VI. Assignment of Proceeding

Michael R. Peevey is the Assigned Commissioner and Carol Brown is the assigned ALJ in this proceeding and principal hearing officer in this portion of the proceeding.

Findings of Fact

1. SDG&E conducted a competitive procurement process, the RFP, to acquire capacity to address its anticipated grid reliability shortfall beginning in 2005, as identified in its LTR.

2. The RFP was issued on May 16, 2003, seeking bids from qualified resources including turn-key natural gas-fired generating units, PPAs, demand reduction products, renewable resources, and any combination of those resources.

3. The RFP specified that the proposed resources must be located within SDG&E's service territory, or have a gen-tie directly interconnected to the electric network internal to the utility's service area, and must be capable of going on-line no later than June 1, 2007.

4. Twenty-two bids were received in response to the RFP, and 13 were found to conform to the RFP.

5. The 13 conforming bids were first evaluated against SDG&E's primary and secondary threshold criteria, then on the basis of LCBF, and finally by a thorough eight-step ranking process that factored in initial and long-term costs.

6. At the completion of the bid review and examination, and follow-up negotiations, SDG&E determined that five proposals were needed to meet its grid reliability needs: one demand reduction program, Comverge; one renewable project, Envirepel; and three gas-fired facilities that include one combustion turbine intermediate unit, Ramco, and two combined cycle power plants, Palomar and Otay Mesa.

7. The Comverge proposal plans to use DLC during the summer months to manage customer end-use equipment, specifically AC units, electric water heaters, and pump motors, targeting commercial customers and irrigation customers.

8. The Comverge proposal should be modified to include a residential customer air-conditioning cycle component, with a cost sharing mechanism of 50/50 SDG&E/Comverge, with the same price cap.

9. Costs for the Comverge program should be recorded in the Interruptible Load and Rotating Outage Programs Memorandum Account (ILROPMA). O&M and A&G expenses should be recovered from all customers through distribution rate changes effective on January 1 of the following year. Any incentive payments made to participants in the Comverge program should also be recorded in the ILROPMA.

10. SDG&E has established that the Comverge proposal will help the utility meet its grid reliability needs and will increase its portfolio of demand reduction programs.

11. We find that the Celerity proposal is a demand reduction program that is consistent with the spirit and intent of the Vision Statement and we authorize SDG&E to complete contract negotiations with Celerity on the terms that the parties agreed to in September 2003.

12. Costs for the Celerity program should be recovered along the same mechanism as allowed for the Comverge contract.

13. The Envirepel renewable project is a biomass project whereby Envirepel will contract for delivery of green waste to be burned as fuel in an environmentally acceptable manner.

14. SDG&E has established that the Envirepel project is a well-suited renewable project, will help the utility meet its grid reliability needs in the 2005 - 2007 timeframe, and will increase its portfolio of renewable resources.

15. SDG&E should record the costs for this contract in the ERRA and recover the costs through commodity rates.

16. The Ramco proposal is a 45 MW 6,000 combustion turbine project that Ramco will build, to SDG&E's satisfaction, and then will be purchased by the utility on a turn-key basis.

17. SDG&E established that Ramco will provide the utility with the benefit of utility ownership of generation and will provide intermediate power to help the utility meet its grid reliability needs 2005 - 2007.

18. We believe that SDG&E's request for a 75 basis point premium for generation assets, specifically for Ramco and Palomar, should be deferred to a cost of capital proceeding, and we find that the ROE for Ramco and Palomar is 10.90% until modified by further action of the Commission.

19. Although SDG&E established a need for Ramco and Palomar, in order to not over-burden ratepayers if there are changes in the market, we adopt TURN/UCAN/s proposal that all customers of SDG&E that are currently ineligible for direct access are obligated to pay for the stranded costs of any new generation for the next ten years.

20. Palomar is a 500 MW/base, 555 MW/peak combined cycle natural gas-fired generation plant to be built by SER and then turned over to SDG&E as a utility-owned generation project.

21. SDG&E established that Palomar is a highly efficient, low heat rate, economically and environmentally superior power plant in SDG&E's service territory and is the least cost/best fit combined cycle option for the utility.

22. SDG&E established that Palomar will enable the utility to meet its short-term grid reliability needs, as well as its long-term needs, gives the utility the benefit of a utility-owned generation asset, and is in the best interest of the consumers and ratepayers for providing needed base power.

23. Although SER is an affiliate of SDG&E, there was nothing in the record to indicate that SER's participation in the RFP, and the subsequent negotiations between the parties to reach a contract, was a violation of the ATRs, or that this deal is covered by the ban on affiliate procurement transactions.

24. However, since SER is an affiliate of SDG&E, we will incorporate the TURN/UCAN suggestion that we encourage SER to renegotiate its DWR contract for the benefit of ratepayers on terms that are competitive with today's power prices.

25. We adopt the heat rate incentive proposed by SDG&E for Palomar, with the modifications suggested by TURN/UCAN that the bench mark heat rate may be adjusted by the Commission to take into account any capital additions or betterments which increase or improve the electrical output or operating efficiency of the facility.

26. SDG&E should record any accrued incentive rewards or penalties associated with the operation of the plant in the utility's ERRA.

27. When the Palomar plant is transferred from SER to SDG&E, the utility may make in-lieu franchise fee payments to the City of Escondido and to any other cities similarly affected by the transfer in ownership of Palomar.

28. Otay Mesa is a 585 MW gas-fired combined-cycle power plant under construction by Calpine, in SDG&E's service area, that will interconnect with SDG&E's electric system at the Miguel substation.

29. The Otay Mesa proposal, as approved by the CEC, includes interconnection and certain network facilities upgrades costing $16 million.

30. However, the output of Otay Mesa will not be fully deliverable and cannot fully satisfy SDG&E's local reliability needs, without some transmission system upgrade. Whether that upgrade should be the two 238 kV lines proposed in A.04-03-008, or some alternative, will be determined during the course of the Commission's review of A.04-03-008, which determination will be informed by the CAISO's own transmission planning process.

31. SDG&E proposes a ten-year PPA with Otay Mesa, beginning January 1, 2008, to correspond with the interconnection and network upgrade work that SDG&E must construct in order to maximize the benefits from this PPA.

32. While power from Otay Mesa is not needed to meet the 2007 - 2009 grid reliability short-fall, SDG&E established that Otay Mesa will provide state-of-the-art, low heat-rate, economical, clean power to SDG&E's service area that will allow the utility to reduce its increasing RMR costs by utilizing Otay Mesa for those contracts, in lieu of the aging, expensive, inefficient units currently being used for those contracts.

33. The Otay Mesa PPA, along with the Comverge, Celerity, Envirepel, Ramco, and Palomar contracts, comports with a "hedging" strategy of having various ownership situations, different pricing and contract terms, fuel diversity, and a mix of resources.

34. SDG&E established that a mixed portfolio will allow it to ensure that it has adequate, reliable, and reasonably priced energy, including reserves, to meet both its short-term and long-term reliability needs.

35. The Commission did take an active interest in encouraging SDG&E to address its grid reliability needs, and in the Valley-Rainbow decision, D.02-12-066, when we denied the 500 kV Interconnection project, we assumed that Otay Mesa would be an in-basin generating resource available and capable of satisfying SDG&E's local reliability needs as of 2005.

36. The Commission also encouraged SDG&E to replace aging, inefficient, and environmentally unfriendly energy sources with new, efficient, state-of-the-art facilities to meet grid reliability needs, reduce RMR costs, and increase reserves-all consistent with the State's Energy Action Plan.

37. The choice of Otay Mesa as a bid winner was consistent with the RFP specifications and bidding process and the final PPA contract was negotiated fairly and was the result of arm's length negotiations.

38. SDG&E established that the Commission's failure to approve the Otay Mesa PPA now could result in the loss of a resource that could not be replaced easily.

39. SDG&E should record costs relating to the Otay Mesa PPA in its ERRA for recovery of those costs through commodity rates.

40. The Commission is not ruling on any of the conditions SDG&E attached to our approval of the Otay Mesa PPA: the DWR/Sunrise contract reallocation is postponed pending our decision on cost allocation of DWR contracts in A.00-11-035; the proposed Transmission system Enhancements will be considered in A.04-03-008; and SDG&E's request for a debt equivalency premium is deferred to an appropriate cost of capital proceeding.

41. SDG&E established that the RFP process was open, competitive, and adequately subscribed, and we find the five contracts, as modified, with Comverge, Celerity, Envirepel, Ramco, Palomar, and Otay Mesa, to be reasonable.

Conclusions of Law

1. It is reasonable to approve the contract SDG&E submitted for Comverge, as modified to include a residential customer component, which includes a 50/50 SDG&E/Comverge sharing mechanism with a price cap.

2. It is reasonable that SDG&E recover the costs for the Comverge program from the Interruptible Load and Rotating Outage Programs Memorandum Account (ILROPMA) O&M and A&G costs associated with payments made in the implementation of the contract, as well as incentives, should be recorded by SDG&E in the ILROPMA recovered from all customers through distribution rate changes effective on January 1 of the following year.

3. It is reasonable to determine that the Celerity proposal meets the standards for a demand reduction program as set forth in the Vision Statement and if SDG&E and Celerity reach a mutually satisfactory contract, we will approve it.

4. It is reasonable for SDG&E to recover the costs for this demand reduction program along the same mechanism as allowed for the Comverge contract.

5. It is reasonable to approve the Envirepel renewable project and SDG&E should record the costs for this project in the ERRA and recover the costs through commodity rates.

6. It is reasonable to approve the Ramco proposal and SDG&E should recover the costs for this utility-owned generation investment through an ROE of 10.90% until modified by further action of the Commission.

7. SDG&E's request for a 75 basis point premium for Ramco and Palomar to increase the ROE for new generation assets is deferred to a cost of capital proceeding.

8. It is reasonable for all customers of SDG&E who are currently ineligible for direct access to pay for stranded costs of any new generation project for the next ten years.

