8. Comments on Draft Decision

The draft decision of Commissioner Neeper and ALJ Gottstein in this matter was mailed to the parties in accordance with Public Utilities Code Section 311(g) and Rule 77.7 of the Rules of Practice and Procedure. Comments were filed on August 24, 2000 by the Bay Area Poverty Resource Council, the California/Nevada Community Action Association, Community Resource Project, Inc., Latino Issues Forum/Greenlining Institute, ORA, PG&E, SCE, SDG&E/SoCal, Residential Service Companies' United Effort (RESCUE)/SESCO Inc. and Insulation Contractors Association. Reply comments were filed on August 29, 2000 by SCE, SDG&E/SoCal, and PG&E.

We have carefully considered the comments on the issues addressed in today's decision. In response to those comments, we clarify the content and scope of the compliance applications to be submitted by the utilities in response to this decision. In particular, we explain that today's decision adopts the Standardization Project (Phase 1) recommendations and extends the PY 2001 programs and funding levels through December 31, 2001, without further program design modifications. Any future proposals for modifying measure eligibility will be considered during the PY 2002 program planning process, after the Commission has received and reviewed the Reporting Requirements Manual Working Group report on cost-effectiveness standards for measure selection. We also extend the filing dates for certain deliverables required by this decision and correct inconsistencies in due dates that appeared in the draft decision. In addition, we clarify how we intend to apply the standardized methodology for estimating CARE penetration rates to the CARE Outreach Pilot results.

Findings of Fact

1. LIAB solicited public input on its recommendations in this proceeding, but did not follow the guidelines set forth by the Assigned Commissioner for the content of this filing.

2. For the most part, LIAB's recommendations for PY 2001 are duplicative of efforts underway, premature, lack sufficient clarity, are in conflict with recent Commission determinations, or do not represent high priority modifications of policies or programs for our consideration. In particular, LIAB's recommendations for improving program evaluation and oversight do not acknowledge current and developing reporting requirements for the utilities, the work of existing measurement and evaluation groups in this and other Commission proceedings, or the Standardization Project, Outreach Pilot, Attic Ventilation Pilot and Needs Assessment Study currently underway. None of the parties commenting on LIAB's recommendations proposed additional or alternate high priority modifications to policies, program designs or funding levels for PY 2001 LIEE programs.

3. There is a lack of standardization in CARE application forms and in the calculation of CARE penetration rates. These issues are not currently being addressed in the Standardization Project.

4. Low-income customers who receive assistance via the utilities' CARE and LIEE programs would benefit from receiving a standardized customer "bill of rights," including a description of the consumer complaint process.

5. LIAB's proposal for independent auditing requirements does not present or weigh the costs of that proposal in resources and manpower, or consider alternate approaches for improving program monitoring. The filings in this proceeding also do not describe current utility procedures (audits, process evaluations, polls, etc.) for monitoring program quality, cost-efficiency and customer satisfaction in low-income assistance programs.

6. The results of the Attic Ventilation Pilots will provide information needed for evaluating the cost-effectiveness of attic ventilation as a stand-alone measure.

7. In order to evaluate the results of the Outreach Pilot for PY 2002, the utilities need to have tracking systems in place throughout the pilot period.

8. The Standardization Project is an appropriate forum for considering LIAB's Specific Program Recommendations 20, 21 and 28.

9. By creating a standardized WIS manual and a consistent set of installation and other procedures, we believe that the recommendations contained in the Phase 1 Standardization Report will improve the implementation of LIEE programs.

10. Assigning specific tasks to LIAB and focusing advisory committee activities to those assigned tasks, will help ensure that program and Commission resources are most effectively and efficiently utilized. Transferring the task of nominating Board members and producing annual operating budgets from LIAB to Energy Division is an effective way to further conserve program resources.

11. To accomplish its current assignments, as clarified by this decision, LIAB and its advisory committee should be able to substantially reduce the number of scheduled meetings.

12. Allowing LIAB members to serve on CALMAC, even as non-voting members, could place them in the inconsistent role of becoming a party in Commission proceedings.

13. LIAB can best fulfill its independent advisory role if its Board members do not also serve on other committees or working groups that address low-income assistance issues.

14. No program design changes or modifications to measure eligibility have been recommended to the Commission as part of the Standardization Project (Phase 1) or in comments on that report.

15. There is insufficient time and resources to go beyond the Phase 1 Standardization Report and implement a compliance phase that would consider new proposals for measure eligibility in PY 2001. Delaying the final approval of eligible measures would also create an unacceptable delay for utilities that are in the process of issuing a Request For Proposals to select new PY 2001 program implementors. Moreover, evaluating proposals to add or delete measures prior to our consideration of the Working Group report would undermine (and prejudge) our efforts to standardize evaluation and reporting efforts for the LIEE program.

16. No further Commission action is necessary to extend the current programs through 2001 since that extension was authorized in D.00-07-020.

17. The Working Group report will be available in time for the Commission's consideration of the recommendations (and any nonconsensus positions) during the PY 2002 program planning cycle.

