Service of OIR
The initial service list for this OIR is attached as Appendix C; it is the list used for the preliminary meetings discussed earlier, with modifications and additions requested by attendees. Intervenors, utilities, and others may have their names added to the service list by calling or sending an e-mail to the Commission's Process Office (415-703-2021;
prc@cpuc.ca.gov).11 Parties are encouraged to use the Internet as much as possible for serving documents, and for that purpose they are referred to Rule 2.3.1 (service by electronic mail).
Finding of Fact
The proposals in the foregoing OIR for adjusting hourly rates and ratesetting methodology for compensation work performed in 2006 by intervenors' representatives appear reasonable in light of data submitted by utilities, discussion at meetings before this OIR, and letters submitted by TURN and UCS.
Conclusion of Law
The compensation proposals in the foregoing OIR should be further considered through a process of public review and comment.
IT IS ORDERED that:
1. The following utilities are respondents in this proceeding: Pacific Gas and Electric Company; San Diego Gas & Electric Company; Southern California Gas Company; Southern California Edison Company; Pacific Bell Telephone Company d/b/a AT&T California; and Verizon California Inc. However, the compensation rules adopted in this proceeding shall apply to all electric, gas, water and telephone utilities, as specified in Public Utilities Code Section 1801.3(a). All such utilities are invited to participate.
2. The proceeding is quasi-legislative. No hearings are required.
3. The respondents shall file and serve additional data, and all parties may file and serve comments, consistent with the foregoing scoping and schedule.
4. The Assigned Commissioner or Administrative Law Judge may adjust the schedule in the Order Instituting Rulemaking as may be appropriate in light of comments on the proposals but consistent with timely adoption of hourly rates for intervenors.
This order is effective today.
Dated August 24, 2006, at San Francisco, California
MICHAEL R. PEEVEY
President
GEOFFREY F. BROWN
DIAN M. GRUENEICH
JOHN A. BOHN
RACHELLE B. CHONG
Commissioners
APPENDIX A
Letter of June 15, 2006 from
Union of Concerned Scientists
(Table 2 omitted)
The Union of Concerned Scientists ("UCS") submits this letter proposal for the setting of the rates of experts and non-attorney advocates (hereafter "experts") in Commission decisions awarding intervenor compensation. This letter is submitted in response to discussions during the informal meeting on intervenor compensation rates chaired by both of you on June 1, 2006, and specifically, in response to ALJ Kotz's suggestion that UCS follow up in writing the oral proposal we made that day regarding the implementation of D.05-11-031 in the setting of expert rates.
This proposal responds to the concern raised by UCS, and echoed by others, that D.05-11-031, while it establishes five experience tiers and associated rate ranges for attorneys, sets no corresponding experience tiers and rate ranges for experts. Establishing experience tiers with associated rates is important because it provides a structured, consistent approach for recognizing the relevance of experience level in the setting of intervenor compensation rates both for established and new intervenors at the Commission. UCS understands that the inconsistent treatment contained in D.05-11-031 with respect to attorney and expert rates is due solely to the fact that the respondent utilities provided a more limited data set for expert rates than was provided for attorney rates. This in turn made the Commission reluctant to establish the same kinds of experience tiers and associated rate ranges for experts that it did for attorneys. UCS submits that this data limitation does not prevent the Commission from reasonably applying consistent treatment to both attorneys' and experts' rates in this respect and we believe that is important to do so as matters of equity and fairness and the well being of the intervenor compensation program. Our proposal responds to this need.
