ALJ/TRP/lil Date of Issuance 12/28/2011

Decision 11-12-036 December 15, 2011

BEFORE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

Application of Southern California Edison Company (U338E) for Approval of its 2009 Energy Efficiency Incentive and Funding Requests.

Application 11-06-027
(Filed June 27, 2011)

And Related Matters.

Application 11-06-028
Application 11-06-031
Application 11-06-032

DECISION ADOPTING 2009 INCENTIVE EARNINGS AWARDS

DECISION ADOPTING 2009 INCENTIVE EARNINGS AWARDS 1 1

1. Summary 2 2

2. Introduction 2 2

3. Procedural Background 3 3

4. Framework for Review of 2009 Energy Efficiency
Incentive Award Claims 6 6

4.1. Discussion 9 9

5. Overview of Utility Incentive Earnings Claims 12 12

5.1. Claim Presented by PG&E 12 12

5.2. Claim Presented by SCE 13 13

5.3. Claim Presented by SDG&E 14 14

5.4. Claim Presented by Southern California Gas Company 14 14

6. Energy Division Review of Utility Claims for 2009 15 15

6.1. Energy Division Review of Ex Ante Savings
Calculations from CFL Bulb Installations 17 17

7. Responses to the Energy Division Compliance Report 19 19

7.1. Response of PG&E 19 19

7.2. Response of SCE 21 21

7.3. Response of SDG&E and SoCalGas (The Joint Utilities) 22 22

7.4. Response of NRDC 22 22

8. Discussion 24 24

9. Assignment of Proceeding 27 27

10. Comments on Proposed Decision 27 27

Findings of Fact 35 35

ORDER 40 40

APPENDIX 1 - Derivation of 2009 Utility Incentive Claims

APPENDIX 2 - Explanation of Adopted Adjustment to 2009 Incentive Earnings Claims for Effects of Double-Counting of Compact Florescent Light Bulbs Installations

DECISION ADOPTING 2009 INCENTIVE EARNINGS AWARDS

1. Summary

In this decision, we award a total of $60,011,998 to Southern California Edison Company, Pacific Gas and Electric Company, and San Diego Gas & Electric Company and Southern California Gas Company ) (collectively, the utilities or the applicants) for savings achieved in their calendar year 2009 energy efficiency programs.