Conclusions of Law

1. For the reasons discussed in this decision, LIAB's May 19, 2000 Recommendations On PY 2001 CARE and LIEE Programs should not be adopted.

2. The joint recommendations for standardizing installation standards and other procedures for the LIEE program, as presented in the Phase 1 Standardization Report, are reasonable and should be approved and the recommendations on cost-effectiveness should be accepted for further consideration by the Working Group, as discussed in this decision. Within 30 days of the effective date of this decision, the utilities should jointly file the new WIS manual in this proceeding which incorporates the follow-up recommendations submitted on July 5, 2000. The utilities should serve a notice of its availability to all appearances and the state service list in this proceeding. This new manual should be used by the utilities in designing their PY 2001 programs, and will be the standard used for all installations in the utility programs beginning January 1, 2001.

3. Within 60 days from the effective date of this decision, the utilities should file compliance applications that present the following:

(a) A joint proposal to standardize the calculation of CARE penetration rates, reflecting any consensus reached by the Reporting Requirements Manual Working Group.

(b) A description of current utility procedures (audits, process evaluations, polls, etc.) for monitoring program quality, cost-efficiency and customer satisfaction and recommendations for improving these procedures or instituting alternative ones, along with the associated costs and manpower requirements.

(c) Recommendations regarding stand-alone attic ventilation based on the results of the Attic Ventilation Pilot, and

(d) A description of how the utilities will be tracking the results of the Outreach Pilot so that those results can be evaluated during the PY 2002 program planning cycle.

4. As discussed in this decision, the utilities should prepare a standardized customer "bill of rights," which includes a description of the consumer complaint process. The utilities should include in their filing a description of how they will disseminate the "bill of rights" to customers. This effort should be coordinated with Phase 2 of the Standardization Project, where policies and procedures are to be standardized across utilities. The utilities should jointly develop this document with public input, and present them for approval no later than the filing of their PY 2002 program applications.

5. The utilities should also work toward the development of a form that requests the same types and categories of data from all customers enrolling in CARE. The utilities should jointly develop such forms with public input and present them in an Advice Letter filing by March 1, 2001.

6. The utilities and other members of the Standardization Project team should explore LIAB's Specific Program Recommendations 20, 21 and 28 during the ongoing development of standardized policies and program procedures. As discussed in this decision, if the utilities are in opposition to conforming qualification guidelines to the state and federal rules, they should describe in detail how they plan to coordinate with other programs so that the low-income customer receives as many of the weatherization measures as are feasible for each eligible low-income dwelling unit.

7. Phase 2 and 3 recommendations by the Standardization Project team should be completed in time for our consideration during the PY 2002 program planning cycle, or sooner if possible.

8. As discussed in this decision, LIAB should meet only when assigned specific tasks by the Commission, which currently are comprised of the following:

(a) filing comments on the proposal of the Reporting Requirements Manual Working Group to standardize the reporting requirements and administrative costs of the low-income assistance programs, and

(b) providing input to the utilities on utility proposals for producing standardized data on bill savings and expenditures for LIEE programs on an overall program and per unit basis, per D.00-07-020.

To address these two issues, LIAB and its advisory committee should be able to substantially reduce the number of scheduled meetings. Based on current assignments, LIAB and its advisory committee should reduce their scheduled meetings to those occurring in October, 2000 and January, 2001. If LIAB desires to meet more frequently or perform additional tasks with the assistance of Commission resources, it must seek and receive approval from the Energy Division. If approval is not given, LIAB shall rely on non-Commission resources to complete any additional tasks or conduct additional meetings other than those directed by today's decision or subsequent Commission order. Such additional tasks or meetings that LIAB elects to undertake must be directly related to the utility low-income assistance programs under our jurisdiction. LIAB should prepare and submit to the Energy Division written minutes of any additional meetings and written reports on any additional activities that are undertaken without the assistance of the Energy Division.

9. LIAB Board members (as individuals) should not serve on CALMAC or on other working groups or committees that address low-income assistance issues.

10. As discussed in this decision, Energy Division should submit recommendations for Board member nominations and LIAB operating budgets.

11. In order to proceed expeditiously with the compliance applications, this order should be effective today.

INTERIM ORDER

IT IS ORDERED that:

1. The joint recommendations for standardizing installation standards and other procedures for the LIEE program, as presented in the Phase 1 Standardization Report are reasonable and are approved and the recommendations on cost-effectiveness are accepted for further consideration by the Working Group, as discussed in this decision. Within 30 days of the effective date of this decision, Pacific Gas and Electric Company, San Diego Gas & Electric Company, Southern California Edison Company and Southern California Gas Company, collectively referred to as "the utilities," shall jointly file the new Weatherization Installation Standards (WIS) manual in this proceeding which incorporates the Phase 1 report recommendations and follow-up recommendations submitted on July 5, 2000. The utilities shall serve a notice of its availability to all appearances and the state service list in this proceeding. This new manual shall be used by the utilities in designing their program year (PY) 2001 programs, and shall be the standard used for all installations in the utility programs beginning January 1, 2001.

