Public Utilities Commission of the State of California
| Results of Public Agenda 3162 |
| Meeting Held on Friday, November 18, 2005 10:00 a.m. |
| San Francisco, California |
Commissioners
| Michael R. Peevey, President |
| Scheduled Commission Meetings |
| 505 Van Ness Avenue, San Francisco |
Website: http://www.cpuc.ca.gov
| Ratesetting Deliberative Meeting* |
| Tuesday, November 29, 2005 (San |
| Francisco ) (Will Be Held) |
| Thursday, December 01, 2005 (San |
| Francisco) |
| Thursday, December 15, 2005 (San |
| Francisco) |
| Monday, December 12, 2005 (San |
| Francisco) |
| Thursday, January 12, 2006 (San |
| Francisco) |
| Monday, January 09, 2006 (San |
| Francisco) |
| Monday, January 23, 2006 (San |
| Francisco) |
| Thursday, January 26, 2006 (San |
| Francisco) |
| Tuesday, February 14, 2006 (San |
| Francisco) |
| Thursday, February 16, 2006 (San |
| Francisco) |
| *Ratesetting Deliberative Meeting dates are reserved as noted but will be held only if there are ratesetting matters to be |
| considered and a Commissioner has requested that a Ratesetting Deliberative Meeting be held. |
| This location is accessible to people with disabilities. If specialized accommodations for the disabled |
| are needed, e.g. sign language interpreters, please call the Public Advisor at (415) 703-2074 or TTY# |
| (415) 703-5282 or toll free # 1-866-836-7825 three business days in advance of the meeting. |
| For further information contact the Public Advisor |
| (415) 703-2074 E-mail: public.advisor@cpuc.ca.gov |
Public Agenda 3162
Friday, November 18, 2005
| The following items are not subject to public comment: |
| · All items on the closed session agenda; these are HEX and EX items. |
PUBLIC COMMENT
Public Comment:
| Alice A. Huffman, CA NAACP, Sacramento |
| Darryl Conklein, Renewable Technologies |
| Betty Jo Toccoli, CA Small Business Assn. & CA Small Business Round Table, Culver City |
| Nancy Biagini, Communications Workers of America, Dist. 9, Sacramento |
| Betty Jo Toccoli, CA Small Business Assn. & CA Small Business Round Table, Culver City |
| Eric Minikel, International Institute of San Francisco, San Francisco |
Consent Agenda
| Items shown on the Consent Agenda will be taken up and voted on as a group in one of the first items |
| of business of each Commission meeting. Items may be removed from the Consent Agenda for |
| discussion on the Regular Agenda at the request of any Commissioner prior to the meeting. |
Orders and Resolutions
| A01-01-021 - Southern California Gas Company (SoCalGas) and San Diego Gas & Electric |
| Company (SDG&E). |
| Decision 02-08-065 deferred the core gas supply portfolio consolidation proposal of SoCalGas and |
| SDG&E pending the outcome of I02-11-040 (the Border Price OII). Current gas supply conditions |
| cause the Commission to permit a new application by the utilities for consolidation. This proceeding is |
| closed. |
| (Comr Kennedy - ALJ Barnett) |
Outcome
Signed
D0511004
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
2
11/21/2005 10:32 am
Public Agenda 3162
Friday, November 18, 2005
Res ALJ 176-3162
| Ratification of preliminary determination of category for proceedings initiated by application. The |
| preliminary determinations are pursuant to Article 2.5, Rules 4 and 6.1 of the Commission's Rules of |
| Practice and Procedure. |
Outcome
Approved
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
A04-06-024 - Pacific Gas and Electric Company (PG&E).
| This decision adopts the May 13, 2005 Settlement with five Supplemental Settlements. Within 45 |
| days, PG&E shall file an advice letter with revised tariffs to become effective on or after January 1, |
| 2006. The eligibility period for standby charge exemptions shall remain in effect. The proceeding |
| remains open to address the agricultural class definition issue. |
| (Comr Peevey - ALJ Mattson) |
11/09/2005 - This revision was not shown on the Agenda mailed to the public.