The absence of expert experience tiers opens up the possibility that the Commission may award an extremely experienced expert, e.g., someone with 20 years' experience, a rate that is at the very low end of the compensation range for experts. Such a result is preventable in the case of attorneys, whether they do or do not have a previously established intervenor rate. For an attorney new to the intervenor compensation program the Commission would award a rate within the range for that attorney's experience level, i.e., the range established for attorneys with at least 13 years of experience. Thus, this attorney would receive a rate of at least $270 per hour, which is twice the lowest attorney rate and 38% of the way between the lowest attorney rate ($135) and the highest attorney rate ($490). For an established intervenor attorney whose previous rate is below the applicable rate range, D.05-11-031 provides a means for increasing that rate to within the applicable range for the attorney's experience tier. However, since there are no corresponding experience tiers for experts, a comparably experienced expert, new or established, potentially could receive a rate that is at or near the low end of the expert rate range established by D.05-11-031.
It would seem more fair and consistent if this expert's rate were set using the equivalent parameters used for attorneys. Applying this principle would mean that the expert's rate would also be no lower than 38% of the way up from lowest expert rate ($110) to the highest expert rate ($360), or $205. As it stands currently, this expert could conceivably receive a rate well below this level.
Since UCS trusts that the Commission originally intended to develop experience tiers for experts (i.e., we believe that no inequity between attorneys and experts was intended), we propose that experience tiers be established for expert rates that are identical to the attorney experience tiers, and further, that expert rates be derived for each tier that are exactly proportionate to the rate ranges that have been established for attorneys. For example, if the attorney rate range for the lowest experience level spanned 20% of the entire attorney range for all experience levels, then the rate range for the lowest expert experience level would span 20% of the entire expert rate range. The existing low and high rates ($110 and $360, respectively) for experts of course would remain the same. We further propose that the ALJ Division apply this experience-based rate structure when making rate determinations, just as it currently does for attorneys. We do not believe that D.05-11-031 needs to be changed to bring this into effect since the ALJ Division is obligated in any case to apply judgment in awarding intervenor rates. Adopting our proposal would simply be creating a consistent, reasonable structure for making such judgments in setting experts' rates, as has been done in the setting of attorneys' rates.
Table 1 on the following page contains the resulting experience-based rate ranges for experts using this method. In the electronic transmission of this letter Table 2 is also provided, which is the Excel spreadsheet version of Table 1. Table 2 enables the reader to view the formula used to derive the expert rates.
|
|
|
|
|
Table 1. Derivation of Intervenor Expert Rate Ranges by Experience Level Based on Current Intervenor Attorney Rate Ranges |
Experience Tier (yrs) |
Rate Range |
Attorneys' Hourly Rate ($) |
Attorney "Escalation Factor" |
Derived Experts' Hourly Rate with Attorney Escalation Factor Applied ($) |
0 to 2 |
Low |
135 |
0.00 |
110 |
|
High |
190 |
0.15 |
149 |
3 to 4 |
Low |
185 |
0.14 |
145 |
|
High |
220 |
0.24 |
170 |
5 to 7 |
Low |
250 |
0.32 |
191 |
|
High |
270 |
0.38 |
205 |
8 to 12 |
Low |
270 |
0.38 |
205 |
|
High |
325 |
0.54 |
244 |
13+ |
Low |
270 |
0.38 |
205 |
|
High |
490 |
1.00 |
360 |
| |
|
|
|
|
NOTES: |
|
|
|
|
1. Rates in boldface are those contained in D.05-11-031. Rates in italic face are those derived by applying the escalation factor. |
2. The Attorney "Escalation Factor" measures the degree to which a given attorney rate moves from the lowest attorney rate of $135 to the highest attorney rate of $490. Thus, a rate exactly in the middle of this range (i.e., $312.50) would have an escalation factor of 0.5. The calculated Attorney Escalation Rates are then used to derive a corresponding low and high Expert Rate for each experience tier. This is done by multiplying each escalation factor by the span between the lowest and highest Expert Rate, which is $250 ($360 minus $110), and adding the result to the lowest Expert Rate ($110). |
We look forward to your response to this proposal and would be happy to respond to any questions. We have emailed a copy of this letter to the informal distribution list for R.04-10-010 that was used by the Commission to announce the June 1 meeting. We apologize in advance if interested individuals are not on this list and we would appreciate any efforts to forward this letter to such individuals.