2. As discussed in Section 6 of this decision, the Low-Income Advisory Board (LIAB) and its advisory committee(s) shall be assisted by Energy Division and other Commission resources only to accomplish the specific tasks assigned to LIAB by the Commission. If LIAB desires to meet more frequently or perform additional tasks with the assistance of Commission resources, it must seek and receive approval from the Energy Division. If approval is not given, LIAB shall rely on non-Commission resources to complete any additional tasks or conduct additional meetings other than those directed by today's decision or subsequent Commission order. Such additional tasks or meetings that LIAB elects to undertake must be directly related to the utility low-income assistance programs under our jurisdiction. LIAB shall prepare and submit to the Energy Division written minutes of any additional meetings and written reports on any additional activities that are undertaken without the assistance of the Energy Division.

3. After LIAB completes its current assignments, LIAB should consider disbanding its advisory committee and convene workshops or working groups when LIAB receives further assignments from the Commission.

4. Within 60 days from the effective date of this decision, the utilities shall file compliance applications that present the following:

(a) A standardized method for calculating California Alternate Rates For Energy (CARE) penetration rates, presented jointly by the utilities and reflecting any consensus reached by the Reporting Requirements Manual Working Group.

(b) A description of current utility procedures (audits, process evaluations, polls, etc.) for monitoring program quality, cost-efficiency and customer satisfaction and recommendations for improving these procedures or instituting alternative ones, along with the associated costs and manpower requirements.

(c) Recommendations regarding stand-alone attic ventilation based on the results of the Attic Ventilation Pilot, and

(d) A description of how the utilities will be tracking the results of the Outreach Pilot so that those results can be evaluated during the PY2002 program planning cycle.

5. In coordination with Phase 2 of the Standardization Project, the utilities shall jointly develop a standardized customer "bill of rights" for low-income assistance programs, which includes a description of the consumer complaint process. The utilities shall describe how they will disseminate the "bill of rights" to customers. They shall develop this document with public input, and present them for approval no later than the filing of their PY 2002 program applications.

6. The utilities shall develop forms that request the same types and categories of data from all customers enrolling in CARE. The utilities shall jointly develop such forms with public input and file them in an Advice Letter filing by March 1, 2001.

7. As discussed in this decision, the utilities and other members of the Standardization Project team shall explore LIAB's Specific Program Recommendations 20, 21 and 28 during the ongoing development of standardized policies and program procedures. Phase 2 and 3 recommendations shall be completed in time for our consideration during the PY 2002 program planning cycle, or sooner if possible.

8. By September 1 of each year, the Energy Division shall solicit and submit nominations for LIAB membership and prepare and submit the LIAB's budget for the upcoming year. The Energy Division shall file its recommendations in the form of a report and serve all appearances and the state service list in this proceeding (or successor proceeding). Interested parties and the LIAB may file comments within 20 days thereafter.

9. All filings required by today's order shall be filed in the Commission's Docket Office and served on the appearances and state service list in this proceeding, or successor proceeding.

This order is effective today.

Dated September 7, 2000, at San Francisco, California.

LORETTA M. LYNCH

President

HENRY M. DUQUE

JOSIAH L. NEEPER

RICHARD A. BILAS

CARL W. WOOD

Commissioners

ATTACHMENT 1

************ APPEARANCES ************
Ron Knecht ADVOCATES FOR THE PUBLIC INTEREST (API) 1465 MARLBAROUGH AVENUE LOS ALTOS CA 94024-5742 (650) 968-0115 ronknecht@aol.com	Tim Tutt CALIFORNIA ENERGY COMMISSION 1516 9TH STREET, MS-22 SACRAMENTO CA 95814
Evelyn Kahl Elsesser Attorney At Law ALCANTAR & ELSESSER LLP ONE EMBARCADERO CENTER, STE 2420 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94111 (415) 421-4143 eke@aelaw.com	Karen Mills CALIFORNIA FARM BUREAU FEDERATION 2300 RIVER PLAZA DRIVE SACRAMENTO CA 95833 (916) 561-5655 kmills@cfbf.com
Michael Alcantar Attorney At Law ALCANTAR & ELSESSER LLP 1300 SW 5TH AVENUE., SUITE 1750 PORTLAND OR 97201 (503) 402-8700 mpa@aelaw.com	Ronald Liebert Attorney At Law CALIFORNIA FARM BUREAU FEDERATION 2300 RIVER PLAZA DRIVE SACRAMENTO CA 95833 (916) 561-5657 rliebert@cfbf.com
Glynnis Jones Vice President APPLIANCE RECYCLING CNTRS OF AMERICA PO BOX 163125 SACRAMENTO CA 95816 (916) 448-8385 GLYNNISJONES@EARTHLINK.NET	Neal A. Johnson CALIFORNIA INTEGRATED WASTE MGMT BOARD 8800 CAL CENTER DRIVE SACRAMENTO CA 95826-3268 (916) 255-2580 njohnson@ciwmb.ca.gov
Barbara R. Barkovich BARKOVICH AND YAP, INC. 31 EUCALYPTUS LANE SAN RAFAEL CA 94901 (415) 457-5537 brbarkovich@earthlink.net	Kevin Smith Consultant CALIFORNIA MANUFACTURERS ASSOCIATION 980 9TH STREET, STE 2200 SACRAMENTO CA 95814-2742 (916) 447-9401
William F. Parker President BAY AREA POVERTY RESOURCE COUNCIL 930 BRITTAN AVENUE SAN CARLOS CA 94070 (650) 595-1342 wparker@baprc.com	Christopher S. Taylor Action Assoc. CALIFORNIA/NEVADA COMMUNITY 225 30TH STREET SUITE 200 SACRAMENTO CA 95816-3359