9. It is reasonable to approve the Palomar contract and SDG&E should recover the costs of that utility owned generation asset through an ROE of 10.90% until modified by further action of the Commission.

10. It is reasonable to approve the Otay Mesa ten-year PPA, but it is not reasonable to approve the conditions SDG&E attached to the PPA.

11. The Comverge, Celerity, Envirepel, Ramco, Palomar, and Otay Mesa contracts benefit consumers, are in the public interest, provide SDG&E with a diversified procurement portfolio with short-term and long-term electricity and electricity-related and demand reduction products, are consistent with SDG&E's long-term resource plan, are consistent with AB 57 and Pub. Util. Code § 454.5, and comport with the Energy Action Plan.

12. The Comverge, Celerity, Envirepel, Ramco, Palomar, and Otay Mesa contracts are all the result of a competitive procurement process that was open and adequately subscribed and consistent with Pub. Util. Code § 454.5(c)(1).

13. No certificate of public convenience and necessity is required for any of the contracts since none of the facilities will be built by the utility, and therefore the Commission does not have to take any actions required under the California Environmental Quality Act.

14. The Commission ratifies the Assigned Commissioner's Ruling of May 25, 2004, denying the motion of TURN/UCAN that sought the recusal of Commission President Peevey from any Commission vote on SDG&E's RFP motion, which is the subject of this decision.

ORDER

IT IS ORDERED that:

1. San Diego Gas & Electric Company (SDG&E) may execute the contract with Comverge as modified to include a residential customer component, with a cost sharing mechanism of 50/50 SDG&E/Comverge, and with the proposed price cap.

2. SDG&E is authorized to recover the costs of the Comverge contract from the Interruptible Load and Rotating Outage Programs Memorandum Account (ILROPMA). O&M and A&G charges and any incentive payments paid to participants will be collected from all distribution customers through the distribution rate changes effective January 1 of the following year.

3. If SDG&E and Celerity reach a mutually acceptable contract for a demand reduction proposal, SDG&E is authorized to execute the contract and recover the costs along the same mechanism established for the Comverge contract.

4. SDG&E may execute the contract with Envirepel, attached to Exhibit RFP-1 as Attachment A, and is authorized to record the costs of this contract in the ERRA and recover the costs through commodity rates.

5. SDG&E may execute a contract with Ramco, that is consistent with the terms and conditions set forth in the Ramco Term Sheet, and is authorized to recover the costs of this generation-owned asset through an established ROE of 10.90%.

6. SDG&E may execute the contract with Palomar and is authorized to recover the costs of this generation-owned asset through the established 10.90% ROE.

7. SDG&E may execute the Otay Mesa Power Purchase Agreement (PPA), attached to Exhibit RFP-8 as Attachment A, and SDG&E is authorized to record the costs of this PPA in the ERRA and recover the costs through commodity rates.

8. SDG&E may file advice letters, or tariffs, as appropriate and necessary to implement the orders, conclusions, and results reached in this decision.

9. This proceeding is closed. In the interest of effective case management, this docket, R.01-10-024, is not to be used to file motions or petitions for approval of electric resource contracts. Parties seeking such authorization should file an application.

This order is effective today.

Dated June 9, 2004, at San Francisco, California.

MICHAEL R. PEEVEY

President

GEOFFREY F. BROWN

SUSAN P. KENNEDY

Commissioners

I will file a dissent.

/s/ CARL W. WOOD

Commissioner

I will file a dissent.

/s/ LORETTA M. LYNCH

Commissioner

I reserve the right to file a concurrence.

/s/ GEOFFREY F. BROWN

Commissioner

APPENDIX A

************ APPEARANCES ************ Marc D. Joseph Attorney At Law ADAMS BROADWELL JOSEPH & CARDOZO 651 GATEWAY BOULEVARD, SUITE 900 SOUTH SAN FRANCISCO CA 94402 (650) 589-1660 mdjoseph@adamsbroadwell.com For: Coalition of California Utility Employees (CUE) and California Unions for Reliable Energy (CURE Karen Terranova ALCANTAR & KAHL, LLP 120 MONTGOMERY STREET, STE 2200 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94104 (415) 421-4143 filings@a-klaw.com Donald Brookhyser Attorney At Law ALCANTAR & KAHL LLP 1300 S.W. 5TH AVENUE, SUITE 1750 PORTLAND OR 97201 (503) 402-9900 deb@a-klaw.com For: Energy Producers and Users Coalition/Cogeneration Associations of California Michael P. Alcantar Attorney At Law ALCANTAR & KAHL, LLP 1300 SW FIFTH AVENUE, SUITE 1750 PORTLAND OR 97201 (503) 402-9900 mpa@a-klaw.com For: Cogeneration Association of California Chris King Executive Director AMERICAN ENERGY INSTITUTE 842 OXFORD ST. BERKELEY CA 94707 (510) 435-5189 ckingaei@yahoo.com For: American Energy Institute Reed V. Schmidt BARTLE WELLS ASSOCIATES 1889 ALCATRAZ AVENUE BERKELEY CA 94703-2714 (510) 653-3399 rschmidt@bartlewells.com For: California City-County Street Light Association

Danielle Merida BINGHAM MCCUTCHEN 3 EMBARCADERO, 18TH FLOOR SAN FRANCISCO CA 94111 (415) 393-2985 danielle.merida@bingham.com For: InterGen William D. Kissinger BINGHAM MCCUTCHEN THREE EMBARACADERO CENTER SAN FRANCISCO CA 94111 (415) 393-2000 william.kissinger@bingham.com For: InterGen NV Bill Powers Working Group BORDER POWER PLANT 4452 PARK BLVD., SUITE 209 SAN DIEGO CA 92116 (619) 295-2072 For: Border Power Plant Scott Blaising Attorney At Law BRAUN & BLAISING, P.C. 8980 MOONEY ROAD ELK GROVE CA 95624 (916) 682-9702 blaising@braunlegal.com For: City of Escondido Chris King CALIF. CONSUMER EMPOWERMENT ALLIANCE ONE TWIN DOLPHIN DRIVE REDWOOD CITY CA 94065 (650) 631-7230 chris@emeter.com Ronald Liebert Attorney At Law CALIFORNIA FARM BUREAU FEDERATION 2300 RIVER PLAZA DRIVE SACRAMENTO CA 95833 (916) 561-5657 rliebert@cfbf.com For: California Farm Bureau Federation Anthony Ivancovich CALIFORNIA INDEPENDENT SYS OPE CORPORATI 151 BLUE RAVINE RD FOLSOM CA 95630 (916) 351-4400 aivancovich@caiso.com

Bill Di Capo Attorney At Law CALIFORNIA POWER AUTHORITY 901 P STREET, SUITE 142A SACRAMENTO CA 95814 (916) 651-9750 baldassaro.dicapo@dgs.ca.gov For: California Power Authority Emilio E. Varanini Iii Attorney At Law CALIFORNIA POWER AUTHORITY 901 P STREET, SUITE 142A SACRAMENTO CA 95814 (916) 651-9750 emilio.varanini@dgs.ca.gov For: California Power Authority Nancy Rader CALIFORNIA WIND ENERGY ASSOCIATION 1198 KEITH AVENUE BERKELEY CA 94708 (510) 845-5077 nrader@calwea.org For: California Wind Energy Association Theresa Mueller Attorney At Law CITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO 1 DR. CARLTON B. GOODLETT PLACE SAN FRANCISCO CA 94102-4682 (415) 554-4615 randy.wu@sfgov.org For: City and County of San Francisco Frederick M. Ortlieb City Attorney CITY OF SAN DIEGO 1200 THIRD AVENUE, 11TH FLOOR SAN DIEGO CA 92101-4100 (619) 236-6318 fortlieb@sandiego.gov For: City of San Diego Martin Proctor CONSTELLATION POWER SOURCE 111 MARKET PLACE, SUITE 500 BALTIMORE MD 21202 (410) 468-3482 martin.proctor@constellation.com For: Constellation Power Source

Mark Savage Attorney At Law CONSUMERS UNION OF U.S., INC. 1535 MISSION STREET SAN FRANCISCO CA 94103 (415) 431-6747 savama@consumer.org Tyson Slocum Research Director CRITICAL MASS ENERGY/ENVIRONMENTAL PRG 215 PENNSYLVANIA AVE, SE WASHINGTON DC 20003 (202) 454-5191 For: Critical Mass Energy & Environmental Program Patrick G. Mcguire CROSSBORDER ENERGY 2560 NINTH STREET, SUITE 316 BERKELEY CA 94710 (510) 649-9790 patrickm@crossborderenergy.com For: Watson Cogeneration Company Edward W. O'Neill Attorney At Law DAVIS WRIGHT TREMAINE LLP ONE EMBARCADERO CENTER, SUITE 600 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94111-3834 (415) 276-6500 edwardoneill@dwt.com For: Intergen, N.V. Steven F. Greenwald JEFFREY P. GRAY Attorney At Law DAVIS WRIGHT TREMAINE LLP ONE EMBARCADERO CENTER, SUITE 600 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94111-3834 (415) 276-6528 stevegreenwald@dwt.com For: Calpine Corporation Lindsey How- Downing Attorney At Law DAVIS WRIGHT TREMAINE, LLP ONE EMBARCADERO, SUITE 600 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94111-3834 (415) 276-6500 lindseyhowdowning@dwt.com