Outcome
| Signed (Comr. Grueneich recused herself from this agenda item and was |
| not part of the quorum in its consideration.) |
D0511005
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Kennedy, Peevey) |
Res W-4569 - R. R. Lewis Small Water Company (RR Lewis).
| This resolution authorizes RR Lewis a surcharge producing an increase in annual revenues of $38,428 |
| or 137% to recover engineering and construction costs of a temporary chlorination system and to |
| recover increases in water testing costs. (Advice Letter 20, filed August 29, 2005) |
Outcome
Approved
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
3
11/21/2005 10:32 am
Public Agenda 3162
Friday, November 18, 2005
Res M-4815
| This resolution adopts level of the Public Utilities Commission Transportation Reimbursement Account |
| fees for fiscal year 2005-06. The fee levels set by this resolution for passenger vehicle operators, |
| vessel operators, commercial air operators and pipeline corporations are unchanged from the fee levels |
| set for fiscal year 2004-05. The fee level set for the railroad corporations reflect a $1,113,000 |
| increase from the level set for fiscal year 2004-05 due to an increase in rail safety staffing and funding |
| for a rail safety working group. |
Outcome
Approved
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
A05-03-023 - Matrix Telecom, Inc. (Matrix).
| A05-03-022 - Related matters. This decision grants Matrix a certificate of public convenience and |
| necessity and approves transfer of assets from Global Crossing Telecommunications to Matrix. These |
| proceedings are closed. |
| (Comr Grueneich - ALJ Yacknin) |
Outcome
Signed
D0511006
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
A05-02-014 - Pacific Gas and Electric Company (PG&E).
| This decision finds PG&E's administration of power purchase agreements and procurement of least |
| cost dispatch power activities for the period January 1, 2004 through December 31, 2004 (Record |
| Period) reasonable and prudent, and also finds PG&E’s $74.9 million undercollected Energy Resource |
| Recovery Account balance at December 31, 2004 reasonable. This proceeding is closed. |
| (Comr Grueneich - ALJ Galvin) |
Outcome
Signed
D0511007
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
4
11/21/2005 10:32 am
Public Agenda 3162
Friday, November 18, 2005
A05-02-005 - Apple Valley Ranchos Water Company (Apple Valley).
| This decision adopts test year 2006 revenue requirements, authorizes a return on equity, and creates a |
| low-income ratepayer assistance program for Apple Valley. This application is closed. |
| (Comr Grueneich - ALJ Long) |
Outcome
Held (12/1/05, Consent Agenda)
A05-07-005 - Vanco Direct USA, LLC (Applicant).
| This decision grants Applicant a certificate of public convenience and necessity to provide resold |
| services. This proceeding is closed. |
| (Comr Grueneich - ALJ Prestidge) |
Outcome
Signed
D0511008
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
| R02-06-001 - Order Instituting Rulemaking on policies and practices for advanced metering, |
| demand response, and dynamic pricing. |
| This decision closes Rulemaking 02-06-001 as most of the activities identified in the proceeding have |
| been completed. The Commission identifies additional activities necessary to ensure that the demand |
| response programs provide full value to California ratepayers and establish a timetable for moving |
| forward on those activities. This proceeding is closed. |
| (Comr Peevey - ALJ Cooke) |
Outcome
Signed
D0511009
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
5
11/21/2005 10:32 am
Public Agenda 3162
Friday, November 18, 2005
| I04-04-024 - Order Instituting Investigation into the proposal of Sound Energy Solutions to |
| construct and operate a liquefied natural gas terminal at the Port of Long Beach. |
| This decision closes this investigation of Sound Energy Solutions’ plan to construct and operate a |
| liquefied natural gas plant at the Port of Long Beach. This proceeding is closed. |
| (Comr Brown - ALJ Malcolm) |
Outcome
Signed
D0511010
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
A05-06-004 - Pacific Gas and Electric Company.