Maurice Brubaker BRUBAKER & ASSOCIATES, INC. 1215 FERN RIDGE PARKWAY, STE 208 ST. LOUIS MO 63141 (314) 275-7007 mbrubaker@consultbai.com	Joy Omania Action Association CALIFORNIA/NEVADA COMMUNITY 225 30TH STREET, SUITE 200 SACRAMENTO CA 95816
Richard Shaw CHASE SHANNON PO BOX 469 FILLMORE CA 91305	Eileen A. Koch CALPINE CORPORATION 50 W. SAN FERNANDO ST. SAN JOSE CA 95113
Michael Yamada CITY OF L.A. DEPT OF WATER AND POWER ROOM 1534 GOB PO BOX 111 LOS ANGELES CA 90051	Jon S. Silva Government Affairs Associate EDISON SOURCE 955 OVERLAND COURT SAN DIMAS CA 91773 (909) 450-6035 jsilva@edisonenterprises.com For: Edison Enterprises
Rita Norton CITY OF SAN JOSE 777 N. 1ST STREET, SUITE 450 SAN JOSE CA 95112-6311 (408) 277-5533 rita.norton@ci.sj.ca.us For: City of San Jose	Renee H. Guild ELECTRIC POWER RESEARCH INSTITUTE PO BOX 10412 3412 HILLVIEW AVENUE PALO ALTO CA 94304-1395 (650) 855-2000
Edward B. Lozowicki Attorney At Law COUDERT BROTHERS 303 ALMADEN BLVD, FIFTH FLOOR SAN JOSE CA 95110-2721 (408) 297-9982 elozowicki@sjo.coudert.com	Lynn M. Haug Attorney At Law ELLISON & SCHNEIDER 2015 H STREET SACRAMENTO CA 95814-3109 (916) 447-2166 lmh@eslawfirm.com For: DEPT OF GENERAL SVCS.
Ray Czahar 5650 GRAVENSTEIN HIGHWAY-RTE 116 NORTH FORESTVILLE CA 95436 (707) 887-2522 rczahar@aol.com	Dan Kirshner Senior Economic Analyst ENVIRONMENTAL DEFENSE FUND 5655 COLLEGE AVE., SUITE 304 OAKLAND CA 94618 dank@edf.org
Mark J. Berman Director Of Business Development DAVIS ENERGY GROUP 123 C STREET DAVIS CA 95616	Beth Dunlop GRUENEICH RESOURCE ADVOCATES 582 MARKET STREET, SUITE 1020 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94104-5305 (415) 834-2300 bdunlop@gralegal.com For: UC/CAL STATE U

Norman J. Furuta Associate Counsel DEPARTMENT OF THE NAVY 900 COMMODORE DRIVE SAN BRUNO CA 94066-5006 (650) 244-2100 furutanj@efawest.navfac.navy.mil	Charles J Hahn 611 ANTON BLVD SUITE 700 COSTA MESA CA 92626 For: Bentley Company
Carolyn A. Baker DUKE ENERGY NORTH AMERICA 980 NINTH STREET, 16TH FLOOR SACRAMENTO CA 95814 (916) 449-9623 cabaker@duke-energy.com	Jan Smutny-Jones Association INDEPENDENT ENERGY PRODUCERS 1112 I STREET, STE. 380 SACRAMENTO CA 95814-2896
Robert E. Burt Executive Director INSULATION CONTRACTORS ASSOCIATION 1911 F STREET SACRAMENTO CA 95814 (916) 444-2950 bob.burt@macnexus.org	William H. Booth Attorney At Law LAW OFFICES OF WILLIAM H. BOOTH 1500 NEWELL AVENUE, SUITE 500 WALNUT CREEK CA 94596 (925) 296-2460 wbooth@booth-law.com
Carl Robert Aron Exec. Vice President ITRON, INC. PO BOX 15288 2818 N. SULLIVAN ROAD SPOKANE WA 99216 (509) 924-9900 carl.aron@itron.com	Emilio E. Varanini, I I I LIVINGSTON & MATTESICH 1201 K STREET, STE 1100 SACRAMENTO CA 95814 (916) 442-1111
James Hodges J. LAWRENCE COMMUNICATIONS 4720 BRAND WAY SACRAMENTO CA 95819 (916) 451-7011 jlhodges@ibm.net For: East Los Angeles Community Union	Marc Mihaly Attorney 396 HAYES STREET SAN FRANCISCO CA 94102 For: LIGB
Norman A. Pedersen Attorney At Law JONES, DAY, REAVIS & POGUE 555 WEST FIFTH STREET, SUITE 4600 LOS ANGELES CA 90013-1025 (213) 243-2810 napedersen@jonesday.com	Sara Steck Myers Attorney At Law 122 - 28TH AVENUE SAN FRANCISCO CA 94121 (415) 387-1904 ssmyers@hooked.net