Ann L. Trowbridge Attorney At Law DOWNEY, BRAND, SEYMOUR & ROHWER 555 CAPITOL MALL, 10TH FLOOR SACRAMENTO CA 95814-4686 (916) 444-1000 atrowbridge@downeybrand.com For: Joint Parties Interested in Distributed Generation Mark J. Skowronski DUKE SOLAR 3501 JAMBOREE ROAD, SUITE 606 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660 (949) 856-2200 mjskowronski@inlandenergy.com For: Solargenix Energy LLC Joseph M. Paul DYNEGY MARKETING & TRADE 5976 WEST LAS POSITAS BLVD. PLEASANTON CA 94588 (925) 469-2314 joe.paul@dynegy.com For: Dynegy Marketing and Trade Douglas K. Kerner Attorney At Law ELLISON, SCHNEIDER & HARRIS LLP 2015 H STREET SACRAMENTO CA 95814 (916) 447-2166 dkk@eslawfirm.com For: Duke Energy North America Andrew B. Brown Attorney At Law ELLISON, SCHNEIDER & HARRIS, LLP 2015 H STREET SACRAMENTO CA 95814 (916) 447-2166 abb@eslawfirm.com For: Independent Energy Producers Assoc. Lynn M. Haug Attorney At Law ELLISON, SCHNEIDER & HARRIS, LLP 2015 H STREET SACRAMENTO CA 95814-3109 (916) 447-2166 lmh@eslawfirm.com For: Department of General Services

Richard H. Hertzberg ENPEX CORPORATION 1329 STRATFORD COURT DEL MAR CA 92014 (858) 792-5505 enpex@aol.com For: ENPEX Corporation Steve Ponder FPL ENERGY, INC., LLC 980 NINTH STREET, 16TH FLOOR SACRAMENTO CA 95814 (916) 449-9596 steve_ponder@fpl.com For: FPL Energy, Inc.LLC. Curtis Kebler GOLDMAN, SACHS & CO. 2121 AVENUE OF THE STARS LOS ANGELES CA 90067 curtis.kebler@gs.com For: WPTF (Reliant Energy) Brian T. Cragg, Attorney At Law GOODIN MACBRIDE SQUERI RITCHIE & DAY LLP 505 SANSOME STREET, SUITE 900 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94111 (415) 392-7900 bcragg@gmssr.com For: Celerity Energy, Inc. James D. Squeri Attorney At Law GOODIN MACBRIDE SQUERI RITCHIE & DAY LLP 505 SANSOME STREET, SUITE 900 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94111 (415) 392-7900 jsqueri@gmssr.com For: Powerex Corp. Gregory Morris GREEN POWER INSTITUTE 2039 SHATTUCK AVE., SUITE 402 BERKELEY CA 94704 (510) 644-2700 gmorris@emf.net For: GREEN POWER INSTITUTE Jody London GRUENEICH RESOURCE ADVOCATES 582 MARKET STREET, SUITE 1020 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94104 (415) 834-2300 jlondon@gralegal.com For: The Cities of Berkeley and Santa Monica

Daniel W. Fessler HOLLAND & KNIGHT LLP 50 CALIFORNIA STREET, SUITE 2800 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94111-4726 (415) 743-6900 daniel.fessler@hklaw.com For: Appearing on behalf of James A. Boothe Andrew J. Skaff Attorney At Law LAW OFFICE OF ANDREW J. SKAFF 220 THE KNOLL ORINDA CA 94563 (925) 254-9975 andy@skafflaw.com For: Dynegy Marketing & Trade William H. Booth Attorney At Law LAW OFFICE OF WILLIAM H. BOOTH 1500 NEWELL AVENUE, 5TH FLOOR WALNUT CREEK CA 94596 (925) 296-2460 wbooth@booth-law.com For: California Large Energy Consumers Assoc. Daniel W. Douglass Attorney At Law LAW OFFICES OF DANIEL W. DOUGLASS 6303 OWENSMOUTH AVE., TENTH FLOOR WOODLAND HILLS CA 91367-2262 (818) 936-2466 douglass@energyattorney.com For: Alliance for Retail Energy Markets and Western Power Trading Forum Gregory Klatt Attorney At Law LAW OFFICES OF DANIEL W. DOUGLASS 411 E. HUNTINGTON DRIVE, SUITE 107-356 ARCADIA CA 91006 (626) 294-9421 klatt@energyattorney.com For: Alliance for Energy Markets and Western Power Trading Forum Paul Fenn LOCAL POWER 4281 PIEDMONT AVE. OAKLAND CA 94611 (510) 451-1727 paulfenn@local.org For: Ratepayers for Affordable Green Energy

John W. Leslie Attorney At Law LUCE, FORWARD, HAMILTON & SCRIPPS, LLP 11988 EL CAMINO REAL, SUITE 200 SAN DIEGO CA 92130 (858) 720-6352 jleslie@luce.com For: Coral Power, LLC Roger A. Berliner MANATT, PHELPS & PHILLIPS, LLP 1501 M STREET, NW, SUITE 700 WASHINGTON DC 20005 (202) 463-4379 rberliner@manatt.com For: County of Los Angeles Rebekah Collins MARIN CLEAN ALTERNATIVE ENERGY NOW PO BOX 605 FAIRFAX CA 94930 rebekah@marincouncil.org For: Marin Clean Alternative Energy Now Richard A. Shortz Esquire MORGAN, LEWIS & BOCKIUS LLP 300 SOUTH GRAND AVE., 22ND FLOOR LOS ANGELES CA 90071-3132 (213) 612-2500 rshortz@morganlewis.com For: Harbor Cogeneration Company Seth Hilton Attorney At Law MORRISON & FOERSTER LLP 101 YGNACIO VALLEY ROAD, SUITE 450 WALNUT CREEK CA 94596-8130 (925) 295-3371 shilton@mofo.com For: El Paso Merchant Energy Peter W. Hanschen Attorney At Law MORRISON & FOERSTER, LLP 101 YGNACIO VALLEY ROAD, SUITE 450 WALNUT CREEK CA 94596-8130 (925) 295-3450 phanschen@mofo.com For: Constellation New Energy, Inc.

Sara Steck Myers Attorney At Law 122 - 28TH AVENUE SAN FRANCISCO CA 94121 (415) 387-1904 ssmyers@att.net For: Center for Energy Efficiency and Renewable Technologies Sheryl Carter NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL 71 STEVENSON STREET, STE. 1825 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94105 (415) 777-0220 scarter@nrdc.org For: NRDC Louis Denetsosie Attorney General NAVAJO NATION DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE PO DRAWER 2010 WINDOW ROCK AZ 86515 (928) 871-6345 For: Navajo Nation Thomas D. O'Connor Attorney At Law O'CONNOR CONSULTING SERVICES, INC 5427 FENWOOD AVENUE WOODLAND HILLS CA 91367 (818) 883-1038 todoc1@aol.com For: Solargenix Energy LLC Noel Obiora Legal Division RM. 4107 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-5987 nao@cpuc.ca.gov For: ORA Mary A. Gandesbery PACIFIC GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY B30A-2486 77 BEALE STREET SAN FRANCISCO CA 94105 (415) 973-0675 magq@pge.com For: Pacific Gas & Electric Company

Evelyn C. Lee Attorney At Law PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY 77 BEALE STREET, MAILCODE 30B SAN FRANCISCO CA 94105 (415) 973-2786 ecl8@pge.com For: Pacific Gas and Electric Company John Whitting Bogy Attorney At Law PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY PO BOX 7442 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94120 (415) 973-8302 j0b5@pge.com For: Pacific Gas and Electric Company Mark R. Huffman Attorney At Law PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY 77 BEALE STREET SAN FRANCISCO CA 94106 (415) 973-3842 mrh2@pge.com For: PG&E Daniel V. Gulino RIDGEWOOD POWER MANAGEMENT, LLC 947 LINWOOD AVENUE RIDGEWOOD NJ 07450 (201) 447-9000 dgulino@ridgewoodpower.com For: RIDGEWOOD POWER, LLC William P. Short RIDGEWOOD POWER MANAGMENT, LCC 947 LINWOOD AVENUE RIDGEWOOD NJ 07450 (201) 447-9000 bshort@ridgewoodpower.com For: Ridgewood Power Managment, LLC Kelly M. Morton Attorney At Law SAN DIEGO GAS & ELECTRIC 101 W. ASH STREET, HQ13B SAN DIEGO CA 92101 (619) 696-4287 kmorton@sempra.com For: Sempra Energy

Jeffrey M. Parrott Attorney At Law SAN DIEGO GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY 101 ASH STREET, HQ 13 SAN DIEGO CA 92101 (619) 699-5063 jparrott@sempra.com For: SDG&E Lisa Urick Attorney At Law SAN DIEGO GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY 555 W. FIFTH STREET, SUITE 1400 LOS ANGELES CA 90013-1011 (213) 244-2955 lurick@sempra.com For: San Diego Gas & Electric Company Gillian A. Wright SEMPRA ENERGY 555 W. FIFTH STREET, GT14D6 LOS ANGELES CA 90013 (213) 244-3833 gwright@semprautilities.com For: SDG&E Kelly M. Morton SEMPRA ENERGY SOLUTIONS 101 ASH STREET, HQ13 SAN DIEGO CA 92101 (619) 696-4287 kmorton@sempra.com Osa Armi Attorney At Law SHUTE MIHALY & WEINBERGER LLP 396 HAYES STREET SAN FRANCISCO CA 94102 (415) 552-7272 armi@smwlaw.com For: Save Southwest Riverside County Beth A. Fox Attorney At Law SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY 2244 WALNUT GROVE AVENUE, RM. 535 ROSEMEAD CA 91770 (626) 302-6897 beth.fox@sce.com For: SCE

James Woodruff Attorney At Law SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY 2244 WALNUT GROVE AVENUE, SUITE 342 ROSEMEAD CA 91770 (626) 302-1924 woodrujb@sce.com For: Southern California Edison Company Mark Fogelman LORI ANNE DOLQUIST/CHRISTINE J. HAMMOND Attorney At Law STEEFEL, LEVITT & WEISS, P.C. ONE EMBARCADERO CENTER, 30TH FLOOR SAN FRANCISCO CA 94111 (415) 788-0900 mfogelman@steefel.com For: Navajo Nation James Paine Attorney At Law STOEL RIVES, LLP 900 SW 5TH AVE STE. 2600 PORTLAND OR 97204-1268 (503) 294-9246 jcpaine@stoel.com For: PacifiCorp Keith Mccrea Attorney At Law SUTHERLAND, ASBILL & BRENNAN 1275 PENNSYLVANIA AVENUE, NW WASHINGTON DC 20004-2415 (202) 383-0705 keith.mccrea@sablaw.com For: CA Manufacturers & Technology Assn. Thomas Tanton 4390 INDIAN CREEK ROAD LINCOLN CA 95648 (916) 645-2854 rtanton@psyber.com For: Vulcan Power Michael Green THE PACIFIC LUMBER COMPANY PO BOX 37 SCOTIA CA 95565 (707) 764-4360 energy@palco.com For: The Pacific Lumber Company