| For approval of the 2006 - 2008 energy efficiency programs and budget. A05-06-011, A05-06-015, |
| A05-06-016 - Related matters. This decision adopts the Joint Staff’s request for overall funding of |
| $162,794,829 for energy efficiency evaluation, measurement and verification activities over the |
| 2006-2008 program cycle. This represents approximately 7.6% of the total portfolio budgets for |
| energy efficiency authorized for this program cycle, including the program budgets adopted in |
| D05-09-043. |
| (Comr Kennedy - ALJ Gottstein) |
Outcome
| Signed (Comr. Grueneich recused herself from this agenda item and was |
| not part of the quorum in its consideration.) |
D0511011
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Kennedy, Peevey) |
Res T-16911
| This resolution revokes certificates of public convenience and necessity (CPCN) of the following |
| companies at their request: Affinity Network Incorporated (CPUC# (#) 5229), Eclipse |
| Communications Corp. (#5366), Easy Cellular, Inc. (#5775), Telephone Company of Central Florida, |
| Inc. (#5846), Teleglobe America, Inc. (#5871), Focal Communications Corporation of California |
| (#5922), Comm South Companies, Inc. (#5943), WWC License (#6141), Global Metro Networks |
| California, LLC (#6497), Tralee Telephone Company, LLC (#6699). |
Outcome
Approved
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
6
11/21/2005 10:32 am
Public Agenda 3162
Friday, November 18, 2005
| A05-08-035 - San Carlos Telecom, Inc. (San Carlos) and Wave eXchange LLC (Wave |
| eXchange). |
| This decision grants the request of San Carlos and Wave eXchange, pursuant to California Pub. Util. |
| Code §§ 851-854, for approval of a transaction pursuant to which Wave eXchange acquires that |
| portion of the outstanding shares of common stock that it does not already own, and thereby voting |
| control of San Carlos. The transaction will not affect the California operations of San Carlos. The |
| matter is uncontested. This proceeding is closed. |
| (Comr Kennedy - ALJ Patrick) |
Outcome
Signed
D0511012
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
A00-07-048 - Southern California Edison Company (SCE).
| This decision grants SCE's Petition to Modify D00-10-040 as previously modified. The decision |
| clarifies that SCE has authority to issue $700 million in secured long term debt to finance energy |
| procurement. This proceeding is closed. |
Outcome
Signed
D0511013
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
A99-01-016 - Pacific Gas and Electric Company.
| For authority to establish post-transition period electric ratemaking mechanisms. A99-01-019, |
| A99-01-034, A99-02-029 - Related matters. These applications dealt with the end of the rate freeze |
| imposed by AB 1890. All matters have been resolved and there is no further need for these |
| proceedings. This decision closes these proceedings. |
| (Comr Kennedy - ALJ Long) |
Outcome
Signed
D0511014
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
7
11/21/2005 10:32 am
Public Agenda 3162
Friday, November 18, 2005
Res T-16960 - SBC California (SBC).
| This resolution approves a CMRS Agreement between SBC and Jerry's Mobile Radio, in accordance |
| with the provisions of General Order 96-A and Resolution ALJ-181. (Advice Letter 27271, filed |
| August 30, 2005) |
Outcome
Approved
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
Res W-4572 - Rio Plaza Water Company, Inc. (Rio Plaza).
| This resolution authorizes Rio Plaza to refinance the Safe Drinking Water Bond Act loan authorized by |
| Decision 88834 and to continue the existing surcharge rates to pay off the new loan. (Advice Letter |
| 40-W, filed September 29 2005) |
Outcome
Approved
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
| R05-07-015 - Order Instituting Rulemaking for purposes of amending the Rules of Practice |
| and Procedure to reflect internet access to the agenda and agenda item documents. |
| This decision amends Rules 79 and 80 to eliminate hard copy agenda, agenda item documents and |
| Daily Calendar subscription service. This proceeding is closed. |
| (Comr Bohn - ALJ Yacknin) |
Outcome
Signed
D0511015
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
8
11/21/2005 10:32 am
Public Agenda 3162
Friday, November 18, 2005
A05-08-040 - Southern California Edison Company (SCE).
| This decision grants SCE authority under Pub. Util. Code § 851 to enter into a lease agreement with |
| RHC Communities, LLC (RHC). The lease is for an 11.3-acre site located on a portion of SCE's |
| Center-Mesa transmission right of way in the City of Pico Rivera. RHC intends to construct and |
| operate a self-storage facility on the site. The application is unopposed. This proceeding is closed. |
| (Comr Brown - ALJ Walker) |
Outcome
Signed
D0511016
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
Res W-4571 - Del Oro Water Company, Paradise Pines District.
| This resolution authorizes Del Oro Water Company, Paradise Pines District a water quantity surcharge |
| producing an increase in revenue of $35,115 or 2.38% to recover the under-collection reflected in the |
| Purchased Water Memorandum Account. (Advice Letter 141, filed July 6, 2005) |
Outcome
Approved
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
(ECP) C05-08-020 - Timothy J. Regello vs. San Diego Gas & Electric Company (SDG&E).