Tim Krause PO BOX 519 CYPRESS CA 90630 For: Energx Controls, Inc.	Sheryl Carter NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL 71 STEVENSON STREET, SUITE 1825 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94105 (415) 777-0220 scarter@nrdc.org
Luis Arteaga ROXANNE FIGUEROA LATINO ISSUES FORUM 785 MARKET ST., 3RD FL. SAN FRANCISCO CA 94103	Thomas J. O'Rourke O'ROUKE & COMPANY 44 MONTGOMERY STREET, RM 1705 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94104
Susan E. Brown Attorney At Law LATINO ISSUES FORUM 785 MARKET STREET, 3RD FLOOR SAN FRANCISCO CA 94103-2003 (415) 284-7224	A. Y. Ahmed OCCIDENTAL ANALYTICAL GROUP 1313 N GRAND AVENUE, STE 392 WALNUT CA 91789 For: Occidental Analytical Group
Richard Sperberg President ONSITE/SYCOM 701 PALOMAR AIRPORT ROAD RM 200 CARLSBAD CA 92009 (760) 931-2400 Rsperberg@onsitesycom.com	Doug Grandy OFFICE OF ENERGY ASSESSMENTS 717 K STREET, SUITE 409 SACRAMENTO CA 95814
Robert B. Mclennan ROGER PETERS Attorney At Law PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY POST OFFICE BOX 7442 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94120 (415) 973-2069 rbm4@pge.com	Don Wood Public Policy Programs Supervisor SAN DIEGO GAS & ELECTRIC 4539 LEE AVENUE LA MESA CA 91941 (619) 536-4002 dwood@sdge.com
Blueley I. Anderson POWER VALUE INCORPORATED 877 YGNACIO VALLEY ROAD, STE 105 WALNUT CREEK CA 94596 (510) 938-8735 sia2@pacbell.net	Yole Whiting SAN DIEGO GAS & ELECTRIC CO. BLDG. 4, ROOM 4226A 8306 CENTURY PARK COURT SAN DIEGO CA 92123
Dennis Dobkowski Clearing House, Inc. RESIDENTIAL ENERGY EFFICIENCY 19896 FELICIA DRIVE YORBA LINDA CA 92886	James F. Walsh Attorney At Law SAN DIEGO GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY PO BOX 1831 SAN DIEGO CA 92112 (619) 699-5039 jwalsh@sdge.com For: San Diego Gas & Electric Company