Matthew Freedman MICHEL PETER FLORIO, RANDY WU Attorney At Law THE UTILITY REFORM NETWORK 711 VAN NESS AVENUE, SUITE 350 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94102 (415) 929-8876 X 314 freedman@turn.org For: TURN Robert Finkelstein Attorney At Law THE UTILITY REFORM NETWORK 711 VAN NESS AVENUE, SUITE 350 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94102 (415) 929-8876 X 307 dedington@turn.org For: TURN Michel Peter Florio Senior Attorney THE UTILITY REFORM NETWORK (TURN) 711 VAN NESS AVENUE, SUITE 350 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94102 (415) 929-8876 mflorio@turn.org For: The Utility Reform Network (TURN) Paul C. Lacourciere Attorney At Law THELEN REID & PRIEST LLP 101 SECOND STREET, SUITE 1800 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94105 (415) 369-7601 placourciere@thelenreid.com For: Ridgewood Olinda LLC and Sierra Railroad Company Jeanne Mc Kinney Attorney At Law THELEN, REID & PRIEST 101 SECOND STREET, SUITE 1800 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94105 (415) 369-7226 jmckinney@thelenreid.com For: Ridgewood Olinda LLC Michael Theroux THEROUX ENVIRONMENTAL PO BOX 7838 AUBURN CA 95604 (530) 823-7300 X 203 mtheroux@jdmt.net For: Chateau Energy, Inc.

Julia Levin STEVEN HAMMOND UNION OF CONCERNED SCIENTISTS 2397 SHATTUCK AVENUE, SUITE 203 BERKELEY CA 94704 (510) 843-1872 jlevin@ucsusa.org For: Union of Concerned Scientists Steve Munson VULCAN POWER CO. 1183 NW WALL STREET, SUITE G BEND OR 97701 (541) 317-1984 smunson@vulcanpower.com Enoch H. Chang Attorney At Law WHITE & CASE LLP THREE EMBARCADERO CENTER, SUITE 2100 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94111 (415) 544-1100 echang@whitecase.com For: CALWEA John Rosenbaum WHITE & CASE LLP THREE EMBARCADERO CENTER, SUITE 2200 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94111 (415) 544-1110 jrosenbaum@whitecase.com For: California Cogeneration Council Lisa A. Cottle Attorney At Law WHITE & CASE LLP 3 EMBARCADERO CENTER, SUITE 2210 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94111-4050 (415) 544-1105 lcottle@whitecase.com For: California Cogeneration Council Joe Karp Attorney At Law WHITE & CASE, LLP 3 EMBARCADERO CENTER, SUITE 2210 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94111 (415) 544-1103 jkarp@whitecase.com For: California Cogeneration Council

********** STATE EMPLOYEE *********** Dan Adler Division of Strategic Planning 505 VAN NESS AVE, RM 5159 San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 355-5586 dpa@cpuc.ca.gov Peter V. Allen Administrative Law Judge Division RM. 5022 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-1123 pva@cpuc.ca.gov Nilgun Atamturk Energy Division AREA 4-A 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-5586 nil@cpuc.ca.gov Carol A Brown Administrative Law Judge Division RM. 5103 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-2971 cab@cpuc.ca.gov Gloria Bell CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF WATER RESOURCES 3310 EL CAMINO AVENUE, SUITE 120 SACRAMENTO CA 95821 (916) 574-1299 gbell@water.ca.gov Jeannie S. Lee Office Of Chief Counsel CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF WATER RESOURCES 3310 EL CAMINO AVENUE, ROOM 120 SACRAMENTO CA 95821 (916) 574-2220 jslee@water.ca.gov John Pacheco California Energy Resources Scheduling CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF WATER RESOURCES 3310 EL CAMINO AVENUE, ROOM 120 SACRAMENTO CA 95821 (916) 574-0311 jpacheco@water.ca.gov

Chief Counsel'S Office CALIFORNIA ENERGY COMMISSION 1516 9TH STREET, MS 14 SACRAMENTO CA 95814 (916) 654-5207 Proc_RPS@energy.state.ca.us Constance Leni CALIFORNIA ENERGY COMMISSION MS-20 1516 NINTH STREET SACRAMENTO CA 95814 (916) 654-4762 cleni@energy.state.ca.us David Hungerford CALIFORNIA ENERGY COMMISSION 1516 NINTH STREET, MS-22 SACRAMENTO CA 95814 (916) 654-4906 dhungerf@energy.state.ca.us Fernando De Leon Attorney At Law CALIFORNIA ENERGY COMMISSION 1516 9TH STREET, MS-14 SACRAMENTO CA 95814-5512 (916) 654-4873 fdeleon@energy.state.ca.us Heather Raitt CALIFORNIA ENERGY COMMISSION 1516 9TH STREET, MS 45 SACRAMENTO CA 95814 (916) 654-4735 hraitt@energy.state.ca.us Jennifer Tachera CALIFORNIA ENERGY COMMISSION 1516 - 9TH STREET SACRAMENTO CA 95814 (916) 654-3870 jtachera@energy.state.ca.us Karen Griffin Executive Office CALIFORNIA ENERGY COMMISSION 1516 9TH STREET, MS 39 SACRAMENTO CA 95814 (916) 654-4833 kgriffin@energy.state.ca.us

Mike Jaske CALIFORNIA ENERGY COMMISSION 1516 NINTH STREET, MS-22 SACRAMENTO CA 95814 (916) 654-4777 mjaske@energy.state.ca.us Ross Miller CALIFORNIA ENERGY COMMISSION MS-20 1516 9TH STREET SACRAMENTO CA 95184 (916) 654-4892 rmiller@energy.state.ca.us Ruben Tavares Electricity Analysis Office CALIFORNIA ENERGY COMMISSION 1516 9TH STREET, MS 20 SACRAMENTO CA 95814 (916) 654-5171 rtavares@energy.state.ca.us For: California Energy Commission Eugene Cadenasso Energy Division AREA 4-A 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-1214 cpe@cpuc.ca.gov Laurence Chaset Legal Division RM. 5131 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 355-5595 lau@cpuc.ca.gov Tara M. Dunn 901 P STREET, SUITE 142A SACRAMENTO CA 95814 (916) 651-9750 tara.dunn@dgs.ca.gov Regina DeAngelis Legal Division RM. 4107 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 355-5530 rmd@cpuc.ca.gov

Paul Douglas Energy Division AREA 4-A 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 355-5579 psd@cpuc.ca.gov Maryam Ebke Division of Strategic Planning RM. 5119 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-1112 meb@cpuc.ca.gov Julie A Fitch Executive Division RM. 5203 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 355-5552 jf2@cpuc.ca.gov John Galloway Energy Division AREA 4-A 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-2565 jhg@cpuc.ca.gov David M. Gamson Executive Division, RM 5214 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-1997 dmg@cpuc.ca.gov Farzad Ghazzagh Office of Ratepayer Advocates RM. 4209 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-1694 fxg@cpuc.ca.gov Julie Halligan Administrative Law Judge Division RM. 5101 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-2027 jmh@cpuc.ca.gov

Donna J Hines Office of Ratepayer Advocates RM. 4102 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-2520 djh@cpuc.ca.gov Trina Horner Executive Division RM. 5217 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-5132 tah@cpuc.ca.gov Aaron J Johnson Division of Strategic Planning RM. 5205 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-2495 ajo@cpuc.ca.gov Kayode Kajopaiye Energy Division AREA 4-A 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-2557 kok@cpuc.ca.gov Robert Kinosian Office of Ratepayer Advocates RM. 4205 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-1500 gig@cpuc.ca.gov Laura L. Krannawitter Office of Ratepayer Advocates RM. 4101 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-1784 llk@cpuc.ca.gov Jeanette Lo Energy Division 505 VAN NESS AVE, RM 4006 San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-1825 jlo@cpuc.ca.gov

James Loewen Energy Division 320 WEST 4TH STREET SUITE 500 Los Angeles CA 90013 (213) 620-6341 loe@cpuc.ca.gov Alan Lofaso Executive Division 770 L STREET, SUITE 1050 Sacramento CA 95814 (916) 327-7788 alo@cpuc.ca.gov Scott Logan Office of Ratepayer Advocates RM. 4209 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-1418 sjl@cpuc.ca.gov For: Office of Ratepayer Advocates Jay Luboff Energy Division AREA 4-A 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 355-5531 jcl@cpuc.ca.gov Carlos A Machado Executive Division 770 L STREET, SUITE 1050 Sacramento CA 95814 (916) 327-3277 cm2@cpuc.ca.gov Lainie Motamedi Division of Strategic Planning RM. 5119 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-1764 lrm@cpuc.ca.gov Richard A. Myers Energy Division AREA 4-A 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-1228 ram@cpuc.ca.gov