Albany, CA 94706
Phone: 510.528.8953
Fax: 510.295-2598
E-Mail:
clyde.murley@comcast.net
cc: Informal distribution list for R.04-10-010
(END OF APPENDIX A)
APPENDIX B
2005 Expert Rates
Adopted Rates Compared to Minimum UCS Proposal Rates
(Decisions Issued July 2005 - June 2006)
Expert
|
Experience (Yrs.)
|
Adopted 2005 Rate ($)
No COLA Added (Decision #) |
UCS Min. Rate ($) No COLA |
Approx. % Increase |
| |
|
|
|
|
Marcus |
13+ |
210 (D0604012) |
210 |
0% |
Weil |
13+ |
250 (D0510009) |
250 |
0% |
Morris |
13+ |
210 (D0510030) |
210 |
0% |
Nogee |
13+ |
232 (D0604022) |
232 |
0% |
Costa |
13+ |
230 (D0604021) |
230 |
0% |
Phillips |
13+ |
335 (D0604021) |
335 |
0% |
Czahar |
13+ |
240 (D0606049) |
240 |
0% |
Gamboa |
13+ |
360 (D0604021) |
360 |
0% |
Chabran |
13+ |
200 (D0604036) |
205 |
2% |
Thayer |
13+ |
200 (D0601034) |
205 |
2% |
| |
|
|
|
|
Woychik |
13+ |
185 (D0606048) |
205 |
11% |
Fowells |
13+ |
180 (D0604036) |
205 |
14% |
Fox |
13+ |
175 (D0606056) |
205 |
17% |
McCann |
10 |
175 (D0604065) |
205 |
17% |
Moss |
10 |
175 (D0604065) |
205 |
17% |
Murley |
13+ |
173 (D0604022) |
205 |
18% |
| |
|
|
|
|
Schilberg |
13+ |
165 (D0604012) |
205 |
24% |
Vaeth |
5 |
150 (D0604027) |
191 |
27% |
Nahigian |
13+ |
155 (D0604012) |
205 |
32% |
Reid |
12 |
150 (D0606026) |
205 |
37% |
Miller |
13+ |
150 (D0604005) |
205 |
37% |
Montes |
13+ |
150 (D0604036) |
205 |
37% |
Rafferty |
4 |
100 (D0606056) |
145 |
45% |
| |
|
|
|
|
Ryan |
13+ |
140 (D0604028) |
205 |
46% |
Hall |
13+ |
140 (D0604028) |
205 |
46% |
Mitchell |
13+ |
140 (D0602016) |
205 |
46% |
Fenn |
12 |
130 (D0605037) |
191 |
47% |
Ruszovan |
13+ |
135 (D0604012) |
205 |
52% |
Schlegal |
13+ |
135 (D0601034) |
205 |
52% |
| |
|
|
|
|
Galloway |
7 |
120 (D0604022) |
191 |
59% |
Frehling |
6 |
120 (D0605037) |
191 |
59% |
Patrick |
13+ |
120 (D0605037) |
205 |
71% |
Wang |
8 |
120 (D0604005) |
205 |
71% |
Chang |
6 |
110 (D0604005) |
191 |
74% |
Adams |
13+ |
110 (D0509037) |
205 |
86% |
(END OF APPENDIX B)
************ SERVICE LIST ***********
Last Update on 07-JUL-2006 by: SMJ
R0410010 INITIAL LIST
APPENDIX C
************ APPEARANCES ************
William P. Adams
ADAMS ELECTRICAL SAFETY CONSULTING
716 BRETT AVENUE
ROHNERT PARK CA 94928-4012
(707) 795-7549
Ronald L. Knecht
ADVOCATES FOR THE PUBLIC INTEREST
1009 SPENCER ST
CARSON CITY NV 89703-5422
(650) 968-0115
ronknecht@aol.com
James Weil
Director
AGLET CONSUMER ALLIANCE
PO BOX 37
COOL CA 95614
(530) 885-5252
jweil@aglet.org
Dan Geis
AGRICULTURAL ENERGY CONSUMERS ASSO.