Bryan Griess RESOURCE MANAGEMENT INTERNATIONAL 3100 ZINFANDEL DRIVE, SUITE 600 SACRAMENTO CA 95852-1516 bryangriess@rmiinc.com	Roberto Haro Cesar E Chavez Institute For Pub Policy SAN FRANCISCO STATE UNIVERSITY 1600 HOLLOWAY AVENUE SAN FRANCISCO CA 94132 (415) 338-6044 chavezin@sfsu.edu For: Low Income Governing Board
Roxanne Figueroa RICHARD HEATH AND ASSOCIATES, INC. 604 BANCROFT WAY BERKELEY CA 94710 (510) 649-1464 rfigueroa@rhainc.com For: Latino Issues Forum	Steven R. Schiller PHILLIP HASLEY Principal SCHILLER ASSOCIATES 1333 BROADWAY, SUITE 1015 OAKLAND CA 94612 (510) 444-6500 steves@schiller.com
Robert Mowris ROBERT MOWRIS & ASSOCIATES 10 RIDGE LANE ORINDA CA 94563	Jeff Schlegel 1167 SAMALAYUCA DRIVE O=t3ÆF†›P72n䦒ۋˆu15Ñ%v5%Ó2¬x+ø  "ïâÿ»­ÝÝ+t$ ÙRü(UWCö ²ìÆH005†ÜË;· BV~T¾@›™RŒ…ÑÞßF‘líTW¦ïT¸¬­#ûæâþèö¬¶àâêúà ã)±²÷õá±Ïýø¡J¾Ü¾ßùôN#øL áÿ»{Óçïì¼ïøôœ�ª±Ç–ïèö»�HÒÈÄ«—ÜÝÖµKÝ"i&Ëð!* Q'**5&Ú _¹q„B/çR°XG^GBN8ݺS£>)g L3‰%G/ß Ž T¢n™~Ì�æ •‹`i!$ �àƒ®2'A\+ž¸¬†v Sž)�)8W¯rya9D»pqiþlvWQ[QJyô© ’ ?[Nzox`ì_RþÃ(0{(66c}ó ù $·}8;n;;Èaa0˜ObÉ]cxmÝHû=�d)Ý!/. ra}—AÅBHP:Ãç¬jlÇ!sP2 ‰65ï~ytje1NeqTc�(Ufsõ)rmÿ:YÇ=- Q[án–z{mÏZBA O;ÿ µ_BXTc‰-lf·TàŠ¶#Õ_ä·â±Üð fù ^AGÍ)Éê Ó„d~}§ RàâÀO Y¼ä¾åF0ï"¨ð¬ú49»Ç  2c"^šjiŸ ÖH[31$^ç\îG{' ó}RêTCžTYK/5õ»�õàçºÌL •r—†ãig|ï}r~c*/ôÃTl G/¡( »=—¼Ì JVàHP½¢¢§¦¶JDëèýQ_€„›?f)š|5j�ËeíA|rÐ�žã‚Ò…—‡ë°ý_åð±ò¢ºÔ×ýmëåÖ¾õ¸º‘�›š˜¤ìè³÷ûèüTµ¿ì”ƒb˜‡'ìþäå­Éþ ºÂûæ²¸»°*ÉßL¼ÇËyã§Ûµ´›žl“˵W™�‘‰ý‚³¶·ÀÔ>ìáA婬5ÓÒÌ¡¯†¼@Þ·âPoVOam`<+ý¶ÞLå/EEe½ªÄJRèÒ¿ªz†-kn y÷Âë’çïdOPÏL< s! Ü{d»yf '<9˜uk½z[dÓO! 1A5Þ~žVftA^s3Í*ç2pý63A3 -ò0L.¹j}JQ^8¤YE׆–µ|#hah}ýXêáËö5ðÿnf! >´Zµ;J"¬bb¢Å¤µ­f±®2Û 5P#zNj0(@äñìµs;ä7ˆ¨XNt2ñ @ûiØèéòÕêãòìž}1$…Ëǣſœ›l—µ¢&©áþ�²·Ëö;0LàßÆ-é®Ê%åäᲱО9Ê¢®ìw !÷�,ØÔÔóÁ ±â¢œ“c‚õèߦ¢ÏÕÃû ·°� ã³<»‡†SžJ]"V 5-6TÈ(-"mRQýbqžM7.ò+F9SHX¡ ×n2Z¢xP»+ŒXQ\P@E€dx~êT“+  Sâ÷±Hâ¿ï#Æ :¸à䶟ê¶òE®¾ ‚2Ša1Z.e;6u]¦OXîQ_ƒ]EPYKj•·<@}±!%>3Ö\ ,6Tz E…JeÌeISq:lÖ>%la1~Ö&$ha÷+Y chuÊh×Xue„Bp»ch/* S1bFsõ6kuu|u‹iPî_nð=ä \f-ec*}Úif”|VéÌ°eJøÿ_÷\äVGSÁ©=Û KCHxõo_¢.EvJ|/¯) àM]*XkVÄ,ÇH~Uk9-@h/À9ç%O2‹<Tî!@wà[Q*[=}!¸~U€FpSŠoI*_7R“MèIY>(U]_ªvÁekFØ [ #àPé^IR-n"‰@¶I”RLDK…AP¦ ZCDbYZyJƒRBÞg41�? F+åTEüYC @4$ }Äkh÷E‹@KdJ�!>RãL;q;9,17eòl¦N3u�$KNV@)Ž=\sü@rNP2|2Y3¶:z±&€8VZ38ƒ_~†f(E/ ðNn³OSé.2v%1«a 3â)R+ \(2u²<|Ù+.àsaw+OÃE^ÊxRS*Ol$çrê?Ç%~OcH"åzùC8H~S(89¾=€P(Në S]1Nû~CQÅ4xrIsGa4�a‘`J� u sàx0c±)-Gol y,lpïmvƒh ¹Yr–RI‚BT KXL°S¸w3ÉO RIêCSü`5 fN}qD.Ž}»x¦fkk+6Ü`EÒ.0,B?vsÁUQùw ÁY:E,kë_=ªc*fPEPöm +D±!:×,;D%_yVjN|VEd±*kó2T+3¸rñKqB`¹Ri>Ÿ8s_dUye % "©oH#R`ÌL,ÐH~Og¯{4E� !`96^J$ë$}‡FËZ5‰ _˜x"ÒSx=Sh"|eY0Ñy/‡l{4¹;WL%cj;ª0K'ßv(}5TS.eâMaÞ?cñp?O/_K<”V'ÖN<1PZµùMMŸ;P ¼ ;CÆI*I}ƒBüg0ƒZOAIz3¶x "û:3NI*[Däf\ÜKbû@R:ÍL;É@Eb5oÜ:ð}6Ìw]/T;oæ~\» ykmNqI5ä8 Í ‘ a/IE©FÚ #E )Shg�|ù'^Êgf +ÇT(2¶]Y%gjAh1½¹Ê #(C°OTˆb+]2!I/Q*ä'NÏSOW£\~KmOïk{šlxP"-RX’:+�iÒz~+_év~ïoR-,R/bR¤KW‘TWYÍhnˆuz“;HqHWho'>æuŒ°Ê5ÊÃÃ;P)a'ÛBE»W‹D]µÍÀÄÁ¡W¤¼Jœ¶€\�Šœ–ïâõZ³¥êëå„¿ä䨃ùôþ¸í½÷ÿÿÁØܿ¡©7°ìHÖG[ÜŸ�×lOÝ=4ÛQxMƒH$4ëƒÈ=Ô:"C=GfwL(L¹#Ò ³Xb^~Z�{[�56"Vsáå^úVî/%�jgH/ råþ«Ë: NNEšEA°¶ãÖXhQxY•/hÂl;'?Z^Ö>DÂ)8¿7- {yGš-.^j,sc�é\ZÏ›YdëiºKO~Ò%gã÷ûÓA U2üIOú9U B¥E¾àbçr:§ `·?Ùʃíò«Ø¹â©ÐB¨ëS®óâ×ÈeÐ¥2Þ«µº-¬à²A¦³²¡·þÔ²áæ¡Y¢É´âùgÒ¥»÷ßÞÁ óŒ @ëá] ;Úðøù;�³ÛÃòëîôó€†ÿÿæmý‹�ÿöáóþŒèþ‹„bàœé8öŒý—ðè÷àŠžý–‘úþôøèãõè{î…|øìë/á’ÿŸëäûtýÐøêû¸­Œ×ÉÖ§²¨@áÂëî° ÷춿ջðÕÔÇ¥±Ô­¦´—º®Ú€{‘·T¿ÿ«¬—ÇÑÊäCÏ�Å8šß¸§¯ÜÓÅ‹£Ñ"œóRµÓå/íð²·‹Þ…0§ ¤R¤Ë¾ü󬯬ا¦0µ½O´ÿ®z³½¼°º·ó¶½ÿU¶°³¾«¶°±ÿ¸¹›ýêòî&òãíéñäÿs··¬Fÿ¨º­¦ðò°­ÓKãþs•ÐÄoãþ™ç›€Òy·´ÿb°Ü¨¤Ø¤§™óÖÆKÐÃ0Ö­²ÿ¿íµŽ§Ã>ÌÛ¥ Ÿ¨­ªÄ¦�ëñý©WëðéŽ�]ç•×É%¼í““‡½»¦Õ™žœ’â‚È%¥¯Œ+�àêò–æ‹d‚ù§RÎâøúö³«ß‘�ÙT³ºK¶Ó£¨¯±å¤Å SÿÜö庽áòàÿóªðäJã¿òåä"øúçé°î¶á侶í¼äþýö±í¥ôùÂ+î^šcý˜ŒìKòî ©EæÓîoXøz›‹¼ÍWP)¶ºêá øG¤Jûö R€ZT»E¥KëhqZ3%yXœp|ƒ’ U@S÷øL¤KÄv< THE GREENLINING INSTITUTE 785 MARKET ST., 3RD FLOOR SAN FRANCISCO CA 94103 (415) 284-7219 leslie@greenlining.org For: Greenlining Institute
Frank A. Spasaro Dsm Transition Manager SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA GAS COMPANY 555 WEST FIFTH STREET, ML-22E2 LOS ANGELES CA 90013-1011 (213) 244-3648 fspasaro@socalgas.com	Marcel Hawiger Attorney At Law THE UTILITY REFORM NETWORK 711 VAN NESS AVENUE, SUITE 350 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94102 (415) 929-8876 marcel@turn.org For: TURN
Patrick Petersilia Director Consumer Marketing SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA GAS COMPANY 555 W FIFTH STREET LOS ANGELES CA 90013-1011 For: Southern California Gas Company	Robert Finkelstein Attorney At Law THE UTILITY REFORM NETWORK 711 VAN NESS AVENUE, SUITE 350 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94102 (415) 929-8876 bfinkelstein@turn.org
Denis Turner SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA TRIBAL CHAIRMEN PO BOX 1470 VALLEY CENTER CA 92082 (760) 749-0910 sctca@inetworld.net For: Southern California Tribal Chairmen's Association	Donald W. Aitken, Ph.D. Senior Scientist, Energy Program UNION OF CONCERNED SCIENTISTS 2397 SHARTUCK AVENUE, SUITE 203 BERKELEY CA 94704 (510) 843-1872 donaldaitken@earthlink.net
Carl Blumstein Energy Institute UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA BERKELEY 2539 CHANNING WAY BERKELEY CA 94720	Lee Riggan VENTURA COUNTY COMMISSION ON CONCERNS & COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT 621 RICHMOND AVENUE OXNARD CA 93030 (805) 486-4725 rigganl@earthlink.net For: Ventura County Commission on Human Concerns, Concerns & Community Development
Linda Williams UTILITY REFORM PROJECT 10266 S.W. LANCASTER ROAD PORTLAND OR 97219	Philip M. Vermeulen 1335 RIDGEDALE COURT ROSEVILLE CA 95661 (916) 784-7055 pmvgov@tomatoweb.com For: Service Institute