James Mcmahon Senior Engagement Manager NAVIGANT CONSULTING, INC. 3100 ZINFANDEL DRIVE, SUITE 600 RANCHO CORDOVA CA 95670 (603) 591-5898 JMcMahon@navigantconsulting.com Wade Mccartney Regulatory Analyst Iv PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION ENERGY DIVISION 770 L STREET, SUITE 1050 SACRAMENTO CA 95814 (916) 324-9010 wsm@cpuc.ca.gov Lisa Paulo Telecommunications Division AREA 3-E 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 355-5495 lp1@cpuc.ca.gov Jan Reid Office of Ratepayer Advocates RM. 4209 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-1546 ljr@cpuc.ca.gov Steven C Ross Office of Ratepayer Advocates RM. 4209 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-2140 sro@cpuc.ca.gov Kip Lipper SENATOR BYRON SHER STATE CAPITOL, ROOM 2082 SACRAMENTO CA 95814 kip.lipper@sen.ca.gov Andrew Ulmer, Attorney at Law SIMPSON PARTNERS LLP 900 FRONT STREET, SUITE 300 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94111 (415) 773-1790 andrew@simpsonpartners.com For: California Department of Water Resources

Don Schultz Office of Ratepayer Advocates RM. SCTO 770 L STREET, SUITE 1050 Sacramento CA 95814 (916) 327-2409 dks@cpuc.ca.gov Karen M Shea Energy Division AREA 4-A 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-5404 kms@cpuc.ca.gov Donald R Smith Office of Ratepayer Advocates RM. 4209 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-1562 dsh@cpuc.ca.gov Stephen St. Marie Energy Division 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-2317 sst@cpuc.ca.gov For: Energy Division Clayton K. Tang Energy Division, AREA 4 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-1823 ckt@cpuc.ca.gov Christine M. Walwyn Administrative Law Judge Division RM. 5117 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-2301 cmw@cpuc.ca.gov Bradford Wetstone Energy Division, AREA 4 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-2826 bxw@cpuc.ca.gov For: Energy Division

********* INFORMATION ONLY ********** Gerald Lahr ABAG POWER 101 8TH STREET OAKLAND CA 94607 (510) 464-7908 jerryl@abag.ca.gov David Marcus ADAMS BROADWELL & JOSEPH PO BOX 1287 BERKELEY CA 94701-1287 (510) 528-0728 dmarcus2@mindspring.com For: ADAMS BROADWELL & JOSEPH James Weil AGLET CONSUMER ALLIANCE PO BOX 1599 FORESTHILL CA 95631 (530) 367-3300 jweil@aglet.org For: Aglet Consumer Alliance Nora Sheriff Attorney At Law ALCANTAR & KAHL LLP 120 MONTGOMERY STREET, SUITE 2200 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94104 (415) 421-4143 nes@a-klaw.com Evelyn Kahl Attorney At Law ALCANTAR & KAHL, LLP 120 MONTGOMERY STREET, SUITE 2200 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94104 (415) 421-4143 ek@a-klaw.com For: Cogeneration Association of California and EPUC/Energy Producers and Users Coalition Rod Aoki Attorney At Law ALCANTAR & KAHL, LLP 120 MONTGOMERY STREET, SUITE 2200 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94104 (415) 421-4143 rsa@a-klaw.com

Christine Henning ALLIANCE POWER 2325 T STREET APT A SACRAMENTO CA 95816 (916) 451-2317 christine-henning@alliancepower.com For: ALLIANCE POWER Renee Guild Director/Reg. Affairs&Emerging Markets ALSTOM EAI CORPORATION 101 METRO DRIVE, SUITE 750 SAN JOSE CA 95110-1099 renee.guild@esca.com James H. Caldwell Jr. Policy Director AMERICAN WIND ENERGY ASSOCIATION 122 C STREET NW. STE. 300 WASHINGTON DC 20001 (202) 383-2517 jcaldwell@awea.org John Laun APOGEE INTERACTIVE, INC. 1220 ROSECRANS ST., SUITE 308 SAN DIEGO CA 92106 (619) 840-4804 jlaun@apogee.net Robert E. Anderson APS ENERGY SERVICES 1500 FIRST AVENUE, SUITE 101 ROCHESTER MN 55906 (507) 289-0800 Robert_Anderson@apses.com Ashley Houston Market Development Manager - Northeast APX INC. 30 PARKMAN STREET 3 BROOKLINE MA 02446 (617) 879-0593 ahouston@apx.com For: APX INC. Daniel Kim Consultant ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON UTILITIES & COMMER STATE CAPITOL, ROOM 5136 SACRAMENTO CA 95814 (916) 327-3277 daniel.kim@asm.ca.gov For: ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON UTILITIES & COMMERCE

Richard D. Ely ASSOCIATES, INC. 3239 RAMOS CIRCLE SACRAMENTO CA 95827-2501 (916) 363-8383 dick@adm-energy.com Lon W. House Energy Advisor ASSOCIATION OF CALIFORNIA WATER AGENCIES 4901 FLYING C ROAD CAMERON PARK CA 95682-9615 (530) 676-8956 lwhouse@innercite.com Carolyn A. Baker Attorney At Law 7456 DELTAWIND DRIVE SACRAMENTO CA 95831 (916) 399-8611 cabaker906@sbcglobal.net Catherine E. Yap BARKOVICH & YAP, INC. PO BOX 11031 OAKLAND CA 94611 (510) 450-1270 ceyap@earthlink.net Barbara R. Barkovich BARKOVICH AND YAP, INC. 31 EUCALYPTUS LANE SAN RAFAEL CA 94901 (415) 457-5537 brbarkovich@earthlink.net For: Barkovich and Yap, Inc. Ryan Wiser BERKELEY LAB MS-90-4000 ONE CYCLOTRON ROAD BERKELEY CA 94720 (510) 486-5474 rhwiser@lbl.gov Terry J. Houlihan BINGHAM MCCUTCHEN LLP 3 EMBARCADERO CENTER, 18TH FLOOR SAN FRANCISCO CA 94111 (415) 393-2022 terry.houlihan@bingham.com

Thomas S. Hixson BINGHAM MCCUTCHEN LLP THREE EMBARCADERO CENTER SAN FRANCISCO CA 94111 (415) 393-2000 thixson@mdbe.com Bruce Mc Laughlin BRAUN & BLAISING P.C. 915 L STREET, SUITE 1420 SACRAMENTO CA 95814 (916) 721-1959 mclaughlin@braunlegal.com For: California Municipal Utilities Association C. Anthony Braun BRAUN & BLAISING P.C. 915 L STREET, SUITE 1460 SACRAMENTO CA 95814 (916) 326-4449 braun@braunlegal.com Maurice Brubaker BRUBAKER & ASSOCIATES, INC. 1215 FERN RIDGE PARKWAY, SUITE 208 ST. LOUIS MO 63141 (314) 275-7007 mbrubaker@consultbai.com Bruno Jeider Power Resources Manager BURBANK WATER AND POWER 164 WEST MAGNOLIA BOULEVARD BURBANK CA 91502 (818) 238-3700 bjeider@ci.burbank.ca.us Philip D. Pettingill CAISO 151 BLUE RAVINE ROAD FOLSOM CA 95630 (916) 608-7241 ppettingill@caiso.com Lee Terry CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF WATER RESOURCES 3310 EL CAMINO AVE, LL90 SACRAMENTO CA 95821-9000 (916) 574-0664 lterry@water.ca.gov For: CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF WATER RESOURCES

Lulu Weinzimer CALIFORNIA ENERGY CIRCUIT 695 9TH AVE. NO.2 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94118 (415) 387-1025 lisaweinzimer@sbcglobal.net Clare Laufenber Gallardo CALIFORNIA ENERGY COMMISSION 1516 NINTH STREET MS 46 SACRAMENTO CA 95814 claufenb@energy.state.ca.us CALIFORNIA ENERGY MARKETS 517-B POTRERO AVENUE SAN FRANCISCO CA 94110 (415) 552-1764 Cem@newsdata.com Cassandra Sweet Managing Editor CALIFORNIA ENERGY MARKETS 517B POTRERO AVE. SAN FRANCISCO CA 94110-1431 (415) 552-1764 16 csweet@newsdata.com Shauna O'Donnell CALIFORNIA ENERGY MARKETS 517 B POTRERO AVENUE SAN FRANCISCO CA 94110 (415) 552-1764 shaunao@newsdata.com For: CALIFORNIA ENERGY MARKETS Karen Norene Mills Attorney At Law CALIFORNIA FARM BUREAU FEDERATION 2300 RIVER PLAZA DRIVE SACRAMENTO CA 95833 (916) 561-5655 kmills@cfbf.com Robert Sparks CALIFORNIA INDEPENDANT SYSTEM OPERATOR 151 BLUE RAVINE ROAD FOLSOM CA 95630 (916) 608-7144 rsparks@caiso.com For: CALIFORNIA INDEPENDENT SYSTEM OPERATOR

Legal & Regulatory Department CALIFORNIA INDEPENDENT SYS OPE CORPORATI 151 BLUE RAVINE RD. FOLSOM CA 95630 (916) 351-4400 e-recipient@caiso.com Linda Y. Sherif, Attorney At Law CALPINE CORP. PO BOX 11749 PLEASANTON CA 94588 (925) 479-6696 sherif1@calpine.com For: CALPINE CORP. Ali Amirali Director Of Transmission Management CALPINE CORPORATION 104 WOODMERE ROAD FOLSOM CA 95630 (925) 479-6760 aamirali@calpine.com For: CALPINE CORPORATION Steven S. Schleimer Director, Market/Regulatory Affairs CALPINE CORPORATION 4160 DUBLIN BLVD. DUBLIN CA 94568-6600 (415) 276-6553 sschleimer@calpine.com For: CALPINE CORPORATION CASE ADMINISTRATION 2244 WALNUT GROVE AVENUE, ROOM 370 ROSEMEAD CA 91770 (626) 302-1711 case.admin@sce.com For: Southern Californi Edison Company Ann Cavanaugh 222 W SOLA STREET APT 2 SANTA BARBARA CA 93101-6630 (209) 406-1203 brenelectricity@yahoo.com Rachel Mcmahon, Policy Analyst CEERT 1100 11TH STREET, SUITE 311 SACREMENTO CA 95814 (415) 202-0866 rachel@ceert.org