925 L STREET, SUITE 800
SACRAMENTO CA 95814
(916) 447-6206
dgeis@dolphingroup.org
David J. Miller
Attorney At Law
AT&T CALIFORNIA
ROOM 2018
525 MARKET STREET
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94105
(415) 778-1393
davidjmiller@att.com
For: AT&T California
Agnes Ng
Attorney At Law
AT&T COMMUNICATIONS OF CALIFORNIA, INC.
525 MARKET ST. 20TH FLOOR 4
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94105
Agnes Ng
AT&T COMMUNICATIONS OF CALIFORNIA, INC.
525 MARKET ST. 20TH F. 4TH
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94101
julianchang@lga.att.com
Sarah Deyoung
Executive Director
CALTEL
50 CALIFORNIA STREET, SUITE 1500
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94111
(925) 465-4396
deyoung@caltel.org
|
Louisa Lam
Attorney At Law
AT&T COMMUNICATIONS OF CALIFORNIA, INC.
525 MARKET ST. 18TH FLOOR, WB 31
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94101
Roger Kropke
BEAR VALLEY ELECTRIC SERVICE
PO BOX 1547
BIG BEAR LAKE CA 92315
kswitzer@scwater.com
Sharon De Cray
CALIFORNIA ALLIANCE OF INFORMATION SRVCS
C/O EDEN I&R
570 B STREET
HAYWARD CA 94541
(510) 537-2710
decray@edenir.org
Glenn Semow
CALIFORNIA CABLE & TELECOMM. ASSOC.
360 22ND STREET, STE. 750
OAKLAND CA 94612
(510) 628-8043
grs@calcable.org
J. Kendrick Kresse
CALIFORNIA CENTER FOR LAW AND THE DEAF
14895 EAST 14TH STREET, SUITE 220
SAN LEANDRO CA 94578
(510) 483-0922
calclad@deaflaw.org
Andrew Ulmer
CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF WATER RESOURCE
1416 NINTH STREET, SUITE 1118
SACRAMENTO CA 95814
(916) 653-8826
aulmer@water.ca.gov
Bruce E. Stanton
Association,Inc.
CALIFORNIA MOBILEHOME RESOURCE & ACTION
1530 ALAMEDA
THE GARDEN ALAMEDA, SUITE 115
SAN JOSE CA 95126
(408) 971-0900
Francis S. Ferraro
Vice President
CALIFORNIA WATER SERVICE COMPANY
1720 N. 1ST STREET
SAN JOSE CA 95112-4598
(408) 367-8200
sferraro@calwater.com
Mark Savage
Attorney At Law
CONSUMERS UNION OF U.S., INC.