Sam De Frawi WASHINGTON NAVY YARD 1314 HARWOOD STREET, SE WASHINGTON DC 20374-5018 (202) 685-0130 defrawis@efaches.navfac.navy.mil	Wallis J. Winegard WINEGARD ENERGY 1806 FLOWER AVENUE DUARTE CA 91010
********* STATE EMPLOYEE ***********
Zaida Amaya-Pineda Energy Division AREA 4-A 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-1109 zca@cpuc.ca.gov	David Abelson Attorney At Law CALIFORNIA ENERGY COMMISSION 1516 9TH STREET, MS-14 SACRAMENTO CA 95184 (916) 654-3951
Bruce Ceniceros CALIFORNIA ENERGY COMMISSION 1516 9TH STREET, MS-42 SACRAMENTO CA 95814-5512 (916) 653-1590	David Hungerford CALIFORNIA ENERGY COMMISSION 1516 NINTH STREET, MS-22 SACRAMENTO CA 95814 (916) 654-4906 dhungerf@energy.state.ca.us
Michael Messenger CALIFORNIA ENERGY COMMISSION 1516 9TH STREET, MS-22 SACRAMENTO CA 95184 (916) 654-4774 mmesseng@energy.state.ca.us	Monica Rudman CALIFORNIA ENERGY COMMISSION 1516 9TH STREET, MS 42 SACRAMENTO CA 95184-5512
Henry Knawls COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES DEPT. OF COMMUNITY & SENIOR SERVICES 3175 WEST 6TH STREET RM 200 LOS ANGELES CA 90020 (213) 738-2644 hknawls@co.la.ca.us	Robert C. Cagen Legal Division RM. 5124 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-2197 rcc@cpuc.ca.gov
Timothy M. Dayonot DEPT. OF COMMUNITY SERVICES AND DEV. 700 NORTH TENTH STREET RM 258 SACRAMENTO CA 95814-0338 (916) 322-2940	Darwin Farrar Legal Division RM. 5039 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-1599 edf@cpuc.ca.gov
Meg Gottstein 21496 NATIONAL STREET PO BOX 210 VOLCANO CA 95689 gottstein@volcano.net	Anne W. Premo Energy Division AREA 4-A 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-1247 awp@cpuc.ca.gov For: CPUC-ENERGY DIVISION

Meg Gottstein Administrative Law Judge Division RM. 5044 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-4802 meg@cpuc.ca.gov	John P. Rozsa Senate Energy Advisor STATE CAPITOL, ROOM 408 SACRAMENTO CA 95814
Judith Ikle Energy Division AREA 4-A 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-1486 jci@cpuc.ca.gov	Stephen J. Rutledge Consumer Services Division RM. 2206 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-1428 sjr@cpuc.ca.gov
Maurice Monson Energy Division AREA 4-A 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-3072 mdm@cpuc.ca.gov	Ulla Maija Wait Dept. Of Community Svcs & Dev. STATE OF CALIFORNIA 700 NORTH 10TH ST., ROOM 258 SACRAMENTO CA 95814-0338
Barbara A. Morton Information & Management Services Divisi RM. 2004 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-3066 bam@cpuc.ca.gov	Don Schultz Office of Ratepayer Advocates RM. SCTO 770 L STREET, SUITE 1050 Sacramento CA 95814 (916) 327-2409 dks@cpuc.ca.gov
Nancy Brockway NATIONAL CONSUMER LAW CENTER, INC. 18 TREMON STREET, SUITE 400 BOSTON MA 02108	Thomas W. Thompson Office of Ratepayer Advocates RM. 4209 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-2881 ttt@cpuc.ca.gov
Barbara Ortega Executive Division RM. 500 320 WEST 4TH STREET SUITE 500 Los Angeles CA 90013 (213) 576-7070 bho@cpuc.ca.gov	Jonathan P. Tom Energy Division AREA 4-A 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-1809 jpt@cpuc.ca.gov

Ourania M. Vlahos Legal Division RM. 5125 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-2387 omv@cpuc.ca.gov	Josie Webb Office of Ratepayer Advocates RM. 4209 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-2247 wbb@cpuc.ca.gov
Phyllis R. White Energy Division AREA 4-A 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-1955 prw@cpuc.ca.gov	Helen W. Yee Legal Division RM. 5031 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-2474 yee@cpuc.ca.gov

(END OF ATTACHMENT 1)

ATTACHMENT 2

(LIST OF ACRONYMS)

ALJ	Administrative Law Judge
CALMAC	California Measurement Advisory Council
CARE	California Alternate Rates for Energy
CBEE	California Board for Energy Efficiency
CBOs	Community-based Organizations
CSD	California Department of Community Services Development
LIAB	Low-Income Advisory Board
LIEE	Low-Income Energy Efficiency
LIGB	Low-Income Governing Board
ORA	Office of Ratepayer Advocates
PG&E	Pacific Gas and Electric Company
PY	Program Year
RER	Regional Economic Research, Inc.
RFP	Request for Proposal
RHA	Richard Heath & Associates
SCE	Southern California Edison Company
SDG&E	San Diego Gas and Electric Company
SoCal	Southern California Gas Company
WIS	Weatherization Installation Standards
Working Group	Reporting Requirements Manual Working Group

(END OF ATTACHMENT 2)