| Complainant seeks an energy efficiency rebate of $1,392. Held: Relief denied because his request did |
| not comply with SDG&E’s Energy Efficiency Rules. This proceeding is closed. |
| (Comr Peevey - ALJ Barnett) |
Outcome
Signed
D0511017
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
9
11/21/2005 10:32 am
Public Agenda 3162
Friday, November 18, 2005
A05-06-024 - Andre Williams (Applicant).
| This decision authorizes Applicant to operate as a passenger stage corporation between certain cities |
| and communities in Placer and Sacramento Counties, on the one hand, and San Francisco and |
| Sacramento International Airports, on the other hand; and to establish a zone of rate freedom. This |
| proceeding is closed. |
Outcome
Signed
D0511018
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
A05-07-009 - Buthaina M. Ibrahim and A-1 Express Shuttle, Inc.
| This decision authorizes Buthaina M. Ibrahim to transfer his passenger stage corporation certificate to |
| A-1 Express Shuttle, Inc. This proceeding is closed. |
Outcome
Signed
D0511019
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
A05-08-004 - Farid Dabit dba On Time Airport Shuttle, and On Time Airport Shuttle, LLC.
| This decision authorizes Farid Salem Dabit to transfer his passenger stage corporation certificate to On |
| Time Airport Shuttle, LLC. This proceeding is closed. |
Outcome
Signed
D0511020
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
10
11/21/2005 10:32 am
Public Agenda 3162
Friday, November 18, 2005
A05-08-028 - Americans' Shuttle 4 Less, L.L.C. (Applicant).
| This decision authorizes Applicant to operate as a passenger stage corporation between points in Los |
| Angeles County, on the one hand, and Los Angeles International, John Wayne, Bob Hope, Long |
| Beach, and Ontario International Airports, Los Angeles/Long Beach Harbors, and the Los Angeles |
| Amtrak Station, on the other hand; and to establish a zone of rate freedom. This proceeding is closed. |
Outcome
Signed
D0511021
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
Res W-4573 - Warring Water Service Inc.
| This resolution modifies the amount of debt obligations of Warring Water Service, Inc. authorized in |
| Resolution W-4557. |
Outcome
Approved
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
A05-04-002 - Southern California Edison Company (SCE).
| Pursuant to Pub. Util. Code §851, SCE is authorized to lease available land on the Gould-Mesa |
| transmission right-of-way to Hawaii Properties, Inc. for the purpose of developing a business park in |
| the City of Rosemead. This proceeding is closed. |
| (Comr Grueneich - ALJ Koss) |
Outcome
Signed
D0511022
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
11
11/21/2005 10:32 am
Public Agenda 3162
Friday, November 18, 2005
A05-03-017 - Southern California Edison Company (SCE).
| Pursuant to Pub. Util. Code §851, SCE is authorized to grant an easement on a parcel of land |
| (approximately one-tenth of an acre) in Tulare County to Brian and Cheryl Ford. This proceeding is |
| closed. |
| (Comr Grueneich - ALJ Koss) |
Outcome
Signed
D0511023
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
A05-08-016 - Mpower Networks Services, Inc. (Applicant).
| This decision grants Applicant a certificate of public convenience and necessity to provide limited |
| facilities-based and resold local exchange telecommunications services. This proceeding is closed. |
Outcome
Signed
D0511024
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
Res E-3960 - Southern California Edison Company (SCE).