1535 MISSION STREET
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94103
(415) 431-6747
savama@consumer.org
|
E.B. Tommy Thomas
President
CHOCTAW COMM. INC. DBA SMOKE SIGNAL COMM
11013 FUQUA ST.
HOUSTON TX 77089-2510
(713) 779-0692
Peter Frech
CITIZENS CONCERNED ABOUT EMFS
PO BOX 120
SAN RAMON CA 94583
(925) 830-4655
pfrech@opendomain.com
Charles E. Born
Manager-State Government Affairs
CITIZENS TELECOMMUNICATIONS CO. OF CA
PO BOX 340
ELK GROVE CA 95759
cborn@czn.com
Dave Hennessy
CMRAA
PO BOX 7468
SAN JOSE CA 95150-7468
(408) 244-8134
cmraa@aol.com
Clyde Murley
CONSULTANT
600 SAN CARLOS AVENUE
ALBANY CA 94706
(510) 528-8953
clyde.murley@comcast.net
For: San Luis Obispo Mothers for Peace
Alexis K. Wodtke
Attorney At Law
CONSUMER FEDERATION OF CALIFORNIA (CFC)
520 S. EL CAMINO REAL, STE. 340
SAN MATEO CA 94402
(650) 375-7847
lex@consumercal.org
For: CONSUMER FEDERATION OF CALIFORNIA (CFC)
