7. Hours Claimed

All intervenors have submitted time logs to support the hours claimed by their professionals. The logs include a daily breakdown of hours by activity. We find that all intervenors have adequately supported the hours for which they claim compensation but, as noted above, this is not equivalent to a finding that hours charged were reasonable in number.

The following tables set forth the hours claimed, rates requested, total fees requested, and other costs claimed by the various professionals in this proceeding for each year of such professional's participation. Unless otherwise indicated, hours claimed equal hours billed less a 50% reduction in hours related to preparation of fee requests and any additional voluntary reductions taken by the professionals involved.

A. TURN

First Name	Last Name	Type	Hours	Rate	Year	Total
Marcel	Hawiger	Attorney	3.35	190	2001	$ 636.50
Marcel	Hawiger	Attorney	17.75	190	2002	3,372.50
Paul	Stein	Attorney	144.75	200	2000	28,950.00
Robert	Finkelstein	Attorney	3.75	280	2000	1,050.00
William	Marcus	Economist	3.08	150	2000	462.00
Gayatri	Schilberg	Economist	194.84	105/115	2000	20,458.20
Gayatri	Schilberg	Economist	31.80	115/130	2001	3,657.00
Gayatri	Schilberg	Economist	39.03	130	2002	5,073.904
Jeffrey	Nahigian	Economist	35.25	95	2000	3,348.75
Jeffrey	Nahigian	Economist	1.50	115	2001	172.50
Copying						2,711.45
Other Expense						1,929.36
Total Claim						$71,822.16

B. CAUSE

First Name	Last Name	Type	Hours	Rate	Year	Total
Steven	Weissman	Attorney	164.4	$315	2000	$ 51,786.00
Alvin	Pak	Attorney	12.6	$315	2002	3,969.00
Marc	Mihaly	Attorney	34.8	$315	2000	10,962.00
Marc	Mihaly	Attorney	0.2	$315	2001	63.00
Marc	Mihaly	Attorney	0.2	$315	2002	63.00
Janette	Schue	Attorney	26.75	$165	2000	4,413.75
Janette	Schue	Attorney	23.5	$165	2001	3,877.50
Janette	Schue	Attorney	12.1	$165	2002	1,996.50
Karen	Johanson	Ratepayer Advocate	164.2	$100	2000	16,420.00
Karen	Johanson	Ratepayer Advocate	25.1	$100	2001	2,510.00
Joan	Tukey	Ratepayer Advocate	45.1	$100	2000	4,510.00
Joan	Tukey	Ratepayer Advocate	2.0	$100	2002	200.00
Copying						2,412.46
Travel						2,606.16
Other Expenses						1,054.43
Total						$106,843.80

C. CCAE

First Name	Last Name	Type	Hours	Rate	Year	Total
Peter	Frech	Engineer	203.00	180	2000	$ 36,540.00
Peter	Frech	Engineer	34.50	905	2000	3,105.00
Peter	Frech	Engineer	21.50	180	2001-2	3,870.00
Peter	Frech	Engineer	12.00	90	2002	1,080.00
Expenses						1,182.13
Total						$ 45,777.13

D. 19SN

First Name	Last Name	Type	Hours	Rate	Year	Total
Roger	Poynts	Engineer	72.7	160	2000	$ 11,632.00
Connie	Easterly	Attorney	202.8	210	2000	42,588.00
Connie	Easterly	Attorney	52.2	210	2001	10,962.00
Travel						1,009.00
Total						$ 66,191.00
50% Reduction6						$ 33,095.50

⁴ Rates for Schilberg were adjusted as of each July 1 during the proceeding, which is the beginning of the fiscal year for her employer. The dollar figures shown for years 2000 and 2001 represent the product of the hours shown times rates in effect when each hour was recorded. ⁵ Frech has reduced his hourly rate for travel and fee-related work by 50% rather than reducing the hours claimed for such work. Frech's method for making this adjustment is actually our preferred method, as this method makes the adjustment more obvious (and thus easier to check) than halving the claimed hours. ⁶ Represents intervenor's proposed equal division of time between itself and its representative UDI, which has an independent interest in the outcome of this proceeding.