| SCE requests the Commission's authorization to establish a memorandum account to record |
| third-party costs associated with certain procurement-related activities. (Advice Letter 1920-E, filed |
| September 30, 2005) |
Outcome
Approved
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
12
11/21/2005 10:32 am
Public Agenda 3162
Friday, November 18, 2005
Regular Agenda
Energy Orders
| R04-04-026 - Order Instituting Rulemaking to implement the California Renewables |
| Portfolio Standards Program. |
| This decision sets forth the basic parameters for the participation of Energy Service Providers, |
| Community Choice Aggregators, and small and multi-jurisdictional utilities in the Renewables Portfolio |
| Standards program. |
| (Comr Peevey - ALJ Allen) |
| Agenda 3157, Item 51 8/25/2005 (Peevey); |
| Agenda 3158, Item 22 9/8/2005 (Bohn); |
| Agenda 3159, Item 29 9/22/2005 (Peevey); |
| Agenda 3160, Item 15 10/6/2005 (Bohn); |
| Agenda 3161, Item 35 10/27/2005 (Staff) |
Outcome
| Withdrawn (Comr. Grueneich recused herself from this agenda item and |
| was not part of the quorum in its consideration.) |
ALTERNATE TO ITEM 4748
| This alternate lays out a policy that electric service providers, community choice aggregators, and small |
| and multi-jurisdictional utilities must comply with certain fundamental aspects of the renewable portfolio |
| standard (RPS) program, but that the commission may distinguish them on a policy basis from the large |
| investor-owned utilities in terms of the manner in which they comply. The decision asks for further |
| proposals from parties on this subject. The alternate also articulates policy preferences on the use of |
| unbundled renewable energy credits for purposes of compliance with RPS. |
| Agenda 3160, Item 15a 10/6/2005 (Bohn); |
| Agenda 3161, Item 35a 10/27/2005 (Staff) |
Outcome
| Signed (Comr. Grueneich recused herself from this agenda item and was |
| not part of the quorum in its consideration.) |
D0511025
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Kennedy, Peevey) |
13
11/21/2005 10:32 am
Public Agenda 3162
Friday, November 18, 2005
| R04-03-017 - Order Instituting Rulemaking regarding policies, procedures and incentives for |
| distributed generation and distributed energy resources. |
| This decision adopts a methodology for assessing the costs and benefits of distributed generation |
| (DG). The purpose of this inquiry into cost-benefit methodologies is to assure that the state’s support |
| for DG projects is economically sound and to assure that state policies promote as much DG as is |
| cost-effective, consistent with the Commission's general policy to include DG facilities as high-priority |
| energy resources. The methodology the decision adopts today is designed to reflect the costs and |
| benefits of DG facilities from various perspectives and employs existing data immediately, which will be |
| modified in the future with the development of more precise economic values for some variables. |
| (Comr Peevey - ALJ Malcolm) |
Agenda 3160, Item 16 10/6/2005 (Staff)
Outcome
Withdrawn
A04-01-009 - Pacific Gas and Electric Company (PG&E).
| This decision approves the steam generator replacement program (SGRP) proposed by PG&E for |
| Diablo Canyon Power Plant Units 1 & 2 subject to the requirements imposed herein. In addition, the |
| decision certifies the Final Environmental Impact Report for the SGRP pursuant to the California |
| Environmental Quality Act. This proceeding is closed. |
| (Comr Brown - ALJ O'Donnell) |
Outcome
| Signed (Pres. Peevey reserves the right to file a concurrence. |
| Comr. Grueneich recused herself from this agenda item and was not part |
| of the quorum in its consideration.) |
D0511026
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Kennedy, Peevey) |
14
11/21/2005 10:32 am
Public Agenda 3162
Friday, November 18, 2005
A05-10-012 - Southern California Gas Company (SoCalGas).
| This decision addresses the request of SoCalGas for authority to rework existing wells at two of its gas |
| storage fields, and to reclassify 4 Bcf of cushion gas to working gas for the benefit of its customers of |
| the California Alternate Rates for Energy program. |
| (Comr Kennedy - ALJ Wong) |
11/18/2005 - This revision was not shown on the Agenda mailed to the public.
Outcome
Signed
D0511027
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
15
11/21/2005 10:32 am
Public Agenda 3162
Friday, November 18, 2005
Energy Resolutions and Written Reports
Res E-3953 - San Diego Gas & Electric Company (SDG&E).
| This resolution approves SDG&E's request updating its revenue requirement associated with the |
| purchase of Ramco Generating One, including modifications to SDG&E's Non-fuel Generation |
| Balancing Account and Energy Resource Recovery Account. (Advice Letter 1711-E, filed July 26, |
| 2005) |
Outcome
Approved
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
Res E-3952 - Sacramento Municipal Utility District (SMUD).
| This resolution concludes that SMUD's proposal to annex the Cities of Davis, West Sacramento, |
| Woodland, and other portions of Yolo County, located in Pacific Gas and Electric Company's |
| (PG&E's) service territory, will not substantially impair PG&E's ability to provide adequate service at |
| reasonable rates within the remainder of its service territory. Request made by letter, effective August |
| 22, 2005, from Sacramento Local Agency Formation Commission to the California Public Utilities |
| Commission. |
Outcome
Approved
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
Res G-3384 - Pacific Gas and Electric Company (PG&E).