Edward W. O'Neill
DAVIS, WRIGHT, TREMAINE, LLP
ONE EMBARCADERO CENTER, SUITE 600
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94111-3834
(415) 276-6500
edwardoneill@dwt.com
|
Sean P. Beatty
Attorney At Law
COOPER, WHITE & COOPER, LLP
201 CALIFORNIA ST., 17TH FLOOR
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94111
(415) 433-1900
sbeatty@cwclaw.com
Doug Garrett
Vice President, Western Region Regulator
COX CALIFORNIA TELCOM, LLC, DBA COX COMM
2200 POWELL STREET, SUITE 1035
EMERYVILLE CA 94608-2618
(510) 923-6222
douglas.garrett@cox.com
Esther Northrup
COX COMMUNICATIONS
5159 FEDERAL BLVD.
SAN DIEGO CA 92105
(619) 266-5315
esther.northrup@cox.com
Betty Jo Toccoli
CSBRT/CSBA
6101 WEST CENTENALIA AVENUE,342
CULVER CITY CA 90230
(800) 350-2722
csba@pacbell.net
Carl K. Oshiro
Attorney At Law
CSBRT/CSBA
100 PINE STREET, SUITE 3110
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94111
(415) 927-0158
ckomail@pacbell.net
David J. Marchant
Attorney At Law
DAVIS WRIGHT TREMAINE LLP
ONE EMBARCADERO CENTER, STE. 600
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94111-3834
(415) 276-6500
davidmarchant@dwt.com
Norman A. Pedersen
HANNA AND MORTON LLP
444 SOUTH FLOWER STREET, SUITE 1500
LOS ANGELES CA 90071-2916
(213) 430-2510
npedersen@hanmor.com
|
William F. Dietrich
Attorney At Law
DIETRICH LAW
2977 YGNACIO VALLEY ROAD, 613
WALNUT CREEK CA 94598-3535
(415) 297-2356
dietrichlaw@earthlink.net
For: 280 Corridor Concerned Citizens
Daniel Kirshner
ENVIRONMENTAL DEFENSE FUND
5655 COLLEGE AVENUE, SUITE 304
OAKLAND CA 94618
(510) 658-8008
dkirshner@environmentaldefense.org
W. Lee Biddle
Attorney At Law
FERRIS & BRITTON
401 WEST A STREET, SUITE 1600
SAN DIEGO CA 92101
(619) 233-3131
lbiddle@ferrisbritton.com
Alan Ramo
GOLDEN GATE UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF LAW
ENVIRONMENTAL LAW AND JUSTICE CLINIC
536 MISSION ST.
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94105
(415) 442-6654
aramo@ggu.edu
A Davis
Assistant Regional Manager
GOLDEN STATE MOBILEHOME OWNERS LEAGUE
22 YOSEMITE RD.
SAN RAFAEL CA 94903
(415) 472-5111
Gregg Morris
GREEN POWER INSTITUTE
2039 SHATTUCK AVE., SUITE 402
BERKELEY CA 94704
(510) 644-2700
gmorris@emf.net
Irene K. Moosen
Attorney At Law
53 SANTA YNEZ AVENUE
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94112
(415) 587-7343
irene@igc.org
|
Enrique Gallardo
LATINO ISSUES FORUM
160 PINE STREET, SUITE 700
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94111
(415) 547-7550
enriqueg@lif.org
Sara Steck Myers
Attorney At Law
LAW OFFICES OF SARA STECK MYERS
122 - 28TH AVENUE
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94121
(415) 387-1904
ssmyers@att.net
Thomas R. Dill
President
LODI GAS STORAGE, LLC
23265 N. STATE RT. 99 W. FRONTAGE RD
ACAMPO CA 95220
(209) 368-9277
trdill@westernhubs.com
Louie De Carlo
Compliance Manager
MCI METRO ACCESS TRANSMISSION SERVICES
201 SPEAR STREET, 9TH FLOOR
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94105
louie.decarlo@mci.com
Richard Severy
MCI TELECOMMUNICATIONS CORPORATION
9TH FLOOR
201 SPEAR STREET
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94105
richard.b.severy@mci.com
Robert Munoz
MCI, INC.
707 17TH STREET, STE 4200
DENVER CO 80202
(303) 390-6642
robert.munoz@mci.com
Adam L. Sherr
Attorney At Law
QWEST COMMUNICATIONS CORPORATION
1600 7TH AVENUE, 3206
SEATTLE WA 98191-0000
(206) 398-2507
Adam.Sherr@qwest.com
|
Devra Wang
NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL
111 SUTTER STREET, 20TH FLOOR
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94104
(415) 875-6100
dwang@nrdc.org
For: NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL
Angela Torr
PACIFIC GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY
77 BEALE STREET, RM. 1058, B10A
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94105
(415) 973-6077
act6@pge.com
Deborah Shefler
PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY
77 BEALE STREET, B30A
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94105
(415) 973-2959
dss8@pge.com
Cynthia Schultz
Regulatory Operations Coordinator
PACIFICORP
825 NE MULTNOMAH, STE 800
PORTLAND OR 97232
(503) 813-6068
