/MCI 17 MCI Affiliate Transaction Report 4/21/05 10/17/05
Verizon/MCI 18 AB 119 4/21/05 10/17/05
Verizon/MCI 19 Proposed Schedules 4/21/05 10/17/05
Verizon/MCI 20 Amendment to Application 5/9/05 10/17/05
Verizon/MCI 21 Supplement to Testimony Smith 6/14/05 10/17/05
Verizon/MCI 21(c) Supplement to Testimony Smith 6/14/05 10/17/05
Verizon/MCI 22 Rebuttal Declaration Rubinfeld 9/12/05 10/17/05
Verizon/MCI 22(c) Rebuttal Declaration Rubinfeld 9/12/05 10/17/05
Verizon/MCI 23 Rebuttal Testimony McCallion 9/12/05 10/17/05
Verizon/MCI 23(c) Rebuttal Testimony McCallion 9/12/05 10/17/05
Verizon/MCI 24 Rebuttal Testimony Hallbach 9/12/05 10/17/05
Verizon/MCI 24(c) Rebuttal Testimony Hallbach 9/12/05 10/17/05
Verizon/MCI 25 Rebuttal Report Smith/McCallion 9/12/05 10/17/05
TURN
TURN 1 Reply Testimony (redacted) Murray/Kientzle 8/15/05 10/17/05
TURN 1(c) Reply Testimony Murray/Kientzle 8/15/05 10/17/05
TURN 2 Reply Testimony (redacted) Roycroft 8/15/05 10/17/05
TURN 2(c) Reply Testimony Roycroft 8/15/05 10/17/05
TURN 3 Reply Testimony Finkelstein 8/15/05 10/17/05
TURN 4(c) Attachment 1, Clews Reports 9/26/05 10/17/05
TURN 5 Attachment 2, Spitzer Comments 9/26/05 10/17/05
TURN 6(c) Attachment 3, Discovery Responses 9/26/05 10/17/05
ATTACHMENT A
EXHIBIT LIST IN A.05-04-020
Exhibit No. Description of Exhibit Witness Date
Ident Recd
Office of Ratepayer Advocates
ORA 1 Reply Testimony (redacted) Selwyn 8/15/05 10/17/05
ORA 1(c) Reply Testimony Selwyn 8/15/05 10/17/05
ORA 2 Reply Testimony (redacted) Piiru 8/15/05 10/17/05
ORA 3 Reply Testimony (redacted) Lee-Whei Tan 8/15/05 10/17/05
ORA 3(c) Reply Testimony Lee-Whei Tan 8/15/05 10/17/05
ORA 4 Reply Testimony Johnston 8/15/05 10/17/05
ORA 5 CAB Complaint Report 9/26/05 10/17/05
ORA 6 Customer Letters to Verizon 9/26/05 10/17/05
ORA 7 Verizon Response to ORA DR9 9/26/05 10/17/05
ORA 7(c) Verizon Response to ORA DR9 9/26/05 10/17/05
ORA 8 Declaration Dovens 9/26/05 10/17/05
Cox
Cox 1 Reply Testimony Gillan 8/15/05 10/17/05
CALTEL
CALTEL 1 Testimony Gillan 8/15/05 10/17/05
CALTEL 2 Reply Testimony Wood 8/15/05 10/17/05
Latino Issues Forum
LIF 1 Expert Testimony Chabran 8/15/05 10/17/05
LIF 2 Expert Testimony Arteaga 8/15/05 10/17/05
LIF 3 Settlement Agreement and Release 9/26/05 10/17/05
Greenlining Institute
Greenlining 1 Testimony Phillips 8/15/05 10/17/05
Greenlining 2 Testimony Gamboa 8/15/05 10/17/05
Greenlining 3 Rebuttal Testimony Gamboa 9/12/05 10/17/05
Greenlining 4 Rebuttal Testimony Phillips 9/12/05 10/17/05
Greenlining 5 Settlement Agreement and Release 9/26/05 10/17/05
ATTACHMENT A
EXHIBIT LIST IN A.05-04-020
Exhibit No. Description of Exhibit Witness Date
Ident Recd
Qwest
Qwest 1 Testimony Axberg 8/15/05 10/17/05
Qwest 1(c) Testimony Axberg 8/15/05 10/17/05
Qwest 2 CPUC Press Release 9/26/05 10/17/05
Qwest 3 Status of Competition 2003 9/26/05 10/17/05
Qwest 4 Exchange Area Map 9/26/05 10/17/05
Qwest 5(c) Excerpt Attorney General 9/26/05 10/17/05
Qwest 6(c) Excerpt VZCA 9/26/05 10/17/05
Qwest 7(c) Excerpt Objections and Responses 9/26/05 10/17/05
Qwest 8(c) Excerpt Cullather 9/26/05 10/17/05
Qwest 9(c) Excerpt VZCA 9/26/05 10/17/05
Qwest 10(c) Excerpt VZCA 9/26/05 10/17/05
Qwest 11(c) Excerpt VZCA 9/26/05 10/17/05
Qwest 12(c) Excerpt VZCA 9/26/05 10/17/05
Qwest 13(c) Excerpt VZCA 9/26/05 10/17/05
Qwest 14(c) Excerpt VZCA 9/26/05 10/17/05
Qwest 15 Excerpt Objections 9/26/05 10/17/05
Qwest 16 Excerpt Objections 9/26/05 10/17/05
Qwest 17 DeWine-Kohl Letter 9/26/05 10/17/05
Qwest 18 Policy Statement-CPUC 9/26/05 10/17/05
Qwest 19 FCC News Release 9/26/05 10/17/05
Telscape
Telscape 1 Testimony (redacted) Compton 8/15/05 10/17/05
Telscape 1(c) Testimony Compton 8/15/05 10/17/05
Disability Rights Advocates
DRA 1 Testimony (redacted) Kasnitz/Knestrick 8/15/05 10/17/05
DRA 1(c) Testimony Kasnitz/Knestrick 8/15/05 10/17/05
Pac-West
Pac-West 1 Reply Testimony Sumpter 8/15/05 10/17/05
Level 3
Level 3 Ex. 1 Reply Testimony Vidal 8/15/05 10/17/05
(END OF ATTACHMENT A)
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that I have by mail this day served a true copy of the original attached Administrative Law Judge's Ruling Receiving Exhibits Into Evidence on all parties of record in this proceeding or their attorneys of record.
Dated October 17, 2005, at San Francisco, California.
/s/ JANET V. ALVIAR
Janet V. Alviar
NOTICE
Parties should notify the Process Office, Public Utilities Commission, 505 Van Ness Avenue, Room 2000, San Francisco, CA 94102, of any change of address to insure that they continue to receive documents. You must indicate the proceeding number on the service list on which your name appears.
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
The Commission's policy is to schedule hearings (meetings, workshops, etc.) in locations that are accessible to people with disabilities. To verify that a particular location is accessible, call: Calendar Clerk (415) 703-1203.
If specialized accommodations for the disabled are needed, e.g., sign language interpreters, those making the arrangements must call the Public Advisor at (415) 703-2074,
TTY 1-866-836-7825 or (415) 703-5282 at least three working days in advance of the event.