| PG&E requests approval of its Winter Gas Savings Program for Residential and Small Commercial |
| Gas Customers and its Winter Revenue Deferred Program and new gas tariff Schedule G-10/20 - |
| Winter Gas Savings Program. (Advice Letter 2675-G, filed November 3, 2005) |
Outcome
Approved
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
16
11/21/2005 10:32 am
Public Agenda 3162
Friday, November 18, 2005
Telecommunication Orders
A05-02-027 - SBC Communications, Inc. (SBC) and AT&T Corp. (AT&T).
| This decision approves the application of SBC and AT&T to transfer control of AT&T and related |
| affiliates to SBC subject to the terms and requirements set forth in this order. The Applicants must |
| comply with prescribed requirements in order for the proposed merger to provide reasonable |
| assurance that the merger will be in the public interest pursuant to Pub. Util. Code § 854. |
| (Comr Peevey - ALJ Pulsifer) |
Outcome
Withdrawn
ALTERNATE TO ITEM 5025
| This alternate decision approves the application of SBC Communications, Inc. (SBC) and AT&T |
| Corp. (AT&T) to transfer control of AT&T and related affiliates to SBC subject to the terms and |
| requirements set forth in this order. As conditions of approval, the Applicants must 1) agree that by |
| February 28, 2006, they will cease forcing customers to purchase separately traditional local phone |
| service as a condition for obtaining DSL; 2) adopt the agreement that Applicants negotiated with |
| Greenlining and Latino Issues Forum by which SBC provides a $57 million increase in philanthropic |
| giving over a five year period and SBC commits to increasing purchases from minority businesses in |
| California; 3) commit $9 million per year for five years to a California Emerging Technology Fund, of |
| which no more than half may be counted towards satisfying the commitment in the Greenlining |
| agreement; and 4) provide a rate freeze on DSD1 and DS3 private network services for current |
| AT&T customers. |
| (Comr Kennedy, Comr Peevey) |
Outcome
| Signed (Comr. Brown reserves the right to file a dissent. |
| Comrs. Grueneich, Kennedy, and Bohn reserve the right to file a |
| concurrence.) |
D0511028
| Yes: (Bohn, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
ALTERNATE TO ITEM 5025
| This alternate decision remands this proceeding for further examination. |
Outcome
Withdrawn
17
11/21/2005 10:32 am
Public Agenda 3162
Friday, November 18, 2005
A05-04-020 - Verizon Communications, Inc. and MCI, Inc.
| This decision authorizes the change in control whereby Verizon Communications, Inc. acquires MCI, |
| Inc. subject to three conditions. As conditions of approval, the Applicants must 1) agree that by |
| January 31, 2006, they will cease forcing customers to purchase separately traditional local phones |
| service as a condition for obtaining DSL; 2) adopt the agreement that Applicants negotiated with |
| Greenlining and Latino Issues Forum by which Verizon provides a $20 million increase in philanthropic |
| giving over a 5 year period and Verizon commits to increasing purchases from minority businesses in |
| California; 3) commit $3 million per year for five years to a California Emerging Technology Fund, of |
| which no more than half may be counted towards satisfying the commitment in the Greenlining |
| agreement. The terms of the Greenlining Agreement and California Emerging Technology Fund are |
| described in detail in the decision. |
| (Comr Kennedy - ALJ Walker) |
Outcome
| Signed (Comrs. Brown and Grueneich reserve the right to file a dissent. |
| Comr. Bohn reserves the right to file a concurrence.) |
D0511029
| Yes: (Bohn, Kennedy, Peevey) |
ALTERNATE TO ITEM 5027
| This alternate decision approves the application of Verizon Communications Inc. (Veriozn) and MCI, |
| Inc. (MCI) to transfer control of MCI's California utility subsidiaries to Verizon, subject to the |
| conditions set forth in the order. |
Outcome
Defeated
| No: (Bohn, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
ALTERNATE TO ITEM 5027
| This Alternate Decision remands this proceeding for evidentiary hearing on the applicability of Section |
| 854(b) and other issues. |
Outcome
Defeated
| No: (Bohn, Kennedy, Peevey) |
18
11/21/2005 10:32 am
Public Agenda 3162
Friday, November 18, 2005
| R01-09-001 - Order Instituting Rulemaking on the Commission's own motion to assess and |
| revise the new regulatory framework for Pacific Bell and Verizon California Incorporated. |
| I01-09-002 - Related matters. This decision grants the petition of The Utility Reform Network and |
| Office of Ratepayer Advocates to expand the years covered by the proposed New Regulatory |
| Framework audit and denies the petition of Verizon to limit the scope of the audit in Phase III, but |
| states that it will consider whether and how to set a cost cap for the audit in Phase III. In addition, the |
| decision defers the commencement of the audit until the conclusion of A05-04-020 or Phase 3 of the |
| instant proceeding, whichever is later. |
| (Comr Kennedy - ALJ Kenney) |
| Agenda 3157, Item 61 8/25/2005 (Brown); |
| Agenda 3158, Item 33 9/8/2005 (Bohn); |
| Agenda 3159, Item 37 9/22/2005 (Kennedy); |
| Agenda 3160, Item 19 10/6/2005 (Bohn); |
| Agenda 3161, Item 43 10/27/2005 (Kennedy) |
Outcome
Held (12/1/05. For further review.)