cynthia.schultz@pacificorp.com
Leigh K. Jordan
PARK WATER COMPANY
9750 WASHBURN ROAD
PO BOX 7002
DOWNEY CA 90241-7002
(562) 923-0711
leigh@parkwater.com
PUBLIC ADVOCATES, INC.
131 STEUART STREET, SUITE 300
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94105
(415) 431-7430
rmarcantonio@publicadvocates.org
|
Greg R. Gierczak
Executive Director-Regulatory
ROSEVILLE TELEPHONE COMPANY
PO BOX 969
ROSEVILLE CA 95678
g.gierczak@surewest.com
Palle Jensen
SAN JOSE WATER COMPANY
374 WEST SANTA CLARA ST.
SAN JOSE CA 95196
(408) 279-7970
palle_jensen@sjwater.com
Keith Epstein
SBC ADVANCED SOLUTIONS, INC.
1010 N. ST. MARYS ST., 14TH FL
SAN ANTONIO TX 78215
(210) 246-8629
kel671@txmail.sbc.com
Colin Petheram
Director-Regulatory
SBC CALIFORNIA
140 NEW MONTGOMERY ST., SUITE 1325
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94105
Keith W. Melville
Attorney At Law
SEMPRA ENERGY
101 ASH STREET
SAN DIEGO CA 92101
(619) 699-5039
kmelville@sempra.com
Vicki L. Thompson
Attorney At Law
SEMPRA ENERGY
101 ASH STREET HQ13
SAN DIEGO CA 92101
(619) 699-5130
vthompson@sempra.com
|
Marc Mihaly
Attorney At Law
SHUTE MIHALY & WEINBERGER LLP
396 HAYES STREET
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94102
(415) 552-7272
armi@smwlaw.com
Mary O. Simmons
SIERRA PACIFIC POWER COMPANY
RATES & REGULATORY AFFAIRS
6100 NEIL ROAD, P.O. BOX 10100
RENO NV 89520
(775) 834-5870
msimmons@sierrapacific.com
Laura Genao
Attorney At Law
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY
2244 WALNUT GROVE AVENUE
ROSEMEAD CA 91770
(415) 929-5530
laura.genao@sce.com
For: SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY
Bridget A. Jensen
Attorney At Law
SOUTHWEST GAS CORPORATION
5241 SPRING MOUNTAIN ROAD
LAS VEGAS NV 89193-8510
(702) 876-7396
bridget.branigan@swgas.com
Frank J. Maglietti
Specialist/Pricing And Tariffs
SOUTHWEST GAS CORPORATION
5241 SPRING MOUNTAIN ROAD
LAS VEGAS NV 89150-0002
frank.maglietti@swgas.com
Valerie J. Ontiveroz
Analyst/State Regulatory Affairs
SOUTHWEST GAS CORPORATION
5241 SPRING MOUNTAIN ROAD
LAS VEGAS NV 89150
(702) 876-7323
valerie.ontiveroz@swgas.com
Stephen M. Kukta
Counsel
SPRINT NEXTEL
201 MISSION STREET, SUITE 1400
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94105
(415) 572-8358
stephen.h.kukta@sprint.com
|
Keith Mccrea
Attorney At Law
SUTHERLAND, ASBILL & BRENNAN
1275 PENNSYLVANIA AVENUE, NW
WASHINGTON DC 20004-2415
(202) 383-0705
keith.mccrea@sablaw.com
Carrie Camarena
Attorney At Law
THE GREENLINING INSTITUTE
1918 UNIVERSITY AVE., 2ND FLOOR
BERKELEY CA 94704
(510) 926-4002
carriec@greenlining.org
For: THE GREENLINING INSTITUTE
Gillian Taylor
THE SIERRA CLUB
52 LA RANCHERIA
CARMEL VALLEY CA 93924
gtaylor@redshift.com
Robert Finkelstein
Attorney At Law
THE UTILITY REFORM NETWORK
711 VAN NESS AVE., SUITE 350
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94102
(415) 929-8876 X310
bfinkelstein@turn.org
John Galloway
UNION OF CONCERNED SCIENTISTS
2397 SHATTUCK AVENUE, SUITE 203
BERKELEY CA 94704
(510) 843-1872
jgalloway@ucsusa.org
For: UNION OF CONCERNED SCIENTISTS
Julia Levin
UNION OF CONCERNED SCIENTISTS
2397 SHATTUCK AVENUE, SUITE 203
BERKELEY CA 94704
(510) 843-1872
jlevin@ucsusa.org
Michael Shames
Attorney At Law
UTILITY CONSUMERS' ACTION NETWORK
3100 FIFTH AVENUE, SUITE B
SAN DIEGO CA 92103
(619) 696-6966
mshames@ucan.org
|
Connie D. Easterly
UTILITY DESIGN, INC.
15 GREEN STREET
MARTINEZ CA 94553-5126
(925) 952-9324
easterly@udi-tetrad.com
Roger L. Poynts
UTILITY DESIGN, INC.
5528 PACHECO BLVD.
PACHECO CA 94553-5126
(925) 674-0218
poynts@udi-tetrad.com
Jesus Roman
Asst. General Counsel
VERIZON
MAILCODE CA501LB
112 LAKEVIEW CANYON RD.
THOUSAND OAKS CA 91362
(805) 372-6233
jesus.g.roman@verizon.com
Elaine M. Duncan
Attorney At Law
VERIZON CALIFORNIA INC.
711 VAN NESS AVENUE, SUITE 300
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94102
(415) 474-0468
elaine.duncan@verizon.com
Jacque Lopez
VERIZON CALIFORNIA INC.
CA501LB
112 LAKEVIEW CANYON ROAD
THOUSAND OAKS CA 91362-3811
(805) 372-6664
jacque.lopez@verizon.com
Donald R. Ward
PO BOX 2173
ORCUTT CA 93457
(805) 937-4860
Raymond J. Czahar
Chief Financial Officer
WEST COAST GAS CO., INC.