David Hoffman CELERITY ENERGY, INC. 7911 N.E. 33RD DRIVE, SUITE 280 PORTLAND OR 97211 (503) 603-9411 dhoffman@celerityenergy.com Chris Chouteau 38 DARRELL PL. SAN FRANCISCO CA 94133 (415) 290-6990 chrischouteau@earthlink.net Sean Casey CITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO 1155 MARKET STREET, 4TH FLOOR SAN FRANCISCO CA 94103 (415) 554-1551 scasey@sfwater.org Janis Lehman Principal Integrated Resource Planner CITY OF ANAHEIM 201 S. ANAHEIM BLVD., SUITE 1101 ANAHEIM CA 92805 (714) 777-9006 Willie M. Gaters Environmental Resource Manager CITY OF CHULA VISTA CITY MANAGER'S OFFICE 276 FOURTH AVENUE CHULA VISTA CA 91910 (619) 409-5918 willieg@ci.chula-vista.ca.us Steven G. Lins CITY OF GLENDALE OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY 613 EAST BROADWAY, SUITE 220 GLENDALE CA 91206-4394 (818) 548-3397 slins@ci.glendale.ca.us Eric Klinkner CITY OF PASADENA 150 LOS ROBLES AVENUE, SUITE 200 PASADENA CA 91101-2437 (626) 744-4478 eklinkner@ci.pasadena.ca.us

Jack Wood Trustee, Managing Company, Llc CLEARWOOD ELECTRIC COMPANY, LLC 21859 ANGELI PLACE GRASS VALLEY CA 95949 (530) 269-0828 jackwood@gv.net June M. Skillman COMPLETE ENERGY SERVICES, INC. 650 E. PARKRIDGE AVENUE, UNIT 110 CORONA CA 92879 (909) 280-9411 jskillman@prodigy.net Virginia Jarrow HARVEY LARSEN CONSUMERS COALITION OF CALIFORNIA 11304 JACK RABBIT TRAIL AUSTIN TX 78750 (512) 918-1025 consumersvoice@aol.com Bob Belhumeur Vice President Sales CORPORATE SYSTEMS ENGINEERING 24946 DANA FIR DANA POINT CA 92629 (949) 240-8000 Bob.Belhumeur@cox.net Maryanne Mccormick CSBRT/CSBA 954 CAROL LANE LAFAYETTE CA 94549 (703) 855-5963 mmcsba@yahoo.com V. John White CTR FOR ENERGY EFFNCY & RENEWABLE TECH 1100 - 11TH STREET, SUITE 311 SACRAMENTO CA 95184 (916) 442-7785 vjw@cleanpower.org Alison Ten Cate D&R INTERNATIONAL 711 MAIN STREET HALF MOON BAY CA 94019 (650) 726-2875 atencate@drintl.com For: D&R INTERNATIONAL

David Casentini D&R INTERNATIONAL 711 MAIN STREET HALF MOON BAY CA 94019 (650) 726-7795 dcasentini@drintl.com For: D&R INTERNATIONAL David Kates DAVID MARK & COMPANY 3510 UNOCAL PLACE, SUITE 200 SANTA ROSA CA 95403 (707) 570-1866 dkates@sonic.net Jeffrey P. Gray DAVIS WRIGHT TREMAINE LLP ONE EMBARCADERO CENTER, SUITE 600 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94111 (415) 276-6500 jeffgray@dwt.com Norman J. Furuta Attorney At Law DEPARTMENT OF THE NAVY 2001 JUNIPERO SERRA BLVD., SUITE 600 DALY CITY CA 94014-3890 (650) 746-7312 norman.furuta@navy.mil For: The Federal Executive Agencies Dale E. Fredericks DG POWER LLC PO BOX 4400 WALNUT CREEK CA 94596-0400 (925) 938-9098 dale@dgpower.com Melanie Gillette DUKE ENERGY NORTH AMERICA 980 NINTH STREET, SUITE 1420 SACRAMENTO CA 95814 (916) 441-6233 mlgillette@duke-energy.com Gregory T. Blue Regulatory Affairs Manager DYNEGY MARKETING AND TRADE 5976 W. LAS POSITAS BOULEVARD PLEASANTON CA 94588 gtbl@dynegy.com

G. Alan Comnes DYNEGY POWER CORP. 3934 SE ASH STREET PORTLAND OR 97214 alan.comnes@dynegy.com Carolyn M. Kehrein ENERGY MANAGEMENT SERVICES 1505 DUNLAP COURT DIXON CA 95620-4208 (707) 678-9506 cmkehrein@ems-ca.com Kevin Simonsen ENERGY MANAGEMENT SERVICES 646 EAST THIRD AVE DURANGO CO 81301 (970) 259-1748 kjsimonsen@ems-ca.com Janis C. Pepper ENERTRON CONSULTANTS 418 BENVENUE AVENUE LOS ALTOS CA 94024 (650) 949-5719 pepper@enertroncons.com For: ENERTRON CONSULTANTS J. Patrick Genn ENPEX CORPORATION 1329 STRATFORD COURT DEL MAR CA 92014 (858) 792-5505 enpex@aol.com Jeffrey S. Ghilardi ENRON WIND CORPORATION 13000 JAMESON ROAD TEHACHAPI CA 93561 (661) 823-6813 jeff.ghilardi@enron.com Kelly Lloyd, ENXCO INC. PO BOX 581043 N. PALM SPRINGS CA 92258 kellyl@enxco.com Kevin Porter, Vice President EXETER ASSOCIATES, INC. SUITE 310 5565 STERRETT PLACE COLUMBIA MD 21044 (410) 992-7500 porter@exeterassociates.ocm

Kent Fickett FICKETT & ASSOCIATES CONSULTING, INC. 8 EL SERENO ORINDA CA 94563 For: FICKETT & ASSOCIATES CONSULTING, INC. Barry R. Flynn FLYNN RESOURCE CONSULTANTS, INC. 5440 EDGEVIEW DRIVE DISCOVERY BAY CA 94514-9267 (925) 634-7500 brflynn@flynnrci.com Ed Chang FLYNN RESOURCE CONSULTANTS, INC. 2165 MOONSTONE CIRCLE EL DORADO HILLS CA 95762 (925) 634-7500 edchang@flynnrci.com Steven Hammond FORESIGHT ENERGY COMPANY 692 HAIGHT STREET, STE. B SAN FRANCISCO CA 94117 (415) 522-1101 shammond@foresightenergy.com Angela Kim FTI CONSULTING 353 SACRAMENTO STREET, SUITE 1800 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94111 (415) 283-4200 angela.kim@fticonsulting.com For: FTI CONSULTING Rocky Ho FTI CONSULTING 353 SACRAMENTO STREET, SUITE 1800 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94111 (415) 283-4200 rocky.ho@fticonsulting.com For: FTI CONSULTING Michael B. Day Attorney At Law GOODIN MACBRIDE SQUERI RITCHIE & DAY LLP 505 SANSOME STREET, SUITE 900 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94111 (415) 392-7900 mday@gmssr.com

John Coequyt, Energy Policy Specialist GREENPEACE USA 702 H STREET WASHINGTON DC 20001 (202) 319-2409 For: Greenpeace USA Jack Mc Gowan GRUENEICH RESOURCE ADVOCATES 582 MARKET STREET, SUITE 1020 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94104 (415) 834-2300 docket-control@gralegal.com Norman A. Pedersen, Attorney At Law HANNA & MORTON 444 FLOWER STREET, SUITE 2050 LOS ANGELES CA 90071 (213) 430-2510 npedersen@hanmor.com Craig Castagnoli HENWOOD ENERGY SERVICES 2379 GATEWAY OAK DRIVE, SUITE 200 SACRAMENTO CA 95833 (916) 569-0985 ccastagnoli@henwoodenergy.com Orlando Foote, Esq. HORTON, KNOX, CARTER & FOOTE 895 BROADWAY EL CENTRO CA 92243-2341 John Steffen IMPERIAL IRRIGATION DISTRICT 333 EAST BARIONI BOULEVARD IMPERIAL CA 92251 (760) 339-9224 jsteffen@iid.com Steven Kelly INDEPENDENT ENERGY PRODUCERS ASSN 1215 K STREET SUITE 900 SACRAMENTO CA 95814 (916) 448-9499 steven@iepa.com Nam Nguyen INLAND ENERGY 3501 JAMBOREE ROAD, SO. TOWER - STE. 606 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92660 (949) 856-2200 namnguyen@inlandenergy.com For: INLAND ENERGY

Jennifer Holmes ITRON INC. 153 WOODCREST PLACE SANTA CRUZ CA 95065 jennifer.holmes@itron.com Gayatri Schilberg JBS ENERGY 311 D STREET, SUITE A WEST SACRAMENTO CA 95605 (916) 372-0534 gayatri@jbsenergy.com Kurt J. Kammerer K.J. KAMMERER & ASSOCIATES 11264 PORTOBELO DRIVE SAN DIEGO CA 92124 (858) 229-1129 KJK@KJKammerer.com Julie Blunden Vice President KEM-XENERGY 492 9TH ST., STE. 220 OAKLAND CA 94607 (510) 891-0446 jblunden@kema-xenergy.com Dan Peaco LA CAPRA ASSOCIATES INC. 20 WINTHROP SQ BOSTON MA 02110-1229 (617) 557-9100 dpeaco@lacapra.com For: LA CAPRA ASSOCIATES INC. Kevin Simonsen LATHAM & WATKINS 701 B STREET, SUITE 2100 SAN DIEGO CA 92101 Kevin.Simonsen@LW.com Diane I. Fellman Attorney At Law LAW OFFICES OF DIANE I. FELLMAN 234 VAN NESS AVENUE SAN FRANCISCO CA 94102 (415) 703-6000 difellman@fellmanlaw.com