ALTERNATE TO ITEM 4819
| I01-09-002 - Related matters. This alternate decision varies from the draft decision in that it does not |
| attempt to direct ORA's audit of Verizon nor does it put limitations on ORA's audit via the allocation of |
| funding for the audit. |
| Agenda 3157, Item 61a 8/25/2005 (Brown); |
| Agenda 3158, Item 33a 9/8/2005 (Bohn); |
| Agenda 3159, Item 37a 9/22/2005 (Kennedy); |
| Agenda 3160, Item 19a 10/6/2005 (Bohn); |
| Agenda 3161, Item 43a 10/27/2005 (Kennedy) |
Outcome
Held (12/1/05. For further review)
19
11/21/2005 10:32 am
Public Agenda 3162
Friday, November 18, 2005
Water/Sewer Orders
| C03-09-001 - Casmalia Community Services District vs. Unocal Corporation, aka Casmite |
| Water System. |
| A03-12-024 - Related matters. This decision issues a certificate of public convenience and necessity |
| (CPCN) to Casmite Corporation to operate existing water system as a public utility, authorizes initial |
| rates, and imposes sanctions for operating without CPCN. |
| (Comr Brown - ALJ Thorson) |
| Agenda 3159, Item 38 9/22/2005 (Bohn); |
| Agenda 3160, Item 20 10/6/2005 (Bohn); |
| Agenda 3161, Item 44 10/27/2005 (Peevey) |
Outcome
| Signed (Comr. Bohn recused himself from this agenda item and was not |
| part of the quorum in its consideration.) |
D0511030
| Yes: (Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
20
11/21/2005 10:32 am
Public Agenda 3162
Friday, November 18, 2005
Water/Sewer Resolutions and Reports
Res W-4570 - Yosemite Spring Park Utility Company (YSPUC).
| This resolution directs YSPUC to collect facilities fees from customers who applied for water service |
| on or after April 6, 2004. (Advice Letter 26, filed June 27, 2005) |
Outcome
Approved
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
21
11/21/2005 10:32 am
Public Agenda 3162
Friday, November 18, 2005
Other Utility Orders
| R04-10-010 - Rulemaking to set hourly rates for purposes of calculating intervenor |
| compensation awards, pursuant to Public Utilities Code Section 1801 and following, for work |
| performed in calendar year 2005. |
| This decision approves principles to govern hourly rates for intervenors’ representatives in calculating |
| award requests for work performed in 2005. This proceeding is closed. |
Outcome
| Signed (Comr. Grueneich recused herself from this agenda item and was |
| not part of the quorum in its consideration.) |
D0511031
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Kennedy, Peevey) |
22
11/21/2005 10:32 am
Public Agenda 3162
Friday, November 18, 2005
Legal Division Matters
FERC Docket No. RM05-25-000
| On September 1, 2005, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) issued a Notice of |
| Inquiry (NOI) inviting comments on whether reforms are needed to FERC’s Order 888 pro forma |
| Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT), and to the utilities’ individual OATTs, in order to ensure |
| that services thereunder are just, reasonable and not unduly discriminatory or preferential. Staff seeks |
| the Commission’s authorization to file comments on FERC’s NOI. These comments must be |
| submitted by November 22, 2005. |
Outcome
Approved-Staff Recommendation
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
23
11/21/2005 10:32 am
Public Agenda 3162
Friday, November 18, 2005
Management Reports and Resolutions
Executive Director Larson Report
Introduction of draft Water Action Plan.