9203 BEATTY DR.
SACRAMENTO CA 95826-9702
(916) 364-4100
westgas@aol.com
|
George
WOMEN'S ENERGY MATTERS
PO BOX 883723
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94188-3723
(510) 915-6215
wem@igc.org
********** STATE EMPLOYEE ***********
Kenneth L. Koss
Administrative Law Judge Division
RM. 5041
505 VAN NESS AVE
San Francisco CA 94102
(415) 703-1463
klk@cpuc.ca.gov
Steven Kotz
Administrative Law Judge Division
RM. 5112
505 VAN NESS AVE
San Francisco CA 94102
(415) 703-2437
kot@cpuc.ca.gov
********* INFORMATION ONLY **********
Katherine Carlin
280 CORRIDOR CONCERNED CITIZENS
1740 LEXINGTON AVENUE
SAN MATEO CA 94402
(650) 627-9997
katie@agnoli.com
Edward G. Poole
Attorney At Law
ANDERSON & POOLE
601 CALIFORNIA STREET, SUITE 1300
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94108-2818
(415) 956-6413
epoole@adplaw.com
For: Western Manufactured Housing Community Association
CALIFORNIA ENERGY MARKETS
517-B POTERERO AVE.
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94110
(415) 552-1764
cem@newsdata.com
|
Melissa W. Kasnitz
DISABILITY RIGHTS ADVOCATES
2001 CENTER STREET, THRID FLOOR
BERKELEY CA 94744-1204
(510) 451-8644
pucservice@dralegal.org
Donald C. Liddell P. C.
DOUGLASS & LIDDELL
2928 2ND AVENUE
SAN DIEGO CA 92103
(619) 993-9096
liddell@energyattorney.com
For: DOUGLASS & LIDDELL
Richard Mccann
M. CUBED
2655 PORTAGE BAY, SUITE 3
DAVIS CA 95616
(530) 757-6363
rmccann@umich.edu
Audrey Chang
NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL
111 SUTTER STREET, 20TH FLOOR
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94104
(415) 875-6100
achang@nrdc.org
For: NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL
Karen Forsgard
PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY
77 BEALE STREET, B10A
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94105
(415) 973-6069
kaf4@pge.com
For: PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY
Law Department File Room
PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY
PO BOX 7442
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94120-7442
cpuccases@pge.com
Leslie Danielson
PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY
77 BEALE STREET, B10A
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94105
lad1@pge.com
For: PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY
|
Jon Welner
PAUL HASTINGS JANOFSKY & WALKER LLP
55 SECOND STREET, 24TH FLOOR
SAN FRANCISCO CA 94105-3441
(415) 856-7207
jonwelner@paulhastings.com
Lisa Browy
Regulatory Case Administrator
SAN DIEGO GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY
101 ASH STREET, CP32D
SAN DIEGO CA 92101
(858) 654-1566
lbrowy@semprautilities.com
Central Files
SAN DIEGO GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY
8330 CENTURY PARK COURT, CP31E
SAN DIEGO CA 92123
(858) 654-1240
centralfiles@semprautilities.com
For: SEMPRA ENERGY UTILITIES
Case Administration
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY
2244 WALNUT GROVE AVENUE, ROOM 370
ROSEMEAD CA 91770
case.admin@sce.com
For: SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY
Case Administration
Law Department
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY
2244 WALNUT GROVE AVENUE, ROOM 370
ROSEMEAD CA 91770
(626) 302-4875
case.admin@sce.com
Lorraine A. Kocen
VERIZON CALIFORNIA INC.
112 S. LAKEVIEW CANYON ROAD, CA501LS
THOUSAND OAKS CA 91362-3831
(805) 372-6945
Lorraine.Kocen@verizon.com
For: VERIZON CALIFORNIA INC.
|
(END OF APPENDIX C)
11 The updated service list will be published at the Commission's Internet site; when serving documents, parties must use the list as published on the date of service.