Galen Barbose LAWRENCE BERKELEY NATIONAL LAB MS 90-4000 1 CYCLOTRON RD. BERKELEY CA 94720 (510) 495-2593 GLBarbose@LBL.gov Mark Bolinger LAWRENCE BERKELEY NATIONAL LABORATORY MS 90-4000 ONCE CYCLOTRON ROAD BERKELEY CA 94720 (510) 495-2881 MABolinger@lbl.gov Karen Lindh LINDH & ASSOCIATES 7909 WALERGA ROAD, NO. 112, PMB 119 ANTELOPE CA 95843 (916) 729-1562 karen@klindh.com Robert L. Pettinato LOS ANGELES DEPARTMENT OF POWER & WATER NATURAL GAS GROUP 111 NORTH HOPE STREET, ROOM 1151 LOS ANGELES CA 90012-0100 (213) 367-1735 robert.pettinato@ladwp.com Richard Mccann M.CUBED 2655 PORTAGE BAY ROAD, SUITE 3 DAVIS CA 95616 (530) 757-6363 rmccann@umich.edu Jack Mcnamara Attorney At Law MACK ENERGY COMPANY PO BOX 1380 AGOURA HILLS CA 91376-1380 (818) 865-8515 jackmack@suesec.com David L. Huard Attorney At Law MANATT, PHELPS & PHILLIPS, LLP 11355 WEST OLYMPIC BOULEVARD LOS ANGELES CA 90064 (310) 312-4247 dhuard@manatt.com

Randall W. Keen Attorney At Law MANATT, PHELPS & PHILLIPS, LLP 11355 WEST OLYMPIC BLVD. LOS ANGELES CA 90064 (310) 312-4361 rkeen@manatt.com C. Susie Berlin Attorney At Law MC CARTHY & BERLIN, LLP 2005 HAMILTON AVENUE, SUITE 140 SAN JOSE CA 95125 (408) 558-0950 sberlin@mccarthylaw.com Kevin Mcspadden Attorney At Law MILBANK TWEED HADLEY & MCCLOY LLP 601 SOUTH FIGUEROA, 30TH FLOOR LOS ANGELES CA 90068 (213) 892-4563 kmcspadden@milbank.com Philippe Auclair MIRANT CORP. 1350 TREAT BLVD., SUITE 500 WALNUT CREEK CA 94597 (925) 287-3144 philippe.auclair@mirant.com For: MIRANT CORP. Robert B. Weisenmiller Phd MRW & ASSOCIATES, INC. 1999 HARRISON STREET, STE 1440 OAKLAND CA 94612-3517 (510) 834-1999 mrw@mrwassoc.com Devra Bachrach NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL 71 STEVENSON ST., STE. 1825 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94105 (415) 777-0220 dbachrach@nrdc.org Cynthia Wooten NAVIGANT CONSULTING, INC. 1126 DELAWARE STREET BERKELEY CA 94702 (510) 559-8707 cwootencohen@earthlink.net

Victoria P. Fleming NAVIGANT CONSULTING, INC. 3100 ZINFANDEL DRIVE, SUITE 600 RANCHO CORDOVA CA 95670-6026 (916) 631-3287 vfleming@navigantconsulting.com Kay Davoodi NAVY RATE INTERVENTION OFFICE WASHINGTON NAVY YARD 1314 HARWOOD STREET SE WASHINGTON DC 20374-5018 (202) 685-0130 DavoodiKR@efaches.navfac.navy.mil Mike Mace NORTHERN CALIFORNIA POWER AGENCY 180 CIRBY WAY ROSEVILLE CA 95678-6420 (916) 781-7291 mike.mace@ncpa.com Harold M. Romanowitz Chief Operating Officer OAK CREEK ENERGY SYSTEMS, INC. 14633 WILLOW SPRINGS ROAD MOJAVE CA 93501 (661) 822-6863 hal@rwitz.net Sara Pictou Executive Assistant OAK CREEK ENERGY SYSTEMS, INC. 14633 WILLOW SPRINGS ROAD MOJAVE CA 93501 (661) 822-6863 sara@oakcreekenergy.com Donald C. Liddell P. C. OFFICES OF DANIEL W. DOUGLASS, A.P.C. 2928 2ND AVENUE SAN DIEGO CA 92103 (619) 993-9096 liddell@energyattorney.com Jonathan M. Jacobs PA CONSULTING SERVICES INC 75 NOVA DRIVE PIEDMONT CA 94610 jon.jacobs@paconsulting.com

PACIFIC GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY MAILCODE B30A PO BOX 770000 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94177 cpuccases@pge.com For: PACIFIC GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY Valerie J. Winn PACIFIC GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY 77 BEALE STREET, B9A SAN FRANCISCO CA 94105 (415) 973-3839 vjw3@pge.com Cecilia Montana PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY 77 BEALE STREET SAN FRANCISCO CA 94105 (415) 973-1595 cfm3@pge.com Ed Lucha PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY MAIL CODE: B9A PO BOX 770000 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94177 (415) 973-3872 ell5@pge.com Sebastien Csapo PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY MAIL CODE B9A PO BOX 770000 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94177 sscb@pge.com Jon Welner PAUL HASTINGS JANOFSKY & WALKER LLP 55 SECOND STREET, 24TH FLOOR SAN FRANCISCO CA 94105-3441 (415) 856-7207 jonwelner@paulhastings.com George A. Perrault PERRAULT CONSULTING 1723 FORD AVENUE REDONDO BEACH CA 90278 (310) 379-0901 perrault@perrcon.net

Stanley I. Anderson POWER VALUE INCORPORATED 964 MOJAVE CT WALNUT CREEK CA 94598 (925) 938-8735 sia2@pwrval.com Anthony Des Lauriers Marketing Manager POWEREX 666 BURRARD STREET, SUITE 1400 VANCOUVER BC V6C 2X8 CANADA (604) 891-6018 anthony.des.lauriers@powerex.com Donald Winslow PPM ENERGY 650 N.E. HOLLADAY, SUITE 700 PORTLAND OR 97232 (503) 813-5406 don.winslow@ppmenergy.com Donald Gilligan PREDICATE LLC 1 POST OFFICE SQUARE SHARON MA 02067 (781) 793-0250 d.d.gilligan@worldnet.att.net Karen P Paull Legal Division RM. 5027 505 VAN NESS AVE San Francisco CA 94102 (415) 703-2630 kpp@cpuc.ca.gov Eileen Parker QUANTUM CONSULTING 2030 ADDISON STREET BERKELEY CA 94704 (510) 540-7200 eparker@qcworld.com Steve S. Rupp R. W. BECK, INC. 2710 GATEWAY OAKS DR., STE 300S SACRAMENTO CA 95833-3502 (916) 929-3653 srupp@rwbeck.com

Peter Bray RAY AND ASSOCIATES SUITE 2 3566 17TH STREET SAN FRANCISCO CA 94110-1093 (415) 437-1633 petertbray@yahoo.com Donald W. Schoenbeck RCS, INC. 900 WASHINGTON STREET, SUITE 780 VANCOUVER WA 98660 (360) 737-3877 dws@r-c-s-inc.com For: RCS, INC. Jim Ross RCS, INC. 500 CHESTERFIELD CENTER, SUITE 320 CHESTERFIELD MO 63017 (314) 530-9544 jimross@r-c-s-inc.com Joanna Stone Poole REALENERGY 300 CAPITOL MALL, SUITE 120 SACRAMENTO CA 95814 (916) 325-2500 jpoole@realenergy.com Steven A Greenberg REALENERGY 4100 ORCHARD CANYON LANE VACAVILLE CA 95688 (916) 325-2500 steveng@destrategies.com For: REALENERGY Kurt W. Bilas Senior Counsel RELIANT ENERGY POWER GENERATIONS, INC. 801 PENNSYLVANIA AVE., N.W. SUITE 620 WASHINGTON DC 20004 (202) 783-7220 kbilas@reliant.com Scott Piscitello RES NORTH AMERICA, LLC 1 SW COLUMBIA STREET, SUITE 460 PORTLAND OR 97258 (503) 219-9000 For: RES NORTH AMERICA, LLC

James Ac Mcdermott Managing Member RUSHEEN CAPITAL PARTNERS, LLC 2332 MANDEVILLE CYN RD., STE 1000 BRENTWOOD CA 90049 (310) 230-3889 jim.mcdermott@rusheen.com For: RUSHEEN CAPITAL PARTNERS, LLC C. Anthony Braun Special Counsel SACRAMENTO MUNICIPAL UTILITIES ASSN 915 L STREET, SUITE 1460 SACRAMENTO CA 95814-3705 (916) 326-4449 braun@braunlegal.com For: BRAUN & BLAISING, P.C. Rob Roth SACRAMENTO MUNICIPAL UTILITY DISTRICT 6201 S STREET MS 75 SACRAMENTO CA 95817 (916) 732-6131 rroth@smud.org Gillian Wright SAN DIEGO GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY 555 W. FIFTH STREET, SUITE 1400 LOS ANGELES CA 90013 (213) 244-3833 gwright@semprautilities.com For: San Diego Gas & Electric Company James Ozenne SAN DIEGO GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY 555 W. FIFTH STREET, GT14D LOS ANGELES CA 90013-1011 (213) 244-3821 jozenne@semprautilities.com For: SAN DIEGO GAS & ELECTRIC Joseph Kloberdanz SAN DIEGO GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY 8330 CENTURY PARK COURT SAN DIEGO CA 92123 (858) 654-1771 jkloberdanz@semprautilities.com Scott J. Anders SAN DIEGO REGIONAL ENERGY OFFICE 8520 TECH WAY - SUITE 110 SAN DIEGO CA 92123 (858) 244-1180 san@sdenergy.org