Agenda 3161, Item 46 10/27/2005 (Staff)
Outcome
Held (12/15/05)
24
11/21/2005 10:32 am
Public Agenda 3162
Friday, November 18, 2005
Closed Session
| This notice is furnished under Government Code Sections 11125 and 11126.3. The Commission |
| will meet in Closed Session following the Public Session of its regularly scheduled meeting. In |
| the Closed Session, the Commission may consider personnel matters as provided under |
| Government Code Section 11126(a), institution of proceedings or disciplinary actions against any |
| person or entity under the jurisdiction of the Commission as provided under Government Code |
| Sections 11126(d)(2) and 11126(e)(2)(C)(i), and pending litigation as provided under Government |
| Code Section 11126(e). Additional items may be added to the closed session agenda pursuant to |
| Gov. Code Section 11126.3(d). If in Closed Session the Commission votes to appoint, employ, or |
| dismiss a public employee, the Commission will thereafter reconvene in Open Session to make the |
| disclosures required by Government Code Sections 11125.2 and 11126.3(f). |
Non-Federal
R01-09-001 - Conference with Legal Counsel - Application for Rehearing
| I01-09-002 - Related matters. Disposition of Application for Rehearing of D04-02-063 filed jointly |
| by the Office of Ratepayer Advocates and The Utility Reform Network. In D04-02-063, the |
| Commission disposed of four of 72 findings resulting from an audit of SBC Pacific Telephone |
| Company (Pacific) for the period of 1997 to 1999. Among other things, the Decision determined that |
| Pacific had properly written off the regulatory asset associated with post-retirement benefits other than |
| pensions (PBOPs) above the line in 1998. |
| Agenda 3159, Item 45 9/22/2005 (Staff); |
| Agenda 3160, Item 26 10/6/2005 (Kennedy); |
| Agenda 3161, Item 48 10/27/2005 (Kennedy) |
Outcome
Held (12/1/05.)
R02-11-039 - Conference with Legal Counsel - Application for Rehearing
| Disposition of applications for rehearing of D04-05-017 and D04-05-018 filed by Mirant Delta, LLC |
| and Mirant Potrero, LLC; Western Power Trading Forum et al.; and Elk Hills Power, LLC. |
| D04-05-017 and D04-05-018 adopted requirements for the operation and maintenance of electric |
| generating facilities pursuant to Public Utilities Code Section 761.3. D04-05-017 adopted Logbook |
| Standards for thermal powerplants; D04-05-018 adopted General Order 167 implementing General |
| Duty Standards and Maintenance Standards for electric generating facilities. |
| Agenda 3160, Item 29 10/6/2005 (Staff); |
| Agenda 3161, Item 50 10/27/2005 (Staff) |
Outcome
Held (12/1/05)
25
11/21/2005 10:32 am
Public Agenda 3162
Friday, November 18, 2005
A04-09-028 - Conference with Legal Counsel - Application for Rehearing
| A04-09-029, A04-09-030, A04-09-031, A04-09-032, A04-09-033, A04-09-034, A04-09-035 - |
| Related matters. Disposition of Application for Rehearing of D05-07-022 filed by California Water |
| Service Company (CWS). D05-07-022 is a general rate case decision that establishes rates for eight |
| CWS districts. The decision adopts a settlement of disputed issues jointly advocated by CWS and the |
| Office of Ratepayer Advocates and denies the unopposed request of CWS for interim rate relief |
| pursuant to Section 455.2 of Public Utilities Code. |
Agenda 3161, Item 55 10/27/2005 (Kennedy)
Outcome
Signed
D0511032
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
R95-04-043 - Conference with Legal Counsel - Application for Rehearing
| I95-04-044 - Related matters. Disposition of application for rehearing of Decision D05-08-040 by |
| The Telephone Connection of Los Angeles, Inc. and The Telephone Connection Local Services, LLC |
| (TCLA), alleging that the Commission has committed legal error by adopting a 1+10-digit dialing |
| pattern in the area served by the 310 NPA. D05-08-040 grants a petition to modify D00-09-073, |
| and approves the immediate implementation of an all services overlay of a new 424 area code, rather |
| than a geographic split, within the 310 NPA. Permissive use of the new dialing pattern in the 310 |
| NPA begins on December 31, 2005 and mandatory use begins on July 26, 2006. |
Outcome
Signed
D0511033
| Yes: (Bohn, Brown, Grueneich, Kennedy, Peevey) |
26
11/21/2005 10:32 am