Susan Freedman Senior Policy Analyst SAN DIEGO REGIONAL ENERGY OFFICE 8520 TECH WAY, SUITE 110 SAN DEIGO CA 92123 (858) 244-1186 saf@sdenergy.org Michael Hyams SAN FRANCISCO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMM 1155 MARKET ST., 4/F SAN FRANCISCO CA 94103 (415) 554-1513 mhyams@sfwater.org For: SAN FRANCISCO PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION Michael Rochman SCHOOL PROJECT UTILITY RATE REDUCTION 1430 WILLOW PASS ROAD, SUITE 240 CONCORD CA 94520 (925) 743-1292 rochmanm@spurr.org Colin Murchie Legislative Assistant SEIA 1616 H STREET NW, 8/F WASHINGTON DC 20006 (202) 628-7745 cmurchie@seia.org For: SEIA Bruce J. Williams Manager, Regulatory Affairs Case Mgmt SEMPRA ENERGY 101 ASH STREET, HQ14A SAN DIEGO CA 92101 (619) 696-4488 bwilliams@sempra.com Douglas Mitchell SEMPRA ENERGY GLOBAL ENTERPRISES 101 ASH STREET, HQ-15G SAN DIEGO CA 92101 (619) 696-4246 dmitchell@sempraglobal.com Helen Hitchins Regulatory Analyst SEMPRA ENERGY SOLUTIONS 101 ASH STREET, HQ-9 SAN DIEGO CA 92101 (619) 696-4816 Hhitchens@SempraSolutions.com

Helen R. Hitchens SEMPRA ENERGY SOLUTIONS 101 ASH STREET, HQ09 SAN DIEGO CA 92101-3017 hhitchens@semprasolutions.com Lawrence Lingbloom Consultant SENATE ENERGY, UTILITIES & COMMUNICATION STATE CAPITOL, ROOM 4040 SACRAMENTO CA 95814 (916) 445-9764 lawrence.lingbloom@sen.ca.gov Robert Ellery Director Of Energy Resources SIERRA PACIFIC INDUSTRIES 19794 RIVERSIDE AVE. ANDERSON CA 96007 (530) 378-8179 bellery@spi-ind.com David M. Norris Associate General Counsel SIERRA PACIFIC POWER COMPANY 6100 NEIL ROAD RENO NV 89511 (775) 834-5696 dnorris@sppc.com David Saul SOLEL INC. PO BOX 811 BEIT SHEMESH IS 99107 ISRAEL david.saul@solel.com For: SOLEL INC. Andrea Mcadoo, Law Department SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON CASE ADMINISTRATION 2244 WALNUT GROVE AVE ROSEMEAD CA 91770 (626) 302-4421 andrea.mcadoo@sce.com For: SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON Bruce Foster, Regulatory Affairs SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY 601 VAN NESS AVENUE, STE. 2040 SAN FRANCISCO CA 94102 (415) 775-1856 fosterbc@sce.com For: SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON

Frank J. Cooley Attorney At Law SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY 2244 WALNUT GROVE AVENUE RM 345 ROSEMEAD CA 91770 (626) 302-3115 frank.cooley@sce.com Laura Genao, Attorney At Law SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY 2244 WALNUT GROVE AVENUE ROSEMEAD CA 91770 (626) 302-6842 laura.genao@sce.com Meredith E. Allen, Atorney At Law SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA GAS COMPANY 101 ASH STREET, HQ13 SAN DIEGO CA 92101 (619) 699-5050 meallen@sempra.com For: Sempra Energy Excetral K. Caldwell, Snior Attorney THE WILLIAM COMPANIES, INC. ONE WILLIAMS CENTER, SUITE 4100 TULSA OK 74172 (918) 573-6413 excetral.caldwell@williams.com For: THE WILLIAMS COMPANIES, INC. Alex A. Goldberg THE WILLIAMS COMPANIES, INC. ONE WILLIAMS CENTER SUITE 4100, MS41-3 TUSLA OK 74172 (918) 573-3901 Alex.Goldberg@williams.com Darcie Loth TRUE PRICING 2 NORTH LAKE AVENUE, SUITE 1040 PASADENA CA 91101 (626) 578-3415 dloth@truepricing.com Robert Berman Office Of Policy Analysis U.S. DEPARTMENT OF INTERIOR 1849 C STREET, NW WASHINGTON DC 20240 (202) 208-3751 rberman@ios.doi.gov For: U.S. DEPARTMENT OF INTERIOR

Michael Shames Attorney At Law UTILITY CONSUMERS' ACTION NETWORK 3100 FIFTH AVENUE, SUITE B SAN DIEGO CA 92103 (619) 696-6966 mshames@ucan.org Andrew J. Van Horn Principal VAN HORN CONSULTING 61 MORAGA WAY, SUITE 1 ORINDA CA 94563-3029 (925) 254-3358 vhconsult@earthlink.nel Patricia Vanmidde Consultant 22006 N 55TH ST. PHOENIX AZ 85054 (480) 515-2849 pvanmidde@earthlink.net Robin J. Walther 1380 OAK CREEK DRIVE, NO. 316 PALO ALTO CA 94304-2016 (650) 330-0717 rwalther@pacbell.net Tim Muller Legal Department WILLIAMS ENERGY SERVICES ONE WILLIAMS CENTER, MD 41-3 TULSA OK 74172 (918) 573-1480 tim.muller@williams.com For: WILLIAMS ENERGY SERVICES Kevin Woodruff WOODRUFF EXPERT SERVICES 1100 K STREET, SUITE 204 SACRAMENTO CA 95814 (916) 442-4877 kdw@woodruff-expert-services.com

Commissioner Geoffrey F. Brown, Concurring:

The decision is important because of our obligation to ensure that SDG&E ratepayers can depend on sufficient service reliability to ensure no blackouts or power shortages, except in rare, extreme situations. Commercial necessity and civic regularity require this. The basic principle of regulation, that such power must be provided at reasonable rates, creates a countervailing tension that has made this procurement case such a conundrum.

Leaving aside Otay Mesa for the moment, I am convinced that the Palomar plant, the Ramco project, the Celerity program and the other proposals before us today are worthwhile and beneficial, both in terms of reliability and rate impacts. SDG&E did a good job soliciting a wide variety of short-term power procurement proposals. The range of winning bids shows a great deal of creativity and diversity among the bidders. In sum, these projects essentially meet SDG&E's energy and capacity needs through 2008.

With respect to Otay Mesa, I have worked hard to understand both the pro and con arguments about this project. Before I discuss these issues, I need to address concerns raised by TURN and UCAN about the process by which the proposal was developed.

There have been allegations of "behind-the-scenes" meddling by Commission personnel in the Otay Mesa contract negotiations. TURN/UCAN filed a motion to recuse President Peevey from voting in this matter because of his active encouragement of the agreement. I believe the ALJ properly denied the motion because the requisite showing of evidence of an "unalterably closed mind" on the issue was not sufficiently demonstrated. There is an inherent tension between a commissioner's role as a gubernatorially-designated president and his duty as a quasi-judicial hearing officer.

The president has an obligation, pursuant to his duty under Public Utilities Code §305, to direct the executive director, the general counsel, and commission staff. Presumably, this power was conferred by the legislature with some expectation that the president would function in an executive fashion as well as a judicial one. Similarly, there is an inherent tension between a commissioner's role as assigned commissioner who helps craft a decision and his concurrent duty to consider it fairly. Though not unknown, it is rare that assigned commissioners conclude that their own authorial handiwork was flawed and then argue on behalf of an alternate.

Personally, I do not think that I would have involved myself and our staff in this proceeding in the same way as occurred. However, as TURN/UCAN pointed out, there is no indication that any unlawful or unethical acts occurred here. What was at issue was whether the conflicting roles created an appearance of impermissible bias. While this was a close question, I do not think the evidence adduced was sufficient to show such bias.

Despite the imperfections of the process, I believe one can make one's decision on the merits of the case.

The "pro" argument on Otay Mesa is, in essence, the "bird in the hand" argument. Here is a plant that we know can meet the utility's energy, capacity and reliability needs for 10 years starting in 2008. It is unclear whether there is another plant, or any combination of power plants, transmission projects and other solutions that can meet these needs for that time period. Although it is possible that the cost may be higher than we would like, we should strike while the iron is hot, because we should not take the risk of being caught short.

One "con" argument is that there is not a clear need for the full amount of power provided by this plant in the near future. Undoubtedly, SDG&E will need to add to its resources at some point in the future, but Otay Mesa may well be premature in 2008. The second "con" argument is on the cost side. The Otay contract is nominally costly in terms of $/MWH, and there may be excessive capacity costs in the early years. However, there are RMR (Reliability Must Run) benefits from building Otay, and benefits from substitution of cleaner, more efficient power.

In reviewing the cold record and attempting to bring it to life, I have spoken to the parties, the ISO, our staff, the ALJ and many members of the public about this proceeding. There is no doubt in my mind that the ratepayers in the San Diego area do not want a repeat of the shortages and uncertainty of the energy crisis of the past few years. I believe the public and the business community in the San Diego area are willing to pay a little extra for insurance that the past will not be repeated. I have been criticized on these grounds for voting against the Valley-Rainbow transmission project, and I am very sensitive to the concerns of the community.

The alternative to approving Otay Mesa at this time is to put out a new RFP (request for proposal) and attempt to find a lower cost solution than this plant to the undeniable resource need in San Diego. The problem is the lack of certainty in that statement - what specific plants? what exact projects? While there are a number of possible candidates, there is no guarantee that any viable and less expensive option will surface.

In this situation, I believe there is great value in choosing the "bird in the hand," even if it is possible that it is a little more expensive than a theoretical, or even a likely but still uncertain, alternative. By my very rough estimates, the potential extra net costs of approving Otay Mesa are less than 1 per cent of SDG&E's total rates. This is a relatively small price to pay for ensuring the economic and energy viability of the region.

Accordingly, I concur in the Commission's decision. I agree with the decision's finding that the conditions that SDG&E says it needs in order to accept this contract are either unnecessary or premature. My mind is open to future disposition of such issues as the reallocation of the Sunrise contract and consideration of debt equivalence. These are not necessary components to get this project moving.

/s/ GEOFFREY F. BROWN

Geoffrey F. Brown

Commissioner

San Francisco, California

June 9